historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Towards a History of Educational Research in Canada: Content Analysis of the AJER

Henry W. Hodysh
Historical Studies in Education / Revue d'histoire de l'éducation · 2000 · 12(1)

Abstract

Historical Studies in Education/Revue d'histoire de /'education The distinction between basic and applied studies points to a theory-practice gap that worried the research community from its beginnings."Educational research to the mid-1980s was approached primarily through quantitative inves tigation.This does not imply that qualitative studies lacked legitimacy, but that their various methodologies did not readily measure up to "scientific and objective" quantitative traditions.16There is little evidence of a shift from one approach to the other.Educational research retained quantitative and qualitative characteristics, as if these were necessarily complementary perspectives. IMPLICATIONSDid the gradual decline in the number of non-university authors signify a narrow ing of theJournal's and the community's interests, or was the continuing high participation of university scholars a "circling of the wagons" as individual interests and power played out against competing groups in times of academic re structuring and financial constraint?And does the growth of theJournalshow that educational research has become a cooperative endeavour among local, provincial, federal andintemational institutions?Does research depend not only on their financial assistance, but, also on the character of their political interests in educational research and editorial policy? CONCLUSIONWe could do with more work on the differential evolution of Canada's decentral ized research communities.One way to begin that work might involve comparisons of theJournalwith other periodicals, such as Interchange (which first appeared in 1970) ortheCanadianJournalofEdueation (which made its debut in 1976).These publications, analyzed under systematic and logically consistent standards, may suggest markers for deciding how educational research moves forward (or side ways) in Canada.It may not be entirely far-fetched to say that in the Canadian educational community the periodical has served not only as the messenger but the message.

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF