Thomas Fleming, Worlds Apart: British Columbia Schools, Politics, and Labour Relations Before and After 1972
Abstract
This book aims to "prompt a much-needed debate about the organizational and political conflicts that have disrupted British Columbia's schools for some time and that continue to imperil public education" (11).It primarily addresses two organizational issues.The first is the ability of the provincial school system, as currently organized, to handle the challenges it faces.The second is the relationship that exists among the organizations responsible for public education in B.C., particularly between the provincial government and the B.C. Teachers Federation.The book also raises, if only indirectly, some interesting questions about the role of history in the determination of public policy.Drawing heavily on historical data, Thomas Fleming, Professor Emeritus of Education at the University of Victoria, suggests that the B.C. Ministry of Education ignores its history, while its main antagonist, the B.C. Teachers Federation, is too much the prisoner of its past.As a result, "For the first time in its history public schooling stands without a story to tell and without bold new ideas to move it forward"(128).Fleming divides the educational history of B.C into two parts.The first, lasting from 1872 to 1972, was "a century of triumph" (23ff ) when a handful of enlightened civil servants, aided by dedicated teachers and inspectors and supported by a cooperative public, created a school system that was "admired, envied in fact, by other jurisdictions across the nation" (37).After 1972, however, this "once harmonious school community was riven by politics, special interests, conflict, and organizational distrust" (12).For Fleming, the causes of this disintegration include the "shortsightedness" of school boards; the "confusion and lack of purpose" of the Ministry of Education; the retreat of university faculties of education into an "isolation ward of unintelligibility"; and above all the "puffery, self-righteousness, and blind ambition"