Historical Identities: The Professoriate in Canada
Abstract
Given the title, subject matter and need for such a work, this book could have been a monograph. That it is not perhaps reflects the state of the discipline or the resources required for such an undertaking. Imposing rational order on the natural chaos of thematic essays is no easy task and one can admire the individual contributions while commiserating with the editors whose task it was to draw the parts together into a coherent whole that is something more than the sum of them. Essay volumes purporting to address large or important topics lend themselves only too well to minute if not microscopic treatments of highly specialized subjects. They let historians off the hook by not compelling them to treat the big picture. Content completely overwhelms or ignores context.