historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Rise, fall, and resurrection of educational technologies: the curious case of Decroly in Spain

María del Mar del Pozo Andrés
Paedagogica Historica · 2024 · 60(1) · pp. 18-39

Abstract

This article, delivered as one of two keynote lectures at the International Standing Conference for the History of Education (ISCHE) in Milan in September 2022, offers an example of an autosociobiographical approach to the history of education, in which the life story of the author is entangled with the collective movement of a generation of pedagogues, to capture “the lived dimension of History”, quoting the winner of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Literature, Annie Ernaux. It describes the journey of the “centres of interest”, a pedagogical technology closely linked to the Belgian educational reformer and scientist Ovide Decroly, which evoked positive and negative emotions among the Spanish pedagogical explorers who visited Decroly Schools in the first decades of the twentieth century. This technology found its way into material school culture in Spain, grew into a veritable mania, but died an early death after the Spanish Civil War. It returned in a new guise, the “globalised didactic units”, thanks to textbooks written by the first post-war generations of pedagogues, who rediscovered Decroly’s ideas, and developed an emotional bond with these textbooks, and ‒ without knowing it ‒ also with their pre-war predecessors.KEYWORDS: Decrolyeducational technologycentres of interestglobalised didactic unitsautosociobiographical approachSUBJECT CLASSIFICATION CODES: Educationhistory Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.Notes1 The author borrowed the phrase “curious case” from the 2008 film “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”, based on a short story by Scott Fitzgerald. Benjamin Button was born looking like an elderly man and died at the age of 84 but physically looking like a child. I find a parallelism with the evolution of the Decroly techniques in Spain, which were rejected in their origins because they evoked images of nineteenth-century classrooms in the first Spanish travellers to Brussels and presented 60 years later as the latest and most revolutionary educational reform.2 María del Mar del Pozo Andrés, “Channels by which the International Pedagogic Movement of the New School Spread Throughout Spain (1889–1936)”, in Conference Papers for the 9th Session of the International Standing Conference for the History of Education, History of International Relations in Education, Volume 2, ed. Sandor Komlósi (Pécs: Janus Pannonius University, 1987), 101–17.3 María del Mar del Pozo Andrés, “La Escuela Nueva en España: Crónica y semblanza de un mito”, Historia de la Educación. Revista Interuniversitaria 22–23 (2003–2004): 317–46.4 María del Mar del Pozo Andrés, “Desde L’Ermitage a la Escuela Rural Española: Introducción, Difusión y Apropiación de los ‘Centros de Interés’ decrolyanos (1907–1936)”, Revista de Educación, no. Extraordinario (2007): 143–66; and Carlos Menguiano-Rodríguez and María del Mar del Pozo-Andrés, “Appropriating the New: Progressive Education and its (Re)constructions by Spanish schoolteachers”, Paedagogica Historica (2021). https://doi.org/10.1080/00309230.2021.1915346.5 Rob Boddice, The History of Emotions (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2018); Barbara H. Rosenwein and Riccardo Cristiani, What is the History of Emotions? (Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2018); Katie Barclay, Sharon Crozier-De Rosa, and Peter N. Stearns, Sources for the History of Emotions: A Guide (London: Routledge, 2020); and Bessie Dernikos, Nancy Lesko, Stephanie D. McCall, and Alyssa Niccolini, eds., Mapping the Affective Turn in Education: Theory, Research, and Pedagogy (London: Routledge, 2020).6 David J. Murray and Bahar Farahmand, “Gestalt Theory and Evolutionary Psychology”, in Psychology: theoretical-historical perspectives, ed. Robert W. Rieber and Kurt Salzinger (Washington DC: American Psychological Association, 1998), 255–87; and Anna Kathryn Kendrick, Humanising Childhood in Early Twentieth-Century Spain (Cambridge: Legenda, 2020), 33–61. In the last book the connections between the Gestalt theory and the globalisation are clearly made. The author bases her arguments on an exhaustive Spanish psychological and pedagogical literature