Transnational treaties on children’s rights: Norm building and circulation in the twentieth century
Abstract
During the twentieth century, the socio-legal status of the child changed dramatically. The adoption of three international treaties specific to the rights of the child – namely, the Geneva Declaration (1924), the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of the Child (1959) and the United Nations Convention on the Rights on the Child (1989) – increasing at each stage the number and different types of rights, is a remarkable illustration of this state of fact. National socio-legal developments have, of course, greatly inspired the authors of these treaties. However, the rights of the child assumed a new dimension in intergovernmental and non-governmental organisations, exchange platforms par excellence. This article seeks a better understanding of the circulation of children’s rights during the twentieth century, within the three above mentioned treaties. From an interdisciplinary and transnational perspective, the study aims to analyse the multiple facets of children’s rights and the origins of non-domestic influences in this international process. The article appraises the role of international and intergovernmental organisations. Based on archival data, it identifies the concepts, the institutions, the agents and the contexts that influenced the evolution of children’s rights. It shows how the genesis, the diffusion and the promotion of international treaties, as well as their subsequent regimes, structured the circulation of children’s rights.Keywords: children’s rightstreatiesnormscirculationinternational organisations Notes1 The masculine case refers to both the masculine and feminine genders and is used for conciseness only.2 To date, only the United States, Somalia and South Sudan have not ratified the Convention, bringing the number of states parties to 193 out of 196.3 See Frédéric Darbellay, “The circulation of knowledge as an interdisciplinary process: Travelling concepts, analogies and metaphors”, Issues in Integrative Studies 30 (2012): 1–18; ISCHE34-SHCY-DHA, Internationalization in Education (18th–20th Centuries), Call for papers (2011).4 Pierre-Yves Saunier, “Les Régimes circulatoires du domaine social 1800–1940: projets et ingénierie de la convergence et de la différence”, Genèses 71, no. 2 (2008): 4–25. See also Saunier, “Circulations, connexions et espaces transnationaux”, Genèses 57, no. 4 (2004): 110–126; Jean-Paul Zúñiga, ed., Pratiques du transnational, terrains, preuves, limites (Paris: Centre de recherches historiques, 2011).5 Martha Finnemore and Katheryn Sikkink, “International norm dynamics and political change”, International Organization 52, no. 4 (1998): 895.6 Jeroen J.H. Dekker, “Children at risk in history: A story of expansion”, Paedagogica Historica 45, no. 1 (2009): 17–36.7 Ellen Key’s expression has almost become a common name for the twentieth century amongst childhood historians and more widely.8 The rights of children were indeed addressed by codes of law before the Industrial Revolution. However, within the scope and the limits of this article, this fact will not be further developed. For an insightful analysis of the rights of the child under Roman law, for instance, see Dominique Youf, Penser les droits de l'enfant (Paris: Presses universitaires de France, 2002).9 Jeroen J.H. Dekker, Educational Ambitions in History: Childhood and Education in an Expanding Educational Space from the Seventeenth to the Twentieth Century (Berlin: Peter Lang, 2010). See also Eckhardt Fuchs, “Children’s rights and global civil society”, Comparative Education 43, no. 3 (2007): 393–412; Ingrid Lohmann and Christine Mayer, “Lessons from the history of education for a ‘Century of the Child at Risk’”, Paedagogica Historica 45, no. 1–2 (2009): 1–16; Annemieke van Drenth and Kevin Myers, “Normalising childhood: Policies and interventions concerning special children in the United States and Europe (1900–1960)”, Paedagogica Historica 47, no. 6 (2011): 719–727.10 Lynne M. Kohm, “Tracing the foundations of the best interests of the child standard in American jurisprudence”, Journal of Law & Family Studies 10 (2008): 337–376.11 Hugh Cunningham, Children and Childhood in Western Society since 1500, 2nd edn. (Harlow: Pearson Education, 2005), 41.12 Ibid., 142.13 Dekker, “Children at risk”.14 Rita Hofstetter, Genève: creuset des sciences de l’éducation (Genève: Droz, 2010).15 See, for instance, Harry Hendrick, Child Welfare, Historical Dimensions, Contemporary Debate (Bristol: Policy Press, 2003); Judith Sealander, The Failed Century of the Child: Governing America’s Young in the Twentieth Century (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003).16 Hendrick, Child Welfare, chap. 2.17 Joëlle Droux, “L'Internationalisation de la protection de l’enfance: acteurs, concurrences et projets transnationaux (1900–1925)”, Critique Internationale 52, no. 3 (2011): 17–33; Lawrence J. LeBlanc, The Convention on the Rights of the Child: United Nations Lawmaking on Human Rights (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1995); Philip E. Veerman, The Rights of the Child and the Changing Image of Childhood (Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1992).18 Paula S. Fass, “A historical context for the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child”, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 633 (2011): 17–29.19 Dominique Marshall, “The construction of children as an object of international relations: The Declaration of Children’s Rights and the Child Welfare Committee of the League of Nations, 1900–1924”, International Journal of Children’s Rights 7 (1999): 108, quoting the assistant to the Secretary General of the LoN.20 Archives of the State of Geneva, International Union for Child Welfare Fund (ASG-IUCW), M1.2, Tri/71.1, Historique de l’UISE, mémorandum, publications de l’UISE de 1929-1939, Texte préparé pour le Xe anniversaire de l’UISE, 5. Translated from French.21 UNESCO Online Archives (UNESCO-OA), http://unesdoc.unesco.org, “1946–1950: First steps in a war-devastated world” (Conference for the Establishment of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation, Institute of Civil Engineers, London, 1–16 November 1945), ECO/CONF/29:27.22 Adam Lopatka, introduction to Legislative History of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) (Geneva: United Nations, 2007), 37.23 Joëlle Droux, “La Première Déclaration des droits de l’enfant (1924): acte de naissance d’un nouveau contrat social transnational?” (computer printout, Institut européen, Université de Genève, 2010).24 League of Nations Archives (LoNA), 12e Session du Conseil de la SDN, 21/41/15, Annexe 161 − Secours aux enfants des pays éprouvés par la guerre, rapport présenté par M. Balfour, délégué de l’Empire britannique et adopté par le Conseil dans sa séance du 23 février 1921.25 LoNA, 21e Session du Conseil de la SDN, Annexe 419, Relations entre l’AIPE et la SDN.26 Droux, “La Première Déclaration des droits de l’enfant”.27 ASG-IUCW, M1.5, Tri/71.1, (Histoire) Exposé des buts de l’UISE (circa 1925): 9.28 ASG-IUCW, AP 92.2.2, Tri/65-3, PV du IVe Conseil Général, jeudi-vendredi 22–23 février 1923.29 ASG-IUCW, AP 92.1.3, Tri/65-3, PV de la 87e séance du Comité Exécutif de l’Union, jeudi 1er mars 1923, Nomination d’une commission de rédaction de la charte de l’enfant.30 ASG-IUCW, AP 92.1.3, Tri/65-3, PV de la 95e séance du Comité Exécutif de l’Union, jeudi 28 juin 1923, Déclaration de Genève.31 ASG-IUCW, AP 92.1.3, Tri/65-3, PV de la 87e séance du Comité Exécutif de l’Union, jeudi 1er mars 1923, Nomination d’une commission de rédaction de la charte de l’enfant. Translated from French.32 LoNA, PV de la Ve Commission, 12e séance (vendredi 18 (sic) septembre 1924, à 15h30), Suite de la protection de l’enfance.33 ASG-IUCW, AP 92.2.2, Tri/65-3, PV du Ve Conseil Général, jeudi-vendredi 28–29 février 1924, Commission de la “Déclaration de Genève”.34 United Nations Organisation General Secretariat Archives (UNOGS-A), 19485-Child Welfare-Declaration on the Rights of the Child-Information from Member Governments (part A 1946-1948) Documentation Relating to the “Declaration of Geneva” Including Declarations and Charters Concerning Children’s Rights Adopted by Various Bodies Subsequent to 1924: 7.35 For a definition of a regime, see Jack Donnelly, “International human rights: A regime analysis”, International Organization 40, no. 3 (1986): 599–642; see also Michael Freeman, Human Rights (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2010).36 ASG-IUCW, M1.2, Tri/71.1, Historique de l’UISE, mémorandum, publications de l’UISE de 1929–1939, Texte préparé pour le Xe Anniversaire.37 Human Rights Commission Archives (HRC-A), S-0916-0009-0011 - Social Questions - Division of Social Activities - Protection of Youth - Child Welfare - Annual Reports, Interoffice Memo from Milhaud to Laugier, Objet: Projet de lettre circulaire à adresser à certains gouvernements membres, 6 December 1946.38 LoNA, PV de la Ve Commission Questions humanitaires et générales, Rapport de la Ve Commission à l’Assemblée, Annexe 2, no. officiel A.52.1934.IV.39 Marielle Debos and Alice Goheneix, “Les ONG et la fabrique de ‘l’opinion publique internationale’”, Raisons