historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Debate on the Teaching of History: Historical Epistemology Meets Nationalist Narrative

Bruce Curtis
Historical Studies in Education / Revue d'histoire de l'éducation · 2013 · 25(2)

Abstract

Canadians federally and residents of Quebec provincially are being exposed to major attempts to rewrite history and to rework historical memory. Federally, such attempts changed course and intensity after the Conservative minority government took office in 2006 and began to militarize memory, while moving to eliminate large portions of the country's scientific and historical research infrastructure. In Quebec, shifting versions of nationalist memory have a more complex pedigree. thier, Cardin and Lefranois' "Cris et chuchotements" is a stimulating polemic directed against the project of people they characterize as ethnic nationalists to ensure that history teaching in Quebec high schools, and official historical memory more generally, support a vision of the "Quebec nation" and its as-yet-unrealized destiny of political independence. 1 In their essay, thier, Cardin and Lefranois show that the teaching of history in Quebec's school system has been a political enterprise since it began. Its objectives and substance have followed the various transformations in Quebec's internal politics and in the province's relation to the rest of the federation. Under the hegemony of the Catholic Church, the boundaries of the French Canadian community were defined in ethnic-religious terms rather than in terms of location in sovereign territory. School history teaching focussed on a grand narrative of triumphant colonisation by heroes of the faith in the service of Divine Providence. With the ending of the Church's hegemony, the boundaries of the community were redrawn as those of the territory of Quebec. Under the Lesage and Bourassa Liberals, Quebec was still seen as the nursery of a French reality for Canada, even if school history turned to focus on a secular Quebec society. However, in opposition to the Trudeau Liberal project of translating the pan-Canadian Catholic vision into a national civil French-Canadianism, the first Parti Qubcois (PQ) government of Rn Lvesque famously wrote off French-Canadians living outside Quebec as doomed to cultural extinction. History teaching was caught up in the ongoing conflict between the Quebec Liberal party's project for heightened provincial autonomy within the Canadian federation

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF