historyofeducation.eu · Journals

L'INVENTION DE LA PRISON MODERNE

Marie‐Sylvie Dupont‐Bouchat
Paedagogica Historica · 1990 · 26(2) · pp. 63-98

Abstract

Since M. Foucault's book “Surveiller et punir” (Paris, 1975) the recent works published in the Anglo‐Saxon countries by M. Ignatieff, “A Just Measure of Pain: the Penitentiary in the Industrial Revolution” (New York, 1978), in the Netherlands by P. Spierenburg, “The Emergence of Carceral Institutions: Prisons, Galleys and Lunatic Asylums. 1500‐1900” (Rotterdam, 1984) and in France by J. Petit, “Ces peines obscures. La prison pénale en France. 1780–1875” (Paris, 1990) allow to tackle once again the problem of imprisonment which opposes the theories on criminal law and the realities of penitentiary practices, by reconciling the history of ideas with that of social facts and institutions. The Belgian model–little studied and relatively unknown–is worth being examined not only in the light of the discussions on the penal system reform in Europe at the end of the 18th century, but also in relationship with the specific traditions in the Spanish Netherlands in the 16th and 17th centuries and the Austrian Netherlands in the 18th century. The control over poverty and the repression of vagrancy during the 16th, 17th and 18th centuries are at the core of the debate on imprisonment. The struggle against vagrancy initiated since the edicts of Charles the Fifth in 1515, led to a hesitation during three centuries between taking measures of assistance or measures of repression (B. Geremek, “La potence ou la pitié” (Paris, 1987)). This issue discloses two trends which are at the same time opposing and complementary: the social import (assistance: hospital) and the penal import (repression: the gallows). Between these two models there is a third one: the workhouse (tuchthuis, spinnenhuis) which became widely common in the Netherlands at the end of the 16th century (Amsterdam, 1596; Antwerp, 1613; Brussels, 1623; Ghent, 1627). But as long as the penal system was closely linked to the idea of corporal punishment, imprisonment remained an administrative measure without judicial intervention. The Belgian invention of the modern prison system consisted precisely of the combination of the two models proposed by Vilain XIIII, an economist, in Gent in 1771 (Mémoire sur la manière de corriger les malfaiteurs et les fainéants pour les rendre utiles à eux‐mêmes et à l'Etat) and by Goswin de Fierlant, a jurist, in Brussels during that same year (Mémoire sur les insuffisances et inconvénients des châtiments corporels et les avantages qu'il y aurait à les remplacer par des maisons de force). The modern prisons of Ghent (1775) and Vilvorde (1779) sprang from the combination of the economic model (the workhouse) and the penal model (the prison for the punishment of convicts). This new modern prison was vaunted by the English philanthropist Howard in 1778 and 1781, and used as a model by the French authorities when during the Empire (1801‐1803) the large central prisons were established.

VagrancyImprisonmentPrisonLunaticPrison reformSociologyPovertyPoor reliefCriminologyCapitalismSocial controlLawPolitical scienceHistoryEconomic history
Open in the catalogue DOI