Nicholas Lemann. The Big Test: The Secret History of the American Meritocracy. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1999. Pp. viii, 406.
Abstract
The Big Test by Nicholas Lemann is a well-written, fascinating, and critical account of the "untold" history of the SAT as the key measure for determining people's fates in America's meritocratic society of post-World War Two.Lemann attempts to demonstrate that this is a history of James Bryant Conant's particular vision of meritocracy, as well as revealing a little luck and a lot of determination on the part of the SAT's chief entrepreneur, Henry Chauncey.The book has generated a great deal of controversy and debate in the United States (see for instance History of Education Quarterly, Spring 2001), particularly because, in Lemann's words, "the machinery that Conant and Chauncey and their allies created is today so familiar and all-encompassing that it seems almost like a natural phenomenon, or at least an organism that evolved spontaneously in response to conditions" (p. 6).This book will be of interest to and should be read by anyone researching the history of testing, but its reach is vast and it will also be a valuable resource for those with an interest in American history and politics, as well as entertaining for all readers of this journal.The history is told largely through a great deal of biographical detail woven together to make up a broad narrative.It is broken into three parts.The first centres around the two main figures in the promotion of the SAT, Conant and Chauncey.Conant, president of Harvard University (1933-1953), was a critic of the small group of established elites that had come to dominate the Ivy League universities and American society more generally, chiefly through the inheritance of privilege.Following Thomas Jefferson, Conant wanted to replace this group of powerful elites with one selected on the basis of innate abilities.That is to say, he sought to create a "natural aristocracy" made up of men of "virtue and talent."This group would be selected from all classes in society on the basis of intelligence, and would be trained in the highest educational institutions to be fitted for public service.Conant had a key role as the head of one of the most prestigious universities in the United States.He first tried out his