Paul Bennett. The Grammar School: Striving for Excellence for 50 Years in a Public School World
Abstract
Readers looking for a strictly academic account of the history of the Halifax Grammar School (HGS) will likely be disappointed by Paul Bennett's The Grammar School: Striving for Excellence for 50 Years in a Public School World. Rather, this volume reads as a celebration of the independent school's first fifty years. The book is an interesting survey of the institution's history, with liberally illustrated pages depicting personalities important to the school's development. In addition, the appendices include eight pages listing school founders, leadership, administration, faculty, staff, student award winners and other notable individuals. These details suggest that the main audience for this slim volume is anyone with a personal connection to the school. Nevertheless, The Grammar School is more than just a souvenir book. The author draws on sources as diverse as HGS and Halifax Board of Education archival records, newspaper accounts, personal interviews and even blogs in order to provide an account of the ups and downs of creating a sustainable independent school. This book also reads as a labour of love. Paul Bennett was the Headmaster of the HGS from 2005 to 2009, and as such, he may be forgiven for a lack of impartiality toward the institution he describes. The process of establishing and sustaining an independent school was a tumultuous one indeed, as evidenced by several of the hyperbolic chapter titles: "The 'Great Schism' and the Separation," "Weathering the Progressive Educational Storm," and the title of the first chapter, "Thunderclap of Reform: Hilda Neatby's 'So Little for the Mind' and the Halifax Grammar School Experiment." The latter title is the same as a previously published essay by Bennett in the Journal of the Royal Nova Scotia Historical Society (2008), and major sections of that work are reprinted here in the first and second chapters. Bennett describes the founding of HGS by a group of parents dissatisfied with public education in the city