politiques 3, no. 19 (2005): 74. Translated from French.40 UNOGS-A, 19485-Child Welfare-Declaration on the Rights of the Child-Information from Member Governments (part A 1946-1948), Documentation Relating to the “Declaration of Geneva”.41 For an analysis of other international treaties on the rights of the child see Anna Holzscheiter, Children’s Rights in International Politics, The Transformative Power of Discourse (Basingstoke: Palgrave-Macmillan, 2010).42 UNOGS-A, S-0445-0077, Draft Declaration on the Rights of the Child (1958-1967), Interoffice Memoranda from J.P. Humphrey to Sir Humphrey Trevelyan (17 April 1958) and from J. Henderson to J.P. Humphrey (5 May 1958).43 AUNOG-S, 19485-Child Welfare-Declaration on the Rights of the Child-Information from Member Governments (part A 1946-1948), Letter from Delegation of Czechoslovakia, 2 September 1948.44 ASG-IUCW, N.1.3, Tri/71.3, Letter from G. Thélin to M. Milhaud, 22 June 1948.45 AUNOG-S, 18795-NGO-IUCW (part A-1937-1951), Memo from M. Milhaud to R. Cilento (Director of Division of Social Activities), 27 May 1948.46 AUNOG-S, S-0445-0077, Draft Declaration on the Rights of the Child (1958–1967), Interoffice Memorandum, To J.P. Humphrey from J. Henderson, director, Bureau of Social Affairs, ESA, Subject: Declaration of the Rights of the Child, 5 June 1958.47 Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights [OHCHR], Legislative History of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (Geneva: United Nations, 2007).48 UNOGS.A, S-0445-0077 Draft Declaration on the Rights of the Child (1958–1967), Interoffice Memorandum from J. Henderson to J.P. Humphrey (5 May 1958).49 ASG-IUCW, M.4.4, Tri/71.1, Confidential Letter to Miss Moser from Frieda S. Miller (2 September 1959).50 Ibid.51 ASG-IUCW, M.4.5, Tri/71.1, Coupures de presses, Editorial, New York Times, 18 October 1959.52 See, in particular, Hofstetter, Genève; Dominique Ottavi, De Darwin à Piaget, pour une histoire de la psychologie de l’enfant (Paris: CNRS Editions, 2009).53 See, in particular, Jordi Cots, “Le BICE et les Droits de l’Enfant: le message de la Convention et le message du BICE”, BICE, l’Enfance dans le Monde (1996): 4–7.54 Bengt Sandin, “Children and the Swedish welfare state: From different to similar”, in Paula S. Fass and Michael Grossberg, eds., Reinventing Childhood after World War II (Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2012), 110–138.55 For a definition of regime coherence, see Donnelly, “International human rights”.56 UNOGS-A, S-0910-0016-01 UN. SG Waldheim-IYC-UNICEF (1980-1981), Secretary General’s Message at the Opening of Final Plenary Session of NGO/IYC Committee, 15 May 1980: 2.57 Veerman, Rights of the Child.58 Cynthia Price Cohen, “The role of nongovernmental organizations in the drafting of the Convention on the Rights of the Child”, Human Rights Quarterly 12, no. 1 (1990): 137–147; Nigel Cantwell, “The origins, development and significance of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child”, in Sharon Detrick, ed., The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Guide to the “Travaux Préparatoires” (Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1992), 19–30.59 UNICEF Online Archives (UNICEF-OA), Executive Board Decisions 1978–1979, E/ICEF/L.1309/Add., 2–11 September, 1979: para. 72.60 HRC-A, G/SO 214 (28) Part 2 [Folder 1] File begins January 1979, ends March 1982, Notes for the Record Approved by Participants, Meeting 17 December 1980 “On the importance given to the child maltreatment question within the UN system”.61 HRC-A, G/SO 214 (28) Part 2 [Folder 2] File begins March 1982, ends December 1986, Resolution Adopted by the Executive Board of UNICEF E/ICEF/1986/CRP.37.62 HRC-A, G/SO 214 (28) Part 6 bis Begins December 1985, ends November 1989, Briefing Note, T. McCarthy Meeting with Mr James Grant.63 United Nations, Convention on the Rights of the Child, General Assembly, Resolution 44/25, 1989, UN doc. A/44/25: article 42.64 HRC-A, G/SO 214 (28) Part 6 bis Begins December 1985, ends November 1989, Letter to delegates, NGO representants, etc. from the NGO committee on UNICEF.65 HRC-A, G/SO 214 (28) Part 7 [Folder 2], Begins September 1989, ends February 1990, New York Times, 29 October 1989.66 General Assembly, Official Records, 14th Session, Plenary Meetings (841st Meeting on November 20, 1959), item 64: Draft Declaration of the Rights of the Child, Report of the Third Committee, A/4249 and Corr.2, paragraph 42.67 Sandrine Kott, “Dynamiques de l’Internationalisation: l'Allemagne et l'Organisation Internationale du Travail (1919–1940)”, Critique internationale 52, no. 3 (2011): 70.