Sarah Glassford and Amy Shaw, eds., Making the Best of It: Women and Girls of Canada and Newfoundland During the Second World War
Abstract
Making the Best of It follows the success of their previous edition A Sisterhood of Suffering and Service (2012).Both are part of the Studies in Military History Series, a joint enterprise by UBC Press and the Canadian War Museum.Where A Sisterhood of Suffering and Service focused on women and girls in Canada and Newfoundland in the First World War, Making the Best of It addresses a diversity of women's and girls' lives in the Second World War.It is an engaging and finely edited volume on women's and girls' experiences at home and overseas, in paid and volunteer labour, on the streets and in stores, and in homes and at work.The editors are particularly sensitive to the various marks of identity that fracture the categories of "girl" and "woman," with particularly strong attention paid to age, ethnicity, and religion, as well as nods to addressing race, specifically Whiteness in some of the essays.Overall, this is a well-crafted collection that speaks to the past, present, and future of the historiography on women and the Second World War.This collection builds on the work of Ruth Roach Pierson, Pamela Wakewich and Helen Smith, and Carolyn Gossage, which is readily engaged in this new volume, with contributors adding complexity to the existing women's history of the period.Since its publication in 1986, Ruth Roach Pierson's 'They're Still Women After All': The Second World War and Canadian Womanhood has rightly dominated conversations on the subject, as well as serving as a model for Canadian women's history more generally.Making the Best of It directly addresses Pierson's work and its formidable legacy -at least in women's history -that the World War II was not the liberating moment for Canadian women as it was sometimes popularly understood.While the question of liberation and -liberation for whom -hovers in the historiography, the editors have chosen not to pursue it as a central organizing theme.Thus, some of the essays in here lightly address it, while most seek to add diversity to the established stories of women in the Second World War, further refining and complicating our understanding of the war on girls and women's lives across Canada, in Newfoundland, and overseas.As the title of the collection reveals, even adding girls into the conversation feels fresh and important in this regard.Barbara Lorenzkowski's essay on the wars impact in the "small spaces of [girls'] childhood" (53) and Claire Halstead's chapter on British evacuees and friendship add interesting new dimensions to girls' histories.Making the Best of It is divided into four sections that collectively include twelve chapters bound by an introduction, conclusion, and section overviews written by the editors.A curated bibliography caps off the book.The first section on "Women, Children, and War" covers a range of issues, from girls' emotional communities in two Atlantic communities to the experiences of British evacuees in Canada to the policy elements of childcare to schoolgirls' conflicted identities in Montreal as they