historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Jeffrey A. Keshen. Saints, Sinners, and Soldiers: Canada’s Second World War. Studies in Canadian Military History Series. Vancouver, Toronto: UBC Press in Association with the Canadian War Museum, 2004. Pp. 389.

Jill Wade
Historical Studies in Education / Revue d'histoire de l'éducation · 2005 · 17(1)

Abstract

Was the Second World War a "good war" or a "bad war" for Canada?In his exhaustively researched, fully documented, and splendidly illustrated book entitled Saints, Sinners, and Soldiers, Jeffrey Keshen convinces the reader that it was a "not-so-good war," or at most something approaching a "good war."Inspired by the historical writings of British and American historians who have studied the social history of the Second World War, Keshen reveals the complexity of wartime society at home and on the front.Yes, there was a prevailing sense of sacrifice and idealism.Still, beyond this nobility of purpose, he finds stresses and strains created by rationing, workplace tensions, housing shortages, shifting gender roles, changes in family life, overseas experiences, and peacetime rehabilitation.Indeed, he regards the war as "a social accelerator quickly thrusting people into situations that boldly challenged their moral and social conventions," and he paints a graphic picture of hoarding, scamming, profiteering, black markets, strikes, "(im)moral matters," working women, "women warriors," juvenile delinquency, and difficult and frequently painful post-war readjustment.The responses of Canadians were both progressive and socially conservative, and from this mix of "patriotic" and "problematic" reactions came "major legacies in law, society, and culture that echo to this very day.""How can this period have both sides?"Keshen asks.Perhaps the answer is a rather modest one: that's life!After all, history is no tidier than life itself, and the stories of those who endured the wretched conflict that was the Second World War may have been more complicated than usual.My sense is that, if you looked at one extended wartime family, you would have found saints, sinners, and soldiers in its midst.For example, it was not unusual to find a grandmother pressing her son-in-law, a Wartime Prices and Trade Board employee, for extra brown sugar and butter for the Christmas shortbread, all the while tending her victory garden, knitting socks, buying Victory Bonds, and supporting the salvage corps.Her two sons, both in uniform, saw more action in their messes than on the front.Sadly, another son-in-law was shot down over Holland on a Bomber Command mission; her widowed daughter received government support for herself and her young son and in the 1950s returned to teaching school.A daughter-in-law served in the air force

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF