Bruce Curtis. The Politics of Population: State Formation, Statistics, and the Census of Canada, 1840-1875. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2001. Pp. 385.
Abstract
Historical demographers know that the census is far from perfectly reliable but, after reading Bruce Curtis' latest book, many more will be mindful of how political it is throughout."Census making," he writes, "is not in any simple sense the taking of things as they are; in an important sense it is the making of things to be taken" (p.305).This is not a segue into linguistic-turn mumbo-jumbo but recognition of the fact that census categories do not exist in an immanent form.The census reflects an "imaginary of social relations," that is to say a conceptualization of what constitutes "society."How "population" is understood and put into neat categories and columns involves the exercise of power and enables the further growth of power.Census making "seeks to tie individuals within an administrative grid and then to hold them steady so that they may become objects of knowledge and government" (p. 26). So, whose vision of what is to be counted should prevail?And to what ends?The larger lessons Curtis draws from this exercise could be applied to a great many modern regimes but the laboratory is very definitely Canadian.In the Canadas between the Act of Union and the early days of Confederation, the campaign of "Rep by Pop" invigorated Canada West's interest in census taking in the 1840s and '50s while anxieties for la survivance animated involvement in Canada East.There were typically Canadian farces attached to the process as well, such as enumerators in French districts who received only English forms, or the complex and loaded question of whether such a thing as a "Canadian" existed for the purposes of the census.Certainly Canadians East and West were equally suspicious of attempts to enumerate their respective "provinces" identically: as