historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Michael D’Antonio. The State Boys Rebellion.

Jason Ellis
Historical Studies in Education / Revue d'histoire de l'éducation · 2007 · 19(1)

Abstract

The State Boys Rebellion, is a well-written and dramatic account of disability, children's experiences of institutionalization, eugenics and reform in the midtwentieth century United States. D'Antonio examines the experiences of a group of boys, particularly one boy, Fred Boyce, from their admission to Massachusetts' Fernald School for the Feebleminded in the 1940s and 1950s, to the present. D'Antonio's main argument is that officials misdiagnosed these "utterly normal" (5) boys (and some girls, housed separately, but whose experiences D'Antonio explores only briefly) as 'feebleminded.' D'Antonio begins his narrative at Boyce's admittance to Fernald in 1949 at the age of eight. At Fernald, Boyce and his peers faced violent attendants; the abuse of younger and more disabled boys by older, more 'normal' ones; hours spent in idleness instead of in school; sexual assaults by male and female staff; and the constant disciplinary threat of banishment to Fernald's forensic unit ("Ward 22") or its totally degraded back wards. Despite these obstacles, Boyce exercised agency by learning to survive in the institution and even by actively questioning the accuracy of his own diagnosis.

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF