historyofeducation.eu · Journals

‘Micro’ politics: mapping the origins of schools computing as a field of education policy

Neil Selwyn
History of Education · 2013 · 42(5) · pp. 638-658

Abstract

This paper examines the emergence of schools ‘micro-computing’ in the UK between 1977 and 1984 – a period of significant educational, technological and political change. During this time, computing developed rapidly from a niche activity in a few select schools to the state subsidized purchasing of a ‘computer in every school’ and the nationwide promotion of computers as a feature of curriculum and pedagogy. Through a series of in-depth retrospective interviews with key policy actors (n=20) this paper develops a detailed ‘policy historiography’ of this period - shedding light on the complex power relations and interests that underpinned these developments. In particular, the paper highlights the origins of these policy interventions in earlier activities, and examines the negotiations and conflicts between and within the two government departments involved in the mass introduction of computing into the UK school system.Keywords: Conservative partyThatcher governmentpolicymakingcomputersinformation technology AcknowledgementThis paper arises from a research project funded by the British Academy (award number SG102072). The author would like to thank the anonymous reviewers for their comments on earlier drafts of the articleNotes1M. McNeil, ‘The Old and New World of Information Technology in Britain’, in Enterprise and Heritage: Crosscurrents of National Culture, ed. J. Corner and S. Harvey (London: Routledge, 2001), 116–36; N. Selwyn, ‘The Place of Technology in the Conservative-Liberal Democrat Education Agenda: An Ambition of Absence?’, Educational Review 63, no. 4 (2011): 395–408.2R. Jones, ‘Microcomputers: Their Uses in Primary Schools’, Cambridge Journal of Education 10, no. 3 (1980): 144–53.3M. Young, ‘Information Technology and the Sociology of Education: Some Preliminary Thoughts’, British Journal of Sociology of Education 5, no. 2 (1984): 205–10.4T. Blyth, ‘Computing for the Masses?’ in Reflections on the History of Computing, ed. A. Tatnall (Berlin: Springer, 2012), 231–42; T. Lean, ‘Mediating the Microcomputer: The Educational Character of the 1980s British Popular Computing Boom’, Public Understanding of Science 22, no. 5 (2013): 546–58.5J. Ozga, ‘Studying Education Policy through the Lives of the Policy-makers’, in Changing Policies, Changing Teachers, ed. S. Walker and L. Barton (Milton Keynes: Open University, 1987).6S. Ball, Education Reform (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1994).7T. Gale, ‘Critical Policy Sociology’, Journal of Education Policy 16, no. 5 (2001): 385.8M. Maguire and S. Ball, ‘Researching Politics and the Politics of Research’, International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 7, no. 3 (1994): 269–85.9S. Gewirtz and J. Ozga, ‘Partnership, Pluralism and Education Policy’, Journal of Education Policy 5 (1990): 37–48.10See N. Selwyn, ‘Researching the Once-powerful in Education: The Value of Retrospective Elite Interviewing in Education Policy Research’, Journal of Education Policy 28, no. 3 (2013): 339–52.11See J. Aberbach and B. Rockman, ‘Conducting and Coding Elite Interviews’, Political Science and Politics 35, no. 4 (2002): 673–6; see also A. Kezar, ‘Transformational Elite Interviews’, Qualitative Inquiry 9, no. 3 (2003): 395–415.12Interview#1 – Staff Inspector for Educational Computing, Inner London Education Authority, November 29, 2011.13Interview#2 – IT industry professional, ex-prime ministerial adviser on computing, July 7, 2011.14Interview#3 – IT industry professional/member of the Council of the British Computer Society/founder of Conservative Computer Group, June 10, 2010.15Interview#4 – Senior official, Microelectronics in Education programme, July 20, 2011.16Interview#5 – University Researcher, August 22, 2011.17Interview#2.18Ibid.19Interview#1.20The direct use of individual names has been avoided in this paper, except in the case of the government Minister for Information Technology (Kenneth Baker) who was interviewed and gave his consent to be named.21Interview#3.22Ibid.23Both quotations from interview#3.24Interview#6 – Senior Civil Servant, Department for Trade & Industry, November 22, 2011.25Interview#7 – Executive Producer, BBC Continuing Education division, July 16, 2011.26Interview#1.27In Daniel Callaghan’s account of Conservative policy-making during the 1980s, Kenneth Baker is described as being pragmatic and self-serving rather than ideologically driven. These accounts imply that Baker was keen to prove himself a ‘believer’ in the Thatcher project given his previous close alignment with Edward Heath during the 1970s. D. Callaghan, ‘The Believers: Politics and Personalities in the Making of the 1988 Education Act’, History of Education 24, no. 4 (1995): 369–85.28In Baker’s memoirs he describes the process of his appointment as Minister for IT as follows: ‘In 1980, I set out an industrial strategy in a series of articles and speeches, and specifically in a speech setting out a ten-point programme. I called for the appointment of a Minister for Information Technology … I sent my strategy paper to several Ministers, campaigned strongly for it to be accepted, and persuaded Margaret Thatcher to visit Logica, Britain’s most lively and energetic software company, to see for herself the potential for information handling…. Margaret’s visit made an impact, for in January 1981 she appointed me to the DTI with the title of Minister of State for Industry and Information Technology. This was the first time a Minister had actually written out his own