Public schools and the Fleming report of 1944: shunting the first-class carriage on to an immense siding?
Abstract
This paper assesses the origins, conclusions and consequences of the Fleming Committee, which considered the relationship between Britain’s leading independent boarding schools and the state. In 1944, the committee recommended one-quarter of the places at these schools should be assigned to a national bursary scheme for children who might benefit from boarding. The author emphasises the role that Ellen Wilkinson played in implementing a Fleming-style scheme in the early years of the Attlee Government. Despite promises to the contrary, the Conservative Government that was elected in 1951 did not expand the scheme, which lingered on in a desultory form. Failure stemmed from a lack of political will, which was reinforced by a shortage of public finance, inconsistent support from independent boarding schools and local education authorities and problems over the selection of pupils. Keywords: public schoolsR.A. ButlerEllen Wilkinsondirect grant Acknowledgements The author would like to thank Clare Bottle for commenting on drafts of this article. Notes 1Spencer Leeson, The Public Schools Question (London: Longmans, 1948), 15. 2Robert Rhodes James, ed., Winston S. Churchill: His Complete Speeches, 1897–1964 (New York: Chelsea House, 1974), vol. VI, 6315. 3Edward C. Mack, Public Schools and British Opinion Since 1860 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1941), 462. 4See, for example, Kevin Jefferys, ‘RA Butler, The Board of Education and the 1944 Education Act’, History 69, no. 227 (1984): 415–31. 5Betty D. Vernon, Ellen Wilkinson (London: Croom Helm, 1982). 6Board of Education, The Public Schools and the General Education System (London: HMSO, 1944), 2. 7P.H.J.H. Gosden, Education in the Second World War (London: Methuen, 1976), 332. 8Warren Chetham Strode, The Guinea-Pig (London: Sampson Low, 1946); The Guinea Pig (Pilgrim Pictures, 1948). 9Paul Sharp et al., Working Together: the Independent/State School Partnerships Scheme (Leeds: University of Leeds, 2001). 10‘Funds are very limited but, if you can show that boarding education is essential and if there is no room for your child at one of the few schools which admit boarders in the state system, you might succeed.’ Independent Schools Council, ‘Local Authority Grants’, http://www.isc.co.uk/ParentZone_LocalAuthorityGrants.htm (accessed January 12, 2011). 11‘The Public School and the General Educational System: Report of the Fleming Committee’, undated (probably July 1944), Education Department (hereafter ED) 136/607, The National Archives: Public Record Office, Kew (hereafter TNA). 12Nicholas Timmins, The Five Giants (London: HarperCollins, 1995), 95. 13Board of Education, The Public Schools, 2. 14Board of Education, The Public Schools, 2. 16Memorandum of Evidence by Maurice Holmes, undated (probably July/August 1942), ED 12/518, TNA. 15Letter from R.A. Butler to Harry Brittain, July 9, 1942, ED 12/518, TNA. 17Gordon Robinson, Private Schools and Public Policy (Loughborough: Loughborough University of Technology, 1971), 97. 19HMC, ‘Decline in the School Population & Its Effect upon the Public Schools’, February 1939, ED 136/129, TNA. 18H.H. Hardy to Maurice Holmes, December 27, 1938, ED 136/129, TNA. 20Memorandum on the Financial Position of the Public Schools, October 4, 1941, ED 136/605, TNA. 21Memorandum by the First Commissioner of Works, September 23, 1939, ED 136/141, TNA. 22‘Difficulties of certain schools on the Headmasters Conference in respect of expenses incurred in connection with their removal’, undated (probably October 1939), ED 136/141, TNA. The concerns of the schools were met to a limited degree through the Public and Other Schools (War Conditions) Act (1941). 23Leeson to Edward Bridges, October 12, 1939, ED 136/141, TNA. 25Cyril Norwood to G.G. Williams, December 3, 1939, ED 136/141, TNA. 24Gary McCulloch, Cyril Norwood and the Ideal of Secondary Education (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007). Norwood was also Chairman of the Secondary Schools Examinations Council (1921–1946) and President of St John’s College, Oxford (1934–1946), as well as the key figure behind the Norwood report (1943) on the secondary school curriculum. 26HMC, Report of the Committee of Three, March 9, 1940, ED 12/518, TNA. 27Note on Local Conferences, July 24, 1941, ED 12/518, TNA. 28See various papers in ED 136/667. 29Public Schools Commission, First Report (London: HMSO, 1968). 30Bernard Thomas, ed., Repton: 1557–1957 (London: BT Batsford, 1957), 127–30. 31Memorandum on the Financial Position of the Public Schools, October 4, 1941, ED 136/605, TNA. 32The Problem of Public and Other Boarding Schools’, undated (probably July 1941), ED 12/518, TNA. 33Leeson, Public Schools, 15; Geoffrey Fisher, ‘Origins and Scope of the G.B.A.’, The Times, December 14, 1960. 34Geoffrey London to R.A. Butler, August 1, 1941, ED 12/518, TNA. 35‘Note by the President’, April 22, 1942, ED 12/518, TNA. 36Geoffrey London to R.A. Butler, May 2, 1942, ED 136/599, TNA. 37Board of Education, The Public Schools, 2. See, for example, Clive Griggs, ‘The Trades Union Congress and the Public Schools 1870–1970’, in Geoffrey Walford, British Private Schools (London: Woburn Press, 2003), 41. 