from the 1920s and 1930s.7 Although the origin of the “centres of interest” goes back to Herbartianism, the term was used for the first time in North America. We can find reports from the early years of the twentieth century that refer to schools there organising their teaching of arts and crafts around broad themes called “centres of interest”. It was the Argentine pedagogue and feminist Ernestina López who introduced the term “centres of interest” in Spain in 1905, in an article that described an experience from the Hyannis School of Massachusetts. Ernestina A. López, “La enseñanza manual en los Estados Unidos”, La Escuela Moderna 15, no. 177 (1905): 852.8 Key works about Decroly are: Marc Depaepe, Frank Simon, and Angelo Van Gorp, “The Canonization of Ovide Decroly as a ‘Saint’ of the New Education”, History of Education Quarterly 53, no. 2 (2003): 224–49; Angelo Van Gorp, Tussen mythe en wetenschap: Ovide Decroly (1871–1932) (Leuven: Acco, 2005); Sylvain Wagnon, Ovide Decroly, un pedagogue de l´Education nouvelle, 1871–1932 (Bruxelles: P.I.E. Peter Lang, 2013); and Marc Depaepe, Frank Simon, and Angelo Van Gorp, Ovide Decroly (1871–1932): Une approche atypique? (Kingston, Canada: Queen’s University, 2022).9 Thomas Fallace, “Recapitulation Theory and the New Education: Race, Culture, Imperialism, and Pedagogy, 1894–1916”, Curriculum Inquiry 42, no. 4 (September 2012): 510–33; and Michael Hines and Thomas Fallace, “Pedagogical Progressivism and Black Education: A Historiographical Review, 1880–1957”, Review of Educational Research, 93, no. 3 (2023): 454–86.10 Pierre Bovet, “Ovidio Decroly”, Boletín de la Institución Libre de Enseñanza LVI, no. 870 (1932): 289–91.11 The educationalist Georges Rouma had written several scientific works in collaboration with Decroly and could speak Spanish fluently because of his pedagogical relationship with Bolivia; Alexis Sluys, principal of a Demonstration School and a Teachers Training College in Brussels, shared several educational spaces with Decroly, enjoyed a close relationship with the Spanish progressive educators, and visited Spain on several occasions; Arthur Nyns and Nicolas Smelten were schoolteachers and headmasters of the Brussels schools numbers 7 and 10 – where Decroly was school doctor – and received Spanish visitors in these institutions as early as in 1902.12 Brussels, “Ángel Llorca diaries of his travel in France and Belgium (1910–1912)”, Ángel Llorca Archive (Madrid: Foundation Ángel Llorca), 19 July 1911.13 Ángel Llorca García, La Escuela Primaria e Instituciones Complementarias de la Educación Popular en Francia, Bélgica, Suiza e Italia. Notas de viaje (Madrid: Lib. de los Sucesores de Hernando, 1912), 117–9.14 In the official report presented by the first group of Spanish schoolteachers that visited the Decroly schools in July 1911 with a state grant, the concept “centres of interest” was mentioned. The authorship of this concept was attributed to Decroly, and they considered it as something very new; however, they had been informed by some Belgian pedagogues that a comparable system was applied in the schools of the city of Marcinelle. Junta para Ampliación de Estudios e Investigaciones Científicas, Excursiones pedagógicas al extranjero. Memoria correspondiente a los grupos de maestros organizados en los años 1911 y 1912 (Madrid: Est. Tip. De Fortanet, 1913), 26. Nevertheless, in several local newspapers’ articles published by these schoolteachers we can observe many more variations. Most of them did not yet identify the Decroly curriculum organisation with the idea of centres of interest, nor did they identify the concept with his name. Thereby, one of these educators had named and exemplified one centre of interest experiment by “Margueritte Jacobs”, presumably Marguerite Jacobs-Pauwels, and she was not presented as a follower of the Decroly method. José María Andreu, “Notas de visita a algunas Escuelas de Francia, Bélgica y Suiza”, El Magisterio Gerundense, 11 June 1913, 40.Sidonio Pintado Arroyo was really the first and only schoolteacher to present the idea of centres of interest as something new and coined by Decroly. He was explaining them as yearly, monthly, or weekly periods of time in which a certain topic was developed by the children. He was also the first one to present Decroly as a “genius” and an “apostle”. His articles were published in several newspapers of the regions of Castilla and