La Reformpädagogik, controverses autour d’une histoire et d’un concept
Abstract
In the past few years, several research projects published in German-speaking countries have tried to cast new light on the history and interpretation of the German “new education”. The traditional interpretation, dominated by the historiography of Herman Nohl and his disciples, has been challenged in several respects: one must go beyond the “pro dome” case made up of the many studies on this theme and question the idea that the German “new education” is defined by its theoretical homogeneity and by its power to innovate. Far from the fact that its first characteristic is that it broke with the past, the German “new education” remains in the direct line against which it had fought. Moreover, it is thought that it did not profit from the monopoly of the reform and that this category would apply to any pedagogical ventures that hesitates between the will to transform reality and the wish to comply with the demands of that same reality. But, when looking at the German “new education”, should one not first distinguish between historical aspects and educational aspects, that is to say, two aspects of the “Reform-pädagogik”, the latter still being relevant today? Consequently, the concept of “Reformpädagogik” opens the door to other definitions and so can specify a form of modernity.