Schooling, organisation of the constitutional monarchy and the education of citizens (Brazil, 1822–1889)
Abstract
The objective of this article is to analyse the process of institutionalisation of public elementary schooling associated with the political organisation of the constitutional monarchy and the legislation regarding citizen rights and prerogatives in Brazil, especially in the province of Minas Gerais, during the nineteenth century. During this century, two characteristics in Brazil were significant: the existence of a constitutional monarchy from 1822 to 1889 and the continuity of slavery until 1888. Paradoxically, the development of the idea of citizen rights and duties, and steps taken to provide access to elementary school, coexisted with these characteristics. Education was considered a decisive step for the effective implementation of social change. My hypothesis is that the new political structure also led to a new dynamic of interdependence between rulers and ruled as constituents of the civilising process underway. Even so, this was an extremely tense process whose results fell short of those intended by the elite governing authorities; by the end of the nineteenth century, Brazil still had an illiteracy rate of 85%. In order to understand this situation, an analysis of situations and conflicts present in the process of implementing public elementary education is essential. Important among these are poverty, ethnic and racial prejudice, political decentralisation of elementary education administration, disputes among local politicians and the definition of teachers as public servants and funding of school supplies. For this study, documents consulted included government reports, laws, official letters and correspondence among government officers, parents and teachers. The main theoretical concepts used were Norbert Elias’ sociological theory for analysis of the civilising process and the dynamics of interdependence in the organisation of society, and the characteristics of postcolonial society discussed by Hilda Sabato, Marcelo Caruso and Miriam Dolhnikoff. Keywords: Schoolingcitizenshippublic educationconstitutional monarchyBrazil Notes 1Report that the Provincial Legislative Assembly of Minas Gerais presented an act to open the ordinary session in 1865, by the supreme magistrate Pedro de Alcântara Cerqueira Leite, president of stated province. Ouro Preto: Typografia do Minas Geraies, 1865, n. 8, 18–9. 2The end of the monarchy and the establishment of the republic was proclaimed on November 15, 1889. 3Until the middle of the eighteenth century, the first initiatives for teaching reading and writing were offered by religious orders, mainly by the Jesuits. Other initiatives were prescribed by the so-called Ordenamientos Filipinos (1603), which ordered the guardians of orphans to hire teachers; teachers were also occasionally hired by the municipal councils. The royal licence of 1759 set the historic framework for the beginning of state control over schools. 4We read: one hundred thousand “réis,” two hundred thousand “réis” and four hundred thousand “réis”. 5Gran Colombia and the United States are examples of this process. 6Norbert Elias, Introdução a Sociologia (Lisboa: Ediciones 70, 2005). 7Revista do Ensino, Ouro Preto: Typografia do Liberal Mineiro, 1886, 3. 8Title VIII: General disposals and guarantees of the civil and political rights of the Brazilian citizens (...) Article 179: The inviolability of the civil and political rights of the Brazilian citizens, who have for base the freedom, the individual security and the property, is guaranteed by the Constitution of the Empire in the following way (...): Proposition 32, The primary instruction is free for all citizens. J. Pinto, As Constituições do Brasil (Bahia: Imprensa Oficial, 1937). 9Cynthia Greive Veiga, Historia da Educação (São Paulo: Atica, 2007). 10José Ricardo Pires de Almeida, História da instrução Pública no Brasil, 1500 a 1889 (São Paulo: EDUC, 1889 [1889], p. 90. 11Maria Beatriz Nizza da Silva. O império luso-brasileiro, 1970–1822. Lisboa: Estampa, 1986. 12Brazil was divided into 20 provinces at the time. 13In the period 1822–1830, one thousand reis was equivalent to 40 pounds sterling (http://antonioluizcosta.sites.uol.com.br). Annual salaries can be estimated at around 500–1250 pounds. 14The Ministry of Education & Health of Brazil was not created until 1930, and it was only then that elementary education was legislated at the national level. 15Hilda Sabato, Soberania popular, cidadania, e nação na América Hispânica: a experiência republicana do século XIX, Almanak braziliense n. 9, Maio, 2009. 16Miriam Dolhnikoff, Representação na monarquia brasileira, Almanak braziliense n. 9, Maio, 2009, 42. 17Marcelo Caruso, Literacy and Suffrage: The Politicization of Schooling in Postcolonial Hispanic America (1810-1850), Paedagogica Historica 46, no. 4: 463–78. 18Even so, the exclusion of these social groups in civil society was a contentious issue in the constituency debate, as was the definition of being Brazilian (born in Brazil) and of being a Brazilian citizen (Dolhnikoff, Representação na monarquia brasileira). 19Hebe Mattos, Escravidão e cidadania no Brasil monárquico (Rio de Janeiro: Zahar, 2004). 20Instrucción Pública ½ box 4, envelop3 1. The majority of the petitions were signed “upon request.” 21Report from the president of the Minas Gerais province, the Illustrated and His Excellence, Dr. Alexandre Joaquim de Siqueira, at the opening of the extraordinary session of the Provincial Legislative Assembly on March 25, 1850. Ouro Preto, Typ. Social, 1850. 22Speech to the Provincial Legislative Assembly of Minas Gerais, at the opening of the ordinary session in 1842 by the Vice President of the Province, Herculano Ferreira Penna. Ouro Preto, Typ. Del Correio de Minas, 1842. 23Provincial Section, codex 232. 24Provincial Section, codex 233. 25Provincial Section, Instrucción Pública, caja 58, sobre 18. 26Instrucción Pública 1/2, box 01, envelope 54 27 Jornal O Normalista 1888, n.2, 2–3.