Alvin J. Esau. The Courts and the Colonies: The Litigation of Hutterite Church Disputes
Abstract
In Canada in 2005 there is clear evidence of a developing debate about the extent to which as a pluralist society we should recognize and encourage particular cultural communities to apply their own internal systems of law, justice, and discipline.The most extensive and articulate challenges to assumptions about homogeneity of political and legal institutions come from First Nations communities.Pressure is also evident, however, among some immigrant communities, most notably among members of the Muslim faith who favour the introduction of sharia law to govern their internal social and familial relations.What we forget and Professor Esau reminds us in The Courts and the Colonies is that the existence of minorities seeking to insulate themselves from the values, governance, and law of the dominant community is of long standing in this country.One of the most intriguing examples is provided by the Hutterites, a group of Germanspeaking religious pacifists and communalists, most of whom came to Canada in the late 1910s after persecution for their pacifism in the United States.As a matter of faith the members of this community have chosen to live their lives apart and insulated, as far as possible, from the state, the dominant culture, and its temptations.What this erudite and engaging study does is two-fold.In the first place, it demonstrates the strength of the traditional belief system of the Hutterites which requires that they foreswear the ways of the world in order to venerate God, follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, and protect their communities from the corrosive values of the state and broader society.Secondly, the author expresses how difficult it has been in more recent decades for certain segments of this faith group to preserve their long-standing beliefs and internal system of government, law, and discipline, and to resist the temptation to resort to the external (Canadian) legal system to resolve their disputes.It has been a long-standing cardinal precept of Hutterite belief that disputes within the faith community should be resolved by the