historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Gary McCulloch, The Struggle for the History of Education

John Allison
Historical Studies in Education / Revue d'histoire de l'éducation · 2013 · 25(2)

Abstract

The Struggle for the History of Education maps out the nature of the field and seeks to highlight the sites of struggle.He opens his monograph by suggesting that the history of education might seem sedate to the outsider but is actually all about struggle.He suggests that the field, like the object of study, is in continual flux.Education is, as he states, a site for social progress, change and equality, struggles for democracy and the fight for social justice.He argues for a clearly articulated vision for the field, and the book is one effort in that direction.McCulloch also underlines the need both to learn from colleagues in faculties of education and teach these colleagues about historical ways of thinking about education.Central to McCulloch's opening argument is the idea that history of education is a site of struggle because it lies at the crossroads of three areas of study: history, education and the social sciences.In the first chapter, McCulloch sets out the idea of the history of education as the struggle for social progress.He speaks to the historiography and the contributions of earlier scholars such as Leopold von Ranke and the "scientific" approach to historical writing.As McCulloch characterizes this, it is the "Acts and Facts" approach to history.McCulloch also reviews the transition from Ellwood Cubberly's progressivist approach to US history of education to Bernard Bailyn's critique, to Lawrence Cremin's critique, to the Marxist analyses of Michael Katz.McCulloch documents a similar intellectual pattern in the United Kingdom and in New Zealand.McCulloch's chapter on the struggle for educational reform and the useable past is particularly engaging.One of the critiques that McCulloch makes of contemporary educational policy is that of historical amnesia, with governments often reinventing the proverbial wheel.He also argues that "the role of the history of education in the struggle for educational reform has been contested and denied not only by policy makers, but also by a number of historians of education who prefer to avoid giving excessive attention to the present" ( 69).Yet McCulloch notes the value of history

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF