historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Elizabeth Smyth, Sandra Acker, Paula Bourne, and Alison Prentice, eds. Challenging Professions: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives on Women's Professional Work. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1999. Pp. 334.

Sara Z. Burke
Historical Studies in Education / Revue d'histoire de l'éducation · 2002 · 14(2)

Abstract

Despite coming first in her class three years in a row, the young physicist Elizabeth Laird was not awarded the prestigious 1851 Exhibition Scholarship from the University of Toronto.In her study of early women physicists, Alison Prentice explains that the scholarship, which enabled the top graduate to pursue advanced study abroad, was awarded instead to the man who came second.Elizabeth Laird is one of many talented, ambitious, and determined women we meet in Challenging Professions, and like Laird, these women all encounter the obstacles, or challenges, of gender bias in their pursuit of professional work.For this reason, the collection is often painful to read, and the combination of historical and contemporary perspectives serves to remind us that these challenges, for many professional women, continue into the present.The current structural inequalities of such male-dominated professions as forestry, explored by Peggy Tripp-Knowles, or chartered accountancy, studied by Cyndy Allen and Margaret Conrad, provide modern-day counterparts to the injustices experienced by Elizabeth Laird and other first-generation professional women in the 1890s.As many of the essays in Challenging Professions reveal, however, inequality is only one aspect of the complex interaction between gender and professionalization.Growing out of an interdisciplinary research network on women and professional education, Challenging Professions is a diverse, absorbing collection of essays.Although the topics range widely in subject matter, perspective, and methodology, the book nevertheless can be read easily as a unified whole; when approached collectively, the seemingly eclectic articles contribute to an overall thematic coherence.The organization of Challenging Professions promotes this conceptual coherence, without disguising the diversity of its individual contributions.Rather than grouping the essays according to subject or chronology, the editors chose to divide the collection into three distinct sections.In the first part, "Individual Odysseys," the authors use a biographical approach.The second section,

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF