Eugenics, Orientalism and Classical Education: The Darker Side of the Western Tradition
Abstract
The history of philosophical systems of thought is more often than not a history of political opportunism and ideological manipulation. The history of eugenics and its impact upon the nineteenth—and twentieth—centuries is very much a history of ideas in action, of dangers covert and overt. Eugenics was not the peculiar outcome of the course of events over the last two and one-half centuries. This paper will explore the origins of the 'eugenic ideal' which can be located in an Hellenic cultural value system and its intellectually combative connection with Plato and Aristotle. This paper will also consider the peculiar relationship of Western classical ideals to the emergence of eugenics in the nineteenth—and early twentieth—centuries.Distant prejudices reinforced by culture, tradition and the propagation of myths and values which promoted the preferred self-images of social elites were potent forces in antiquity. The emergence of eugenics in Western and Eastern European societies is a continuing case-in-point. In the end, whether we are inquiring into the worlds of the Greek city-states (poleis) or nineteenth—and twentieth—century modern and contemporary historical experiences, we are dealing with a volatile mix of ideas.Social engineering within the imagined nation-state, polis or 'tribal community' is inherently perilous. The idea of a preferred, more perfect and superior group, class, tribe or state of people (these are not mutually exclusive notions) is historically antique and contemporaneously vicious. Whilst such ideas are time-worn, they nonetheless remain historically potent. It is this historical and trans-historical character of the potency of eugenic ideas which should be addressed.