From Isolation and Stagnation to ‘Modern’ Mathematics in Iceland: a Reform or Confusion?
Abstract
At the beginning of the twentieth century, Iceland was under Danish rule. It was isolated in the middle of the North Atlantic, enjoying only little cultural exchange with other countries. A strong tradition of literacy and nurturing of literature flourished there, while knowledge in mathematics, natural sciences and technical matters was mainly confined to the few who attended the high school to become officials. Compulsory lower secondary education was formally established by a legislative act in 1946 and the high school was opened up with a centrally organized entrance examination. A number of new mathematics teachers were needed at the lower secondary level to meet these new education opportunities, while the teacher training programme provided only for primary education. A programme for secondary school teachers was established in 1951 but it produced too few teachers. A State Textbook Publishing House for the compulsory school level was kept with minimal funding and consequent lack of innovations in the field of learning material. In the mid‐1960s, increased pressure was felt on the school system from a massive expansion of demand for more and better education, resulting from a better economy and an increasing number of intellectuals criticizing the deficiencies of the school system. The OECD paradigm – that mathematical and technical education contributed to economic progress, and its support to an international ‘modern’ mathematics reform wave – reached Iceland under these conditions. In a couple of years, ‘modern’ mathematics was introduced at all school levels, with consequent turmoil that lasted a decade. Similar problems arose in Iceland to those in other countries; the set theoretical approach did not meet the expectations of the educators and parents complained that they did not understand their children’s homework. However, the reform brought new opportunities to teachers and a large amount of funds was allotted to curriculum development and publication of new teaching material. All things considered, the introduction of ‘modern’ mathematics to Iceland must be regarded as a reform in spite of the various problems it brought. Notes 1 Sigurðsson, Jón. “Um skóla á Íslandi.” In Af blöðum Jóns forseta, edited by Sverrir Jakobsson. Reykjavík: Hiðíslenska bókmenntafélag, 1994: 81–135. 2 Kjartansson, Helgi Skúli. Ísland á 20. öld. Reykjavík: Sögufélag, 2002: 158. 3 Sigurgeirsson, Ingvar, ed. Námsefni í 50 ár. Reykjavík: Námsgagnastofnun, 1987: 9. 4 Gjone, Gunnar. ‘Moderne matematikk’ i skolen. Internasjonale reformstrebelser og nasjonalt læreplanarbeid. Vol. I. Oslo, 1983: 8–59. 5 Ibid., 60–61. 6 Gjone, “Moderne matematikk,” Vol. II, 55. 7 Cooper, Barry. Renegotiating Secondary School Mathematics. A Study of Curriculum Change and Stability. London: Falmer Press, 1985. 8 OEEC. New Thinking in School Mathematics. Paris, 1961: 7. 9 Gjone, “Moderne matematikk,” Vol. II, 57. 10 Howson, G., K. Keitel, and J. Kilpatrick. Curriculum Development in Mathematics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982: 93–125. 11 Jónasson, Matthías, and Sveinbjörn Sigurjónsson. “Stutt skýrsla frá þinpgi O. E. E. C.” Menntamál 35, no. 1 (1962): 74–79. 12 Efnahagsstofnunin. Nokkur efnisatriði erinda og umræðna frá fundum um menntaáætlanagerð 2. og 3. júní, 1965. (A report from the Economics Institution: Several Items from Talks and Discussions in a Meeting on Educational Planning 2 and 3 June 1965). Reykjavík, 1965. 13 Gíslason, Dr Gylfi, Minister of Education in 1956–1971. Telephone interview, 17 January 2002. 14 Björnsson, Sveinbjörn. “Samanburður á námi í stærðfræði, eðlisfræði og efnafræði í dönskum, norskum og íslenskum unglinga‐ og gagnfræðaskólum.” Menntamál 39, no. 2 (1966): 101–21. 15 Arnlaugsson, Guðmundur. Tölur og mengi. Reykjavík: Ríkisútgáfa námsbóka, 1966. 16 Alðingistíðindi A1 1966. [Parliament Report]. þingskjal 1 Reykjavík, 1966: 99. 17 Niss, Mogens. “Goals of Mathematics Teaching.” In International Handbook of Education. Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1996: 34. 18 Menntamálaráðuneytið, skólarannsóknadeild. Endurskoðun námsefnis á grunnskólastigi. Skýrsla um starfsemi skólarannsóknadeildar. Reykjavík: 1978. 19 Stjórnartíðindi [Governmental Report], 1967–1971. Financial budget. 20 Menntamálaráðuneytið, skólarannsóknadeild. Endurskoðun námsefnis á grunnskólastigi. Skýrsla um starfsemi skólarannsóknadeildar. Reykjavík: 1978. 21 Lárusson, Hörður. Stærðfræði handa 7, 8, og 9. bekk grunnskóla. Reykjavík: Ríkisútgáfa námsbóka, 1971–1974. 22 Gíslason, Kristinn. ‘Nýja stærðfræðin’ í barnaskólum Reykjavíkur. (A written report in the possession of the author), 1978. 23 Kristjánsdóttir, Anna. Um stærðfræðinám í grunnskóla skólaárið 1977–1978 (A letter to mathematics teachers). Iceland Ministry of Education. Reykjavík: School Research Department, 1977. 24 Sveinsson, Magnús. “Hugleiðingar um stærðfræðinám fyrr og síðar.” Menntamál 45, no. 2 (1972): 88–91. 25 Gjone, “Moderne matematikk,” Vol. I, 53. 26 Niss, “Goals of Mathematics Teaching,” 13. 27 Kjartansson, Helgi Skúli. Ísland á 20. öld. Reykjavík: Sögufélag, 2002: 158.