La Rioja between 1912 and 1915. See Sidonio Pintado, “Progresos pedagógicos. Institución del doctor Decroly”, El Norte de Castilla, 2 November 1913, 1.15 Ricardo Campillo, “Una visita a la Escuela Decroly”, Revista de Pedagogía 34 (1924): 367.16 Antonio Juan Onieva, Nuestro viaje de estudios al extranjero (Madrid: El Magisterio Español, 1926), 119.17 Emilio Sotelo Rey, Por la Europa Pedagógica (Ávila: Suc. de A. Jiménez, 1913), 85–8.18 Antonio Ballesteros, Las escuelas nuevas francesas y belgas (Madrid: Pub. de la Revista de Pedagogía, 1930), 85.19 Diario del grupo de Inspectores e Inspectoras enviado por la Junta de Ampliación de Estudios a Francia y Bélgica en pensión de dos meses, París-Bruselas, Vol. II (Madrid: JAE, 1922), 98.20 Lorenzo Miralles, “Cuestiones Pedagógicas. La enseñanza en el extranjero. Algunas notas acerca de la enseñanza de las ciencias experimentales en la escuela primaria, en Francia, en Bélgica y en Inglaterra”, El Radical. Diario Republicano, 17 April 7, 1910, 1; Valentín Ferrero García, “Viaje pedagógico a Francia, Bélgica y Suiza. Notas” (29 November 1912), JAE Archive, F-36.21 Brussels, “Ángel Llorca diaries of his travel in France and Belgium (1910–1912)”, Ángel Llorca Archive (Madrid: Foundation Ángel Llorca), 29 November 1912. .22 Ll. [Ángel Llorca], “Desde Bélgica. Diario de una excursión de maestros e inspectores”, Desde la Escuela y para la Escuela 5, no. 118 (1921): 71.23 Campillo, “Una visita a la Escuela Decroly”, 367.24 Rodolfo Llopis, “El doctor Decroly en España”, El Sol, 13 April 1926, 2.25 Jacobo Orellana Garrido, “La difusión del método Decroly”, La Escuela Moderna 37, no. 387 (1923): 921–3.26 Eduardo Canto, “Desde Bélgica. Notas rápidas”, El Magisterio Español 62, no. 8124 (1928): 715.27 As a paradigmatic example of an “educational pilgrimage”, see the trip done by Decroly himself together with Raymond Buyse. Marc Depaepe and Lieven D’hulst with the collaboration of Maartje Theuninck (2011). An Educational Pilgrimage to the United States. Un pèlerinage psycho-pédagogique aux États-Unis.: Travel Diary of Raymond Buyse, 1922. Carnet de voyage de Raymond Buyse, 1922 (Louvain: Leuven University Press, 2011).28 L.H. [Luis Huerta], “Libros. Psicología aplicada a la educación”, Boletín de la Asociación de Maestros de las Escuelas Nacionales de Madrid 4, no. 13 (1934): 29.29 José Martínez Aguilar, “Decroly”, Las Provincias, 18 December 1928, 9.30 José Xandri Pich, Cuatro meses en Francia y Bélgica (Madrid: Tip. Encomienda, 1923), 147.31 Cándido Solbes Oltra, “Estudio por el Maestro Nacional de la Escuela Jardín Altamira, Alicante” (15 March 1926), JAE Archive, S-92.32 Jesús Revaque, “El Doctor Decroly”, El Cantábrico, 25 September 1932, 1.33 To understand these descriptions, see Depaepe, Simon, and Van Gorp, “The Canonization”, 224–49.34 Ángel Aniceto Gracia Morales, “Diario del Maestro de Borceguillas (Segovia), del viaje al extranjero del año 1924, pensionado por el Estado, después de disuelto el grupo a que pertenecía, dirigido por el Sr. Valls”, (23/24 July 1924), JAE Archive, G-167.35 Per Abbat, “Labor fecunda. Apostillas a una excursión astur”, La Voz de Asturias, 25 June 1926, 8.36 María Luisa Navarro de Luzuriaga, “Turismo Pedagógico. La Educación Nueva”, La Gaceta Literaria 1, no. 21 (1927): 4.37 De Coster, Depaepe, Simon and Van Gorp stated that Decroly “is sometimes called the ‘European Dewey’ in the United States” mentioning a book of 1929 in which this description is used. Tom De Coster, Marc Depaepe, Frank Simon and Angelo Van Gorp, “Dewey in Belgium: A libation for modernity? Coping with his presence and possible influence”, in Inventing the modern self and John Dewey: Modernities and the travelling of pragmatism in education, ed. Thomas S. Popkewitz (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005), 95. But in Spain this expression was used as well and at an earlier date; see Antonio Ballesteros, El Método Decroly (Madrid: Publicaciones de la Revista de Pedagogía, 1928), 20–1.38 Juan Canals Huguet, “La Escuela de Verano de Barcelona”, Escuelas de España 2, no. 22 (1935): 476.39 “Por los niños anormales”, La Libertad, 24 February 1928, 2.40 Epifania San Julián Sáizar, “Viaje de estudio al extranjero. V”, Suplemento a La Escuela Moderna 37, no. 3315 (1928): 1410.41 Xandri, Cuatro meses, 165.42 Manuel Díaz Rozas, “Diario de Viaje. Resumen de Trabajo” (30 May and 8 June, 1930), JAE Archive, D-41.43 Florentino Rodríguez y Rodríguez, El método Decroly (Madrid: Junta para Ampliación de Estudios e Investigaciones Científico, 1925), 318.44 There was a kind of competition between the Spanish Decrolyans to see who was going to publish the first works of Decroly in Spain. Pedro Rosselló was writing to him: “ça a été une joie et une deception en même temps d’apprendre que votre brochure avec monsieur Boon et que vous nous aviez promis pour notre collection de l’‘Asociación Española Instituto J.J. Rousseau’ était deja [sic] traduite en Espagnol … Vous n’avez pas quelque’autre petite brochure a publier a coté de celles de Mr. Claparède et Bovet deja [sic] parues?”, Pedro Rosselló to Ovide Decroly, Madrid, 20 March 1922, Centre d’Études Decrolyennes, Uccle (Belgium). The “brochure” mentioned by Pedro Rosselló was Vers l’École rénovée, published by Ovide Decroly and Gérard Boon in 1921 in Bruxelles and in 1922 in Madrid, from a translation made by Sidonio Pintado. Ovide Decroly and Gérard Boon, Hacia la Escuela renovada. Una primera etapa, trans. Sidonio Pintado (Madrid: La Lectura, 1922).45 He was also the first translator to Spanish of the pedagogical ideas of Decroly. Dr. Decroly and Mlle. Monchamp, La iniciación a la actividad intelectual y motriz por los juegos educativos. Contribución a la pedagogía de los niños y de los irregulares, trans. and ed. Jacobo Orellana Garrido (Madrid: Francisco Beltrán, 1919).46 He also translated several books about the Decroly method, the first of them a work of Gérard Boon, Essai d’application de la Méthode Decroly dans l’Enseignement primaire (1924), that includes some lectures of Decroly to the Belgian teachers. Gérard Boon, Aplicación del método Decroly a la enseñanza primaria y la instrucción obligatoria, trans. and ed. Rodolfo Tomás y Samper (Madrid: Francisco Beltrán, 1926). In the prologue Tomás y Samper had written an extensive account of the Decroly life and method, and he was worried that the Belgian doctor would be angry with him “par le stile si peu brillant que j’emploie en parlant de vous”, and that he was afraid that Decroly could understand because “vous lisez déjà l’espagnol”. Rodolfo Tomás y Samper to Ovide Decroly, 25 March 1926, Centre d’Études Decrolyennes, Uccle (Belgium).47 Sidonio Pintado Arroyo, Decroly. Biografía, ideas Pedagógicas, Bibliografía (Madrid: El Magisterio Español, 1924).48 Louis Dalhem, El método Decroly aplicado a la escuela, trans. and ed. Jacobo Orellana Garrido and Sidonio Pintado Arroyo (Madrid: La Lectura, 1924), 7. Dalhem’s book was based on experiments in Brussels schools and was considered a handbook for Decroly teachers.49 Ibid., 215–81. The objective of including this chapter was to encourage the Spanish schoolteachers to experiment with the Decroly method in their classrooms.50 He was also the translator of the famous book by Amélie Hamaïde about the Decroly method as she had applied it in the schools of Brussels prior to her l’Ermitage experience. Amélie Hamaïde, El método Decroly, trans. and ed. Sidonio Pintado Arroyo (Madrid: Francisco Beltrán, 1923).51 Depaepe, Simon, and Van Gorp, “The Canonization”, 248.52 Anna Rubiés to Ovide Decroly, Barcelona, 31 December 1927, Centre d’Études Decrolyennes, Uccle (Belgium).53 Ibid.54 They wrote the following books about their experience: Ana Rubiés, Aplicación del método Decroly a la enseñanza primaria (Madrid: Pub. de la Revista de Pedagogía, 1929); Ana Rubiés Monjonell, Experiencias didácticas (Madrid: Pub. de la Revista de Pedagogía, 1934); Ana Rubiés Monjonell, Lectura-escritura global. Cuatro años de experiencias (Barcelona: Bosch, 1938); Federico Doreste Betancor, Metodología de la lectura y la escritura (Madrid, Pub. de la Revista de Pedagogía, 1933).55 To know more about other ways of defining or using the notion of “Decrolyan”, see De Coster, Depaepe, Simon, and Van Gorp. “Dewey in Belgium”, 85–109; and Angelo Van Gorp, “‘Like air bricks on earth’: Notes on developing a research agenda regarding the post-war legacy of new education”, Espacio, Tiempo y Educación 7, no. 1 (2020), 7–25.56 José Xandri Pich, La vida en la Escuela. Ensayo de adaptación de un método científico de enseñanza. First Grade (Madrid: Yagües, 1928); José Xandri Pich, de Grade and I and II (Madrid: Yagües, 1928); José Xandri Pich, Grade and Grade I and II (Madrid: Yagües, Ballesteros, El Método Decroly. In this book for the first time a report was presented about the of the Decroly method in the Spanish had the Belgian doctor that he had to de la a following Antonio to Ovide Decroly, 31 December 1928, Centre d’Études Decrolyennes, Uccle Rodolfo Llopis, La pedagogía de dos (Madrid: La Lectura, The newspapers published the – and ‒ that Decroly himself was this book into because he his pedagogical ideas to be in the the made by Rodolfo en el de Rodolfo El 3 1928, Rodolfo informed Decroly that he would a and in the first of and that he would be to speak about the Decroly method. But he film de and avec pour The last was as a of that could be used to the between Decroly and Rodolfo to Ovide Decroly, Madrid, 2 Centre d’Études Decrolyennes, Uccle y de la en Decroly 2 no. This been of the de et de in in a Revista de Psicología Pedagogía no. (1935): The of a schoolteacher is very well in la Escuela e a las del El Magisterio Español no. José María “La en la Escuela. de un El Magisterio Español no. (1932): José María “El no. (1935): and El de 5, no. (1934): San El Magisterio Español no. (1932): López, “El y la Escuela El Magisterio Español no. (1932): San “El de y de El Magisterio no. (1934): and y “La enseñanza por el El Magisterio Español no. (1932): José en de 20 July “Una El Magisterio Español no. (1932): y de las in Metodología de la ed. del y pedagógico del de la pedagogía Ibid., Ibid., Ibid., y no. Ibid., Review of the book by Ovide Decroly and Amélie Hamaïde, El y la en el año de la escuela Decroly, Escuelas de España 10 (1934): The of in the School The University of Press, La del Método en la Enseñanza trans. and ed. María (Madrid: La Lectura, In the prologue she that she had with the a of in the of Madrid, a progressive school where he had applied the method with the Kendrick, Humanising and en la Escuela. Una de Escuelas de España no. 25 and and en la Escuela. Una de La Escuelas de España no. of and of in the of the School Curriculum (New York: Teachers College University, A short of the Decrolyans Sidonio Pintado, Federico Anna Rubiés, José Xandri, Antonio and Rodolfo can be found in Juan de de y de e Historia Institución el – and Jacobo see el y la Rodolfo Tomás y Samper see José El pedagógico del Rodolfo Tomás y Samper del Español del y Una El 3 The was the only in Spain, which Spanish schoolteachers were to and with from the See José “Diario de María del de de la La y de de de Carlos que el Carlos las de en la escuela 1 de – Archive of the Teachers Training College of de University Archive of the José See the of this and of these in and María José Martínez the of Spanish School A for the of the and School History of Education no. María and de September Pozo Notes in by del Pozo of and of University of Madrid, Pozo Arthur J. and El de de trans. I from the in Arthur J. and of (New York: and La de la Educación, ed. J. didácticas en la enseñanza de las 5, no. 34 ed. de María y de la Educación Nueva”, This article, published in the of the the of the was based more on the ideas of It can be as a kind of the pedagogical that she at the she rejected the origin of the of Decroly and some but – following – she that they were by the educational to new into the school based on the emotions and the psychological of the María del Mar del Pozo and “The of the New Education Movement in the Paedagogica Historica 42, no. Juan Manuel García, y 7, no. 3 and Juan Manuel García, al estudio del de no. de la de y no. Un de Educación de El de March de un Una del 2 April Jesús de un Memoria de la David and “The of it been to American Educational no. 3 I this concept from the winner of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Literature, Annie Ernaux. called her of writing which can be as the of her life story with the collective movement of a in an to capture “the lived dimension of Annie The trans. (London: del Pozo and de Rodríguez, del Pozo and y el de Rodríguez, and del Pozo and y el de Rodríguez, and e de Rodríguez, on del Mar del Pozo del Mar del Pozo been a in Theory and History of Education at the University of where she a in she is of the Antonio of Education In she was as of the Spanish for the History of Education been a of the of the International Standing Conference for the History of Education (ISCHE) of research are history of education, and of educational the New Education the of in the of in education, history of education, and history of school most book and del Pozo the of Education De

Sociology
Open in the catalogue DOI