historyofeducation.eu · Journals

A forced but passionate marriage: The changing relationship between past and present in Dutch history education 1945–1979

Alexander Albicher
Paedagogica Historica · 2012 · 48(6) · pp. 840-858

Abstract

Although the history of history education is an under-researched topic worldwide, the international literature about history education contains a clear image of the historical development of the school subject. This image basically consists of a sharp dichotomy between traditional history education, which was largely insensitive to topical affairs and focused on tradition; and modern history education, which placed topical affairs at the centre of attention and critically engaged pupils in the study of history. Despite being very pervasive, this image does not do justice to the complex relationship between past and present in history education. In this article I will attempt to reassess this one-dimensional image by examining the changing relationship between past and present in Dutch history textbooks published between 1945 and 1979. More specifically, the analysis concentrates on the question of how these textbooks dealt with matters of proximity and distance on multiple levels, and how this affected the relationship between past and present in the course of time. Keywords: history of history educationhistory text bookshistoriographyThe Netherlands Notes 1For a discussion of Decroly’s ideas in relation to history education, see Joop Toebes, History: A Distinctive Subject?, 9–11. 2<-!!-> 3From the meeting abstracts it became clear that the Dutch historians Enno van Gelder and Jan Willem Berkelbach van der Sprenkel served as examples. J.A.J. Jousma, H.J. Nannen and B.W. Schaper, “Een poging tot omschrijving van de stof voor het gymnasiaal eindexamen in de geschiedenis”, Weekblad voor Gymnasiaal en Middelbaar onderwijs 42 (1950): 1023–1029. It was not clear, however, whether they were inspired by the academic work of Van Gelder and Berkelbach van der Sprenkel, or by their textbooks. The concept of cultural history used by Wereld in wording might be compared to what Peter Burke, in What is Cultural History? (Cambridge and Malden: Polity Press, 2008) 7–13, characterised as “classic cultural history”, namely, “painting the portrait of an age”. 4<-!!-> 5The use of historical documents in history education was not an entirely new phenomenon. Separate collections of reading texts were available that could be used in history class, such as W.L.D. van den Brink, Uit middeleeuwse tijden: cultuurhistorisch leesboek voor gymnasium en HBS (Baarn: Versluys, 1900). However, judged by the debate on the goals for history education, it was very unlikely that these texts were used as an exercise in the construction of history. That textbooks from this period incorporated these texts in the main text was a novelty, but I doubt whether the opinion of textbook authors towards the issue fundamentally changed during this period. 6<-!!-> 7Rijpma, Ontwikkelingsgang, vol. 3, 112–120. 8<-!!-> 9Reinsma, Fundamenten, vol. 1, 2. 10<-!!-> 11Novem, Wereld, vol. 3, 232. 12<-!!-> 13Hermann W. von der Dunk, “Holland: The shock of 1940”, Journal of Contemporary History 2, No. 1 (1967): 169–182. 14<-!!-> 15Rijpma, Ontwikkelingsgang, vol. 3, 316–336; Blonk, Leerboek, vol. 3, 388–403. It was only towards the end of the 1970s, but especially since the 1980s, that this trauma became noticeable in textbooks and the wider public debate. See, for example, Frank van Vree, In de schaduw van Auschwitz: Herinneringen, beelden, geschiedenis (Groningen: Historische Uitgeverij, 1995); and Dienke Hondius, Oorlogslessen: Onderwijs over de oorlog sinds 1945 (Amsterdam: Bert Bakker, 2010). 16<-!!-> 17Reinsma, Fundamenten, vol. 3, 158–159. 18<-!!-> 19Novem, Wereld, vol. 3, 5. 20<-!!-> 21For an argument in favour of Contemporary History, see P.A.M. Geurts, “Pleidooi voor onderwijs in de eigentijdse geschiedenis”, Publicaties van het Katholiek Paedagogisch Bureau ten behoeve van het VHMO 15 (Den Bosch: Malmberg, 1962). Other teachers were not so much opposed to Contemporary History as to an over-accentuation of this period in relation to earlier periods. See Fontaine, “Verslag van de historische conferentie op de Pietersberg te Oosterbeek op vrijdag 7 en zaterdag 8 oktober 1960”, Kleio 2, No. 2 (1961): 14–16; and C.W. Van Voorst van Beest, “Pleidooi tegen ongeproportioneerd onderwijs in de eigentijdse geschiedenis”, Kleio 4, No. 3 (1963): 7–9. The pressure upon history education to pay more attention to Contemporary History or, more specifically, to the Second World War, came from public figures such as the director of the Dutch Institute for War Documentation, Lou de Jong, and institutions such as the Polemological Institute, but also from politicians and the ministry of education itself. In any event, the issue was debated in Parliament and brought up at each Annual Commemoration Day. 22<-!!-> 23This shift to central (written) exams applied to all school subjects, but the opposition was particularly fierce in the field of history education. It took more than a decade before the exams were actually implemented. 24<-!!-> 25Wim F. Kalkwiek, ed. Geschiedenis in onderwerpen: Aspect van wereldoriëntatie (Amsterdam: Meulenhoff Educatief, 1975–1979); W.J.M. Boonekamp, F.A. Kraat and W.H. Mannesse, Intrada-Fuga-Coda (Groningen: Wolters-Noordhoff, 1968–1970); and the new edition of Wereld in wording, which was transformed in a four-volume semi-concentric method after 1968. 26<-!!-> 27For general information about the thematic approach in Germany and The Netherlands, see Geurts, “De thematische methode in het geschiedenisonderwijs”, Kleio didactica, vol. 1 (Den Haag: VGN, 1964); Piet van der Meulen, “Exemplarisch of thematisch?,” Kleio 8, No. 1 (1967): 4–7; Joachim Rohlfes, “Exemplarischer Geschichtsunterricht”, in Klaus Bergmann, ed. Handbuch der geschichtsdidaktik (Düsseldorf: Schwann, 1985), 256–258; and Toebes, Geschiedenis: een vak apart? (Meppel: Krips repro, 1981), 52–58. For the UK, see: Peter Carpenter, History Teaching: The Era Approach (Cambridge: Spottiswoode, Ballantyne & Co., 1964), mainly 37–48; and John A. Fairley, Patch History and Creativity (London: Longman, 1970). 28<-!!-> 29The best indication could be found in the many scrawls and scribbles of pupils and teachers that I encountered in the margins of old textbooks, containing messages such as “learn”, “just read” or “skip passage”. A closer study of these and other “user comments” would offer interesting insights into the way these textbooks were used in the classroom. 30<-!!-> 31First edition of Novem, Wereld, vol. 3, 74–75. 32<-!!-> 33Novem, Wereld, vol. 3, 129. The authors recommended “a mild form of psychological counseling” to facilitate this modernisation process. 34<-!!-> 35Boonekamp, Fuga, 98–138. 36<-!!-> 37Kalkwiek, Geschiedenis, vol. 1, 60; Boonekamp, Intrada, 61–62. 38<-!!-> 39Kalkwiek, Geschiedenis, vol. 3, 88–113. 40<-!!-> 41Kalkwiek, Geschiedenis, vol. 4/5, 80–82; Kalwiek, Geschiedenis, vol. 3, 90–99; and Novem, Wereld, vol. 3, 79–80. 42<-!!-> 43Jo Tollebeek, “De conjunctuur van het historisch besef”, in Bart Raymaekers and Gerd van Riel, eds. Horizonten van weten en kunnen (Leuven: Universitaire pers, 2001) 167–194; Maarten C. Brands, “Het verkeerde verleden”, BMGN 90 (1975): 171–188. 44<-!!-> 45Novem, Wereld, vol. 3, 105. 46<-!!-> 47Kalkwiek, Geschiedenis, vol. 2, 170. 48<-!!-> 49Boonekamp, Kraat and Mannesse, Werkboek bij Intrada (Groningen: Wolters Noordhoff, 1968), 25, 31. 50<-!!-> 51Ronald Donk, “Geschiedenis”, in Hans van Helden and Hans Voorbach, eds. Schoolvak in ontwikkeling: Ontwikkelingen in AVO/VWO (Amsterdam: Bureau Lerarenopleiding, 1989), 100–102; and Carla van Boxtel, “Geschiedenis als schoolvak: Veranderende opvattingen over doelstellingen en inrichting van het middelbaar geschiedenisonderwijs in Nederland 1945–1992” (Master thesis, University of Amsterdam, 1993), 42–46. 52<-!!-> 53Boonekamp, Intrada,1–18; Kalkwiek, Geschiedenis, vol. 4 54<-!!-> 55Old edition of Novem, Wereld, vol. 1, 28. 56<-!!-> 57Novem, Wereld, vol. 1, 72, 80–82. 58<-!!-> 59Boonekamp, Fuga, 1–61. 60<-!!-> 61O.L. Davis Jr., “Understanding the history of the social studies”, in Howard D. Mehlinger and O.L. Davis Jr., eds. The Social Studies: Eighteenth Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education. Part II (Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press, 1981), 19. 62<-!!-> 63Illustrative of this obliviousness amongst historians is the fact that even mathematicians have their own International Journal for the History of Mathematics Education, whereas no comparable platform exists for the history of history education.

History of educationSubject (documents)SociologyRelation (database)Intellectual historyHistorySocial scienceLawPolitical scienceLibrary science
Open in the catalogue DOI