historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Training a child in the way he/she should go. Cultural transmission and child-rearing within the home in England, circa 1550–1800

Linda A. Pollock
Paedagogica Historica · 1996 · 32 · pp. 79-103

Abstract

The history of childhood has been dominated by a few main issues: whether or not there was a concept of childhood in the past; the amount of affection and intimacy between parents and children in the past; the severity of the discipline imposed on children in the past. One group of historians claims that the domestic, nuclear, child-centered family emerged gradually in the eighteenth century; the other that parent-child relations throughout history can be characterized by continuity rather than change.There seems little hope of reconciling the protagonists in the debate. We need to begin our study of past childhood afresh, attempting to discern not the existence of otherwise of concepts of love or childhood, but rather how parents viewed their role and what it was they wished to achieve as they nurtured their children from infancy to adulthood.All societies face similar problems in bringing up their young: how to ensure that children will become responsible, productive, mature individuals, fully compatible with the culture into which they are born. Prior to the nineteenth century, the family was the main agent of cultural transmission, the school played a subsidiary role. Education in the past meant not just the acquisition of academic skills but the attainment of such factors as: self-discipline, the habits of good breeding, a thorough grounding in religion, a set of moral values. When parents discussed the education of their offspring, they meant this in the widest possible sense. It is in this sense that the term "education" is used here.This article discusses the socialization of children within the domestic environment in England from the mid-sixteenth to the nineteenth centuries. It identifies the main goals of parents in the past and how they set about achieving their aims. Close attention is paid to sex differences: both the different perspectives of mothers and fathers and also the different experiences of boys and girls. How child-rearing regimes were affected by rank and status, is exemplified as well. The complicated relationship between advice literature and individual behaviour is explained by comparing the goals set out in the prescriptive literature with the actual aims of parents as outlined in their diaries, autobiographies, letters, and other sources. Finally, the amount of change in child-rearing practices is examined.A detailed analysis of parental aspirations and how they were or were not achieved will help advance the by now stale historiographical debate beyond such unhelpful questions as "Did parents love their children in the past?".

Training (meteorology)Child rearingSociologyCultural transmission in animalsTransmission (telecommunications)PsychologyDevelopmental psychologyGeographyTelecommunicationsComputer science
Open in the catalogue DOI