Marianne A. Larsen, The Making and Shaping of the Victorian Teacher: A Comparative New Cultural History
Abstract
We have all been students and many of us are teachers.And we all think that we know what makes a "good" teacher.As Marianne Larsen illustrates, our twenty-first century assumptions about the importance of education and of the key role that teachers play within the system eerily echo beliefs that first emerged in the Victorian age.This well-crafted and persuasive analysis of The Making and Shaping of the Victorian Teacher explores how education reformers and soon the state "invented" the model teacher and how these expectations were embedded and reinforced by new practices that effectively governed teachers' lives and their work.Larsen is clear from the beginning that this is not a collective biography.Instead, she seeks to examine "how it became possible to think about teachers in new ways" (22) and how the ideas and subsequent processes that were championed by Victorian reformers were instrumental in making "good" teachers.This is a decidedly cultural history that rests, as Larsen explains in Part One, on a close reading of the emerging discourses about educational reform.The first section of the book also places her subject firmly into a comparative context.Concerns raised by growing industrialization and urbanization encouraged educational reformers throughout Europe and North America to call for free and eventually compulsory education as a way to address social ills and ensure the well being of the state.Although educational systems differed, educational reformers, migrants and the emerging education press promoted a cross fertilisation of ideas and assumptions about the benefits of popular education.Part Two explores how teachers became the object of concern amid this new vision of the educational state.At the beginning of the century teachers were viewed with disdain.Teaching, after all, was "a refuge for the destitute individual" and most teachers were old, sick, ignorant, immoral, cruel and clearly unable to manage increasingly