How the influenza pandemic 1918/19 affected teacher education and schools in several ways − a case study from Switzerland
Abstract
Outbreaks of respiratory infections have impact on schools. The present article draws upon sources from the school archives of the former teachers' seminary Muristalden in the city of Bern in Switzerland. The aim is to ascertain how the various pandemic waves 1918/1919 affected school operations and the people living at Muristalden. During the summer wave 1918 (Phase A), the summer vacations were extended until end of August 1918 to limit infection spread. During the strong second wave in the autumn/winter 1918 (Phase B), the entire autumn quarter was cancelled. However, as this wave coincided with the General Strike in November 1918, during which Muristalden was occupied by the military, many families living at the seminary became ill due to the high prevalence of flu among soldiers. A kind of distance learning was instituted by requiring students to complete homework. At the beginning of 1919 (Phase C), when most of the official measures had been lifted again, considerable gaps in students' knowledge became evident. Those seminarians who had not yet suffered from the flu became ill within a very short time. This rapid spread resulted in many and long absences, hindering regular teaching and learning. The epidemic resulted in very few fatalities at Muristalden but many seminarians had to struggle with longer-termed after-effects. While the Muristalden case study is just one piece of a jigsaw that many have forgotten, together with other case studies it will contribute to a better understanding of past pandemics and their impacts on education.KEYWORDS: Spanish fluhistorical epidemiologyeffects of pandemics AcknowledgementsThe authors would like to thank the Campus Muristalden, and especially Ursula Käser, Andreas Schudel, Andreas Gräub, and Jürg Spring, for archive access and support. Andreas Krummen deserves special thanks, as his knowledge of the Muristalden archives was essential for this work. In addition, in April 2020, he circulated a four-page summary of the events that took place at Muristalden in 1918/19, which served as an initial stimulus for this article.Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.Notes1 As the Covid 19 pandemic has continued to unfold through several waves that took place during 2020 and 2021, a debate has arisen in history, in the history of medicine, and in the history of public health/epidemiology about how valuable lessons from the past can be in the context of a new outbreak. After three years of the Covid-19 pandemic, the consensus is that there are indeed certain aspects (e.g. management of subsequent waves) where scenarios from the past – adapted to a new context – are valuable for pandemic planning today and in the future, but also other areas for which the current context and challenges are too different for lessons from the past to be helpful. For a selection of positions see: Mark Honigsbaum, "History Offers Little Guide to How We Should Escape from Covid's Clutches", The Guardian, 7 November 2021, www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jul/11/history-offers-little-guide-to-how-we-should-escape-from-covids-clutches; Svenn-Erik Mamelund, "COVID-19: The Power of Historical Lessons", American Journal of Public Health 111, no. 3 (2021): 405–6; Howard Markel, "History won't Help us now. We have no Historical Precedent for this Moment", The Atlantic, 19 August 2021, www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/08/1918-influenza-pandemic-history-coronavirus/619801/; Graham Mooney, "The Dangers of Ignoring History Lessons During a Pandemic", Annals of Internal Medicine 174, no. 4 (2021): 556–7; and Robert Peckham, "COVID-19 and the Anti-Lessons of History", The Lancet 395, no. 10227 (2021): 850–2.2 Guillaume Lachenal and Gaëtan Thomas, "COVID-19: When History has No Lessons", History Workshop Online, 30 March 2020, www.historyworkshop.org.uk/covid-19-when-history-has-no-lessons/. For a discussion of this article in the light of the history of education, see Ian Grosvenor and Karin Priem, "Histories of the Past and Histories of the Future: Pandemics and Histories of Education", Paedagogica Historica 58, no. 5 (2022): 581−90.3 Grosvenor and Priem, "Histories", 583.4 Helena Cabeleira and Ana Isabel Madeira, "The Noise of the Living and the Silence of the Dead: Public Histories of Education in between Pandemics in the 'Rural' Portugal (1918–2021)", Paedagogica Historica 58, no. 5 (2022): 646–59.5 Andreas Hoffmann-Ocon, "'Keine passiven Redekränzchen' – Soziale und organisatorische Experimente in der politischen Kultur der Lehrpersonen(fort)bildung in Zürich um 1918", in 1918 in Bildung und Erziehung. Traditionen, Transitionen, Visionen, ed. Andrea De Vincenti, Norbert Grube and Andreas Hoffmann-Ocon (Bad Heilbrunn: Klinkhardt, 2020), 109–34.6 Jennifer Burri and Adrian Juen, "Schule zwischen Harmonie und Aufstand – SchülerInnenmitbestimmung an den Zürcher LehrerInnenseminaren um 1918", in 1918 in Bildung und Erziehung, 40–64.7 Between 21 May and 10 June 2020, still only a few months into the pandemic, Tony Honorato and Ana Clara Bortoleto Nery, two educational scientists from Brazil, asked 18 of their colleagues