job specification before being appointed’. K. Baker, The Turbulent Years: My Life in Politics (London: Faber & Faber, 1993), 57.29Interview#8 – Kenneth Baker – Minister for IT, Department for Trade & Industry, October 5, 2011.30Interview#9 – Official on NDPCAL programme/official on Microelectronics in Education programme, May 1, 2012.31Interview#9.32Interview#4.33Interview#10 – Head of Computing Education, Her Majesty’s Inspectorate/Adviser to DES, July 20, 2011.34Interview#10.35Interview#10. In Daniel Callaghan’s account of the DES at this time, the Deputy Secretary in charge of the Schools Branch (Walter Ulrich) is described as a powerful gatekeeper of incoming schools proposals – effectively vetoing policies that he considered unworkable or undesirable. D. Callaghan, Conservative Party Education Policies 1976–1997 (Brighton: Sussex Academic Press, 2006).36Interview#10.37Interview#11 – Senior Official, Microelectronics in Education programme, July 19, 2011.38Interview#10.39Interview#6.40Interview#8. In Thatcher’s memoirs she describes the Micros in School initiative as an uncontroversal ‘means of strengthening industry’ that also appealed to her personal beliefs: ‘As a scientist, I was fascinated by the technology itself; as a passionate advocate of free enterprise capitalism I was convinced that, given the right framework of laws and an appropriately educated workforce, it could widen choice, generate wealth and jobs and improve the quality of people’s lives … we all made special efforts to widen understanding of what IT could do for business. Of course, it was the young people who found it easiest to learn the new skills and one of our most valuable and appreciated initiatives was to put a desk-top computer in every secondary school.’ M. Thatcher, The Downing Street Years (London: HarperCollins, 1993), 271.41Interview#8.42Interview#6.43Ibid.44Interview#12 – Electronics teacher at independent school/developer with IT manufacturer/adviser to BBC Computer Literacy project, June 15, 2011.45Interview#6.46Interview#8.47Interview#12.48Interview#2.49Interview#7.50Interview#13 – Founder/CEO, UK IT manufacturer, November 2, 2011.51Interview#11.52Interview#4.53Interview#2.54Interview#13.55Interview#12.56Interview#10.57Daniel Callaghan describes the DES at the time as being staffed by a number of highly able and bright, but also ‘trenchant’ and ‘combative’ deputy secretaries and under secretaries, prone to blocking what they perceived as unworkable or undesirable policies. That this culture extended down from senior levels is perhaps not surprising. Callaghan, Conservative Party Education Policies, 43–5.58Interview#14 – Junior civil servant, Department for Education & Science, April 30, 2012.59Interview#5.60Interview#4.61Interview#1.62Interview#12.63Interview#14.64Interview#8.65Interview#11.66Interview#11.67Interview#6.68Interview#15 – University–based researcher, July 11, 2011.69Interview#11. The permanent secretary in the DES during the 1979 to 1983 administration is quoted in Daniel Callaghan as describing Kenneth Baker as combining personal ‘chutzpah’ with ‘political clout’. Callaghan, Conservative Party Education Policies, 80.70Interview#3.71Interview#8.72Interview#3.73Interview#1.74Interview#2.75Interview#11.76Interview#11.77Interview#4.78Interview#10.79Interview#4.80Callaghan, Conservative Party Education Policies.81J. Ozga, ‘Researching the Powerful: Seeking Knowledge about Policy’, European Educational Research Journal 10, no. 2 (2011): 222.82C. Chitty, ‘The Changing Role of the State in Education Provision’, History of Education 21, no. 1 (1992): 12.83S. Gewirtz and J. Ozga, ‘Interviewing the Policy Elite’, in Researching the Powerful in Education, ed. G. Walford (London: UCL Press, 1994), 189.84C. Batteson and S. Ball, ‘Autobiographies and Interviews as Means of ‘Access’ to Elite Policy Making in Education’, British Journal of Educational Studies 43, no. 2 (1995): 205.85P. Ribbins and B. Sherratt, ‘The Permanent Secretary as Policy-maker, Shaper, Taker, Sharer, and Resister in Education’, Journal of Educational Administration and History 45, no.1, (2013): 37.86Callaghan, Conservative Party Education Policies.87P. Ribbins and B. Sherratt, ‘Permanent Secretaries, Consensus and Centrism in National Policymaking in Education’, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership 40, no. 5 (2012): 552.88Cf. J. Fitz and D. Halpin, ‘From a “Sketchy Policy” to a “Workable Scheme”’, International Studies in Sociology of Education, 1, nos. 1–2 (1991): 129–51.89Callaghan, ‘The Believers’, 376.90G. Whitty and T. Edwards, ‘Researching Thatcherite Education Policy’ in Researching the Powerful in Education, ed. G. Walford (London: UCL Press, 1994), 14–31.91C. Batteson, ‘A Review of Politics of Education in the ‘Moment of 1976’’, British Journal of Educational Studies 45, no. 4 (1997): 363–77.92S. Ball, ‘Researching Inside the State’, in Researching Education Policy, ed. D. Halpin and B. Troyna (London: Routledge, 1994), 103.93Callaghan, Conservative Party Education Policies, chapter 3.94Ribbins and Sherratt, ‘The Permanent Secretary as Policymaker’, 32.95I. Lawrence, Power and Politics at the Department of Education & Science (London: Cassell, 1992).96Ribbins and Sherratt, ‘Permanent Secretaries, Consensus and Centrism’.97Whitty and Edwards, ‘Researching Thatcherite Education Policy’, 28.98S. Ball, ‘Political Interviews and the Politics of Interviewing’, in Researching the Powerful in Education, ed. G. Walford (London: UCL Press, 1994), 113.

HistoriographyCurriculumPoliticsSociologyPublic administrationGovernment (linguistics)Public relationsMedia studiesPolitical scienceSocial scienceLawPedagogy
Open in the catalogue DOI