Must Biography be Educational?
Abstract
A hoary but persistent tradition has it that people's lives, once in print, become exemplary and educational. Aristotle put his stamp on this idea, Plutarch famously supplied it with content, and, closer to ourown time, the Victorians and the Edwardians gaveit a moralistic twist. One thinks of Thomas Carlyle and his imitators, Leslie Stephen and his "moral progeny," John Morley and his imitators in the field of political biography, and Lytton Strachey, inimitable in his insight that "great" people mostly have feet of clay. In this lineage, the biographer's task (apart from recounting the agreed facts of a life) is to warn readers of moral danger, to urge moral greatness, or to tell of the links between greatness of character and greatness ofdeeds---or all three. In raising questions like these, and furthermore intensifying our sensibility, biographers were and are "educating" -but only if one accepts a morally-freighted definition of education.' Since at least the 1920s biographers have been voting with their pens and their computers. Their verdict is in. They havemoved awayfrom moralized consi deration of lives past and present. Under the old job description, biographers found themselves performing functions once restricted to prophets. Fewer and fewer found they could honestly make strong ethical, aesthetic, social, and poli tical prescriptions, or see this as their primary obligation. The New York Review