Ambiguities in the Lives of Children: Postmodern Views on the History and Historiography of Childhood in English Canada
Abstract
Ambiguity is certainly instructive in that it reveals‐ that the problem itself persists at the heart of the solution presumably given to it.’ 1 1’George Canguilhem, The Normal and the Pathological (New York. Zone Books, 1391) p. 76. Childhood is an historical and social category wrought with ambivalence. The history and the historiography of childhood in English Canada is reviewed in terms of changes in the domain assumptions which serve as a normative basis for adult child interaction and social policies. Historical narratives reflect changing perceptions of children through tropes. This study traces the tropes, or poetic understructure, of the narratives of childhood in Canada from their origins in English Poor Laws to the present. Children have historically been viewed largely in terms of metaphors. Children have represented either ineptness and dependence, or progress and human potential. At the end of the nineteenth century, childhood came to be identified in a metonymic sense, as a “thing in itself. The scientific child study movement synthesized a synecdochal model of childhood in the 1920s and 1930s. The modern child was to be nurtured, manipulated and perfected in order to fit newly framed adult standards of normalcy. In conclusion, the invention of childhood has been composed of trends which are contradictory, the essence of irony.