the following question: "What possible types of knowledge or devices develop from research in the History of Education for in-depth understanding and the assessment of impacts on the Covid-19 pandemic in School Education?" Tony Honorato and Ana Clara Bortoleto Nery, "History of Education and Covid-19: The crisis of the school according to African (Akanbi, Chisholm), American (Boto, Civera, Cunha, Kinne, Rocha, Romano, Rousmaniere, Southwell, Souza, Taborda, Veiga, Vidal) and European (Depaepe, Escolano, Magalhães, Nóvoa) researchers", Acta Scientiarum. Education 42 (2020): 1–21. Another important publication in this regard is a 2022 special issue of Paedagogica Historica with the title Histories of the Past and Histories of the Future: Pandemics and Historians of Education edited by Ian Grosvenor and Karin Priem. For an overview of the state of the art, see Kate Rousmaniere, "Unprecedented Times: A History of Pandemics in North American Education", Paedagogica Historica 58, no. 5 (2022): 716–8.8 Friedrich Schmid, Die Influenza in der Schweiz in den Jahren 1889–1894 (Bern: Francke, 1895); Kaspar Staub et al., "Public Health Interventions, Epidemic Growth, and Regional Variation of the 1918 Influenza Pandemic Outbreak in a Swiss Canton and its Greater Regions", Annals of Internal Medicine 174, no. 4 (2021): 533–9; Andreas Tscherrig, Krankenbesuche verboten! Die Spanische Grippe 1918/19 und die kantonalen Sanitätsbehörden in Basel-Landschaft und Basel-Stadt (Basel: Verlag Basel-Landschaft, 2016); and Swiss Health Office (ed.), Bulletin of the Swiss Health Office (Bern: Scheitlin, 1957, 1969, and 1970).9 This article is an extension of a German-language short comment that was published in June 2023: Staub Kaspar, "Die Influenza-Pandemie 1918/19 in Bern und ihre Auswirkungen am Lehrerseminar Muristalden", Berner Zeitschrift für Geschichte 85, no. 2 (2023): 37–53.10 Howard Markel et al., "Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918–1919 Influenza Pandemic." JAMA 298 (2007): 644–54.11 Alexandra Minna Stern et al., "'Better Off in School': School Medical Inspection as a Public Health Strategy During the 1918–1919 Influenza Pandemic in the United States", Public Health Reports 125 (2010): 63–70.12 Staub et al. (as in note 14).13 Ibid.14 This research gap is currently being addressed in an interdisciplinary way by the research group "Anthropometry and Historical Epidemiology" at the University of Zurich. More information is available on the website: www.iem.uzh.ch/en/pastpandemics.html.15 Kapar Staub et al., "Historically High Excess Mortality During the COVID-19 Pandemic in Switzerland, Sweden, and Spain", Annals of Internal Medicine 175, no. 4 (2022): 523–32; and Christian Sonderegger and Andreas Tscherrig, "Die Grippepandemie 1918−1919 in der Schweiz", in "Week by Week New Price Surcharges": Food, Energy, and Resource Conflicts in World War I Switzerland, ed. Christian Pfister et al. (Basel: Schwabe, 2016), 259–84.16 A recent estimation has shown that, without the introduction of vaccination from 2021 onward, the death toll due to the Covid-19 pandemic could have reached similar magnitudes as the 1918/19 pandemic in Switzerland, also in relative terms: Zwahlen Marcel and Kaspar Staub, "What would have Happened if We would not have had the Covid-19 vaccination?", Swiss Medical Weekly, 14 August 2022. https://smw.ch/index.php/smw/announcement/view/54.17 A detailed analysis of the Spanish flu spread in the canton of Bern and the reactions of the authorities has recently been published. Staub et al. (as in note 13); Kaspar Staub, "If Immunization is too Low, Dropping Temperatures in Fall 2021 may Lead to Epidemic Resurgence − as in 1918, 1957 and 2020", Swiss Medical Weekly,151, no. 3334 (2021): w3001; and Marco Bernhard et al., "From Pandemic to Endemic: Spatial-Temporal Patterns of Influenza-Like Illness Incidence in a Swiss Canton, 1918–1924", Economics and Human Biology (forthcoming 2023).18 Kaspar Staub et al., "Learning from Past Crises – The Example of the 1918 Influenza Pandemic in the Swiss Army", Swiss Review of Military and Disaster Medicine (SRMDM) 99, no. 1 (2022): 619–28; Armin Rusterholz, "'Das Sterben will nicht enden!': The 'Spanish Flu Epidemic' 1918/19 in the Swiss Army with special consideration of the military victims of Glarus", Jahrbuch des Historischen Vereins des Kantons Glarus 90 (2010): 9–43; and Walter Nussbaum, "Die Grippe-Epidemie 1918–1919 in der schweizerischen Armee", Gesnerus: Swiss Journal of the History of Medicine and Sciences 39, no. 2 (1982): 242–59.19 In connection with "influenza" in the period around 1918, we can only ever speak of "influenza-like illness" (ILI), since viruses were not yet known at that time and the influenza virus as a causative agent of infection could not be confirmed through laboratory tests.20 Staub et al. (as in note 13).21 This was followed in January/February 1920 by an even stronger wave of follow-ups, which, however, are not part of this study. See Staub (as in note 17).22 Markel Howard, "Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918−1919 Influenza Pandemic", JAMA 298, no. 6 (2007): 644−54. This information was still available in early 2020. As Christian Drosten, virologist and one of the main consultants of the German chancellor, recently explained, it was his historical knowledge of how American cities fought the "Spanish flu" that led him to recommend school closures in Germany (Karl Lauterbach and Christian Drosten, "Spiegel-Gespräch", interview by Rafaela von Bredow and Markus Feldenkirchen. Der Spiegel 7, 2 February 2023, 43).23 Clive H. Church and Randolph C. Head, A Concise History of Switzerland (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013), 201.24 Adrian Zimmermann, "Der Landesstreik in der Region Bern: Vorgeschichte, Verlauf und Auswirkungen", Berner Zeitschrift für Geschichte 81, no. 2 (2019): 3–43.25 Ingrid Brühwiler and Matias Gardin, "Fabricating National Unity in Torn Contexts: World War I in the Multilingual Countries of Switzerland and Luxembourg", in Small Nations and Colonial Peripheries in World War I, ed. Gearóid Barry, Enrico Dal Lago and Róisín Healy (Boston: Brill, 2016), 154.26 Christian Pfister et al. (eds.), "Woche für Woche neue Preisaufschläge": Food, Energy, and Resource Conflicts in World War I Switzerland (Basel: Schwabe, 2016).27 Kaspar Staub, "Der vermessene menschliche Körper als Spiegel der Ernährungs- und Gesundheitsverhältnisse am Ende des Ersten Weltkrieges", in "Woche für Woche neue Preisaufschläge", 285–305; and Joël Floris and Kaspar Staub, "Measuring Hunger", in Hunger Draws the Map: Blockade and Food Shortages in Europe 1914–1922, ed. Hew Strachan et al. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023), forthcoming.28 Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden. 42. Jahresbericht des Evangelischen Seminars auf dem Muristalden bei Bern. 1918–1919. (Bern: Buchdruckerei Berner Tagblatt, 1919). 1–72.29 Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden (ed.), Gedenkschrift zum 75 jährigen Bestand des Evangelischen Seminars auf dem Muristalden Bern: 1854–1929 (Bern: Verlag Berner Tagblatt, 1929); Jakob Aellig, Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden: Jubiläumsschrift 1854–1954, a contribution to Bernese church and school history (Bern: Verlag Seminar Muristalden, 1954); Jakob Staub, 125 Jahre Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden, 100 Jahre Seminarschule Muristalden, Jubiläumsschrift 1979 (Bern: Verlag Seminar Muristalden, 1979).30 Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden. 42. Jahresbericht, 1–72.31 Staub et al. (as in note 20).32 See note 30 above.33 It is reported that, as the need for rationing became more acute, there were concerns about the supply first of bread and then also of potatoes and milk, due to which the potato consumption of the seminarians was reduced by two to three times and the milk rations to a few decilitres. Thanks to the supplies and donations from aid societies and kind-hearted people from all over the canton, it was nevertheless possible to "face the winter with confidence".34 See note 30 above.35 Ibid.36 Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden, Gedenkschrift, 270−2.37 See note 30 above.38 Evangelisches Seminar Muristalden, Gedenkschrift, 272.39 The annual reports of Campus Muristalden on the years 2020 and 2021 make similar references to the historical caesura of the Covid-19 pandemic and the associated restrictions at Muristalden. Campus Muristalden (ed.), Annual Report: Gymnasium, Continuing Education Classes, Elementary School, Boarding School (Bern: Campus Muristalden, 2020 and 2021), www.muristalden.ch/ueber-uns/portraet/jahresberichte/.40 David M. Morens et al., "A Centenary Tale of Two Pandemics: The 1918 Influenza Pandemic and COVID-19, Part I", American Journal of Public Health 111, no. 6 (2021): 1086–94.41 Christian Pfister, "The 20th Century 'Catastrophe Gap' and the Loss of Traditional Risk Awareness", Gaia 18, no. 3 (2009): 239–46.42 Kaspar Staub et al., "The 'Pandemic Gap' in Switzerland across the 20th Century and the Necessity of Increased Science Communication of Past Pandemic Experiences", Swiss Medical Weekly (2020), online: https://smw.ch/index.php/smw/announcement/view/34.Additional informationFundingThe authors reported there is no funding associated with the work featured in this article.Notes on contributorsLukas BoserLukas Boser is a historian of education. His research is focused on the histories of measurement, standardisation, normalisation, maths education, reading and writing education, and the making of citizens. Since 2013 he has held an appointment as senior lecturer at the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Northwestern Switzerland, School of Education. He has also been a visiting scholar at Stanford University (2017), a honorary fellow at the University of Wisconsin-Madison (2011), and since 2019 he has been a visiting professor at the University of Vienna.Kaspar StaubKaspar Staub is an expert in history, epidemiology, and evolutionary medicine. Since 2014, he has built-up and headed the research group "Anthropometry and Historical Epidemiology" at the University of Zurich. Among other things, he is a faculty member of the Swiss School of Public Health, a member of the new Crisis Competence Centre of the UZH, and a lecturer at the Institute of History at the University of Bern. His research focusses on the interactions between human health and the changing environment during the last 200 years.