38Parliamentary Debates (Commons), 381, July 2, 1942, 482–4. 39Board of Education, The Public Schools, 1. 40R.A. Butler to Sir Cyril Norwood, June 8, 1942, ED 136/681, TNA. 41John Simon to R.A. Butler, May 27, 1942, ED 136/599, TNA. 42Board of Education, Abolition of Tuition Fees in Grant-Aided Secondary Schools (London: HMSO, 1943). This includes a minority report written by seven members of the committee, including the Chairman, that was more sympathetic to the retention of fees. 43Board of Education, The Public Schools, 66. 44Anthony Howard, RAB: The Life of R.A. Butler (London: Jonathan Cape, 1987), 121; Paul Addison, The Road to 1945 (London: Jonathan Cape, 1975), 239. 45Board of Education, The Public Schools, 72–4. 46J.F. Wolfenden, The Public Schools To-Day (London: University of London Press, 1948), 19. 47‘Fleming Report: The Public Schools and General Educational System’, July 24, 1944, ED 136/607, TNA. 48McCulloch, Norwood, 149. 49Quoted in Robinson, Private Schools, 91. 50Paul Sharp, ‘Central and Local Government’, in A Century of Education, ed. Richard Aldrich (London: RoutledgeFalmer, 2002), 104. 51Griggs, ‘Trades Union Congress’, 43. 52Gosden, Education, 355. 53HMSO, Education Act (1944), Section 8(2)(d). 54For example, according to a wartime note, ‘in exceptional cases, pupils are sent as boarders to Secondary Schools on account of the remoteness of their homes’. G.G. Williams, ‘The Place of Boarding Schools in a Federal System of Secondary Education’, undated, ED 12/518. 56R.A. Butler to G.M. Young, September 14, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. Pupils tended to join public schools when aged 13, but to leave elementary schools when aged 11. This left a two-year gap for Fleming-style bursaries that prep schools were keen to help fill, although the Fleming report declared this should only happen where a prep school was deemed to be efficient and was not run for private profit. These criteria were unpopular among some prep school headmasters. See Vyvyen Brendon, Prep School Children (London: Continuum, 2009), 138, and Donald Leinster-Mackay, The Rise of the English Prep School (London: Falmer, 1984), 272. 55Various submissions to the Fleming Committee, ED 12/518, TNA. 57‘Minutes of a Special General Meeting of the GBA’, 4 October 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 58Leeson to R.A. Butler, October 17, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 59GBGSA, ‘Resolutions’, October 6, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA; Association of Head Mistresses of Boarding Schools, ‘Resolutions’, October 11, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA; Association of Head Mistresses of Independent and Direct Grant Schools, ‘Resolutions’, October 26, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 60‘T.U.C. on Labour Reforms’, The Times, October 5, 1944. 61National Union of Teachers, ‘Public Schools and the General Educational System’, November 4, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 62‘Demand for more Treasury responsibility’, The Times, January 3, 1945; ‘Woman Teacher’s View’, The Times, April 5, 1945. 63Mr. Sharam’, September 16, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 64David Butler and Gareth Butler, Twentieth-Century British Political Facts 1900–2000 (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 2000), 190. 65Sir George Schuster to R.A. Butler, 29 November 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 66Gosden, Education, 356–63. 67Ministry of Education, ‘Education Act, 1944: Draft Regulation under Section 81 Scholarships and Other Benefits’, Circular 26, March 13, 1945, 2. 68‘Public Schools and Bursaries’, The Times, March 24, 1945. 69‘Report of the Committee Appointed By the Minister of Education To consider in detail the recommendations of Scheme B as set out in the Fleming Committee’s Report’, August 1945, ED 136/607, TNA. 71Michael Parkinson, The Labour Party and the Organization of Secondary Education 1918–65 (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1970), 104. 70Brian Simon, Education and the Social Order, 1940–1990 (London: Lawrence & Wishart, 1991), 137. 72Ministry of Education, ‘Development Plans: Date of submission and form of plans’, Circular 90, March 8, 1946, 4. 73Ministry of Education, ‘Boarding Education’, Circular 120, August 19, 1946, 2. 74Public Schools Commission, First Report, 19. 75The Assisted Places Scheme was a national scheme, but it was for day pupils – help with boarding fees was sometimes available from schools’ own budgets, but only around 6% of beneficiaries boarded; Tony Edwards, John Fitz and Geoff Whitty, The State and Private Education (London: Falmer, 1989), 88–9. 76Lady Simon of Wythenshawe, ‘Labour and the Public Schools’, Tribune, June 25, 1948, 11. 79Labour Party, Labour and the New Society (London: Labour Party, 1950), 15. 77Parliamentary Debates (Commons), 476, June 13, 1950, 14. 78Robinson, Private Schools, 95–6. 80H. Raymond King, ‘Changes in School Organisation, Curricula and Methods’, in The Year Book of Education 1952 (London: Evans Brothers, 1952), 155. 81John Cole, ‘The Fleming Report’, Guardian, April 9, 1957, 11. 82King, ‘Changes’, 155. 83Board of Education, The Public Schools, 56. 84David Parker, John Newsom (Hatfield: University of Hertfordshire, 2005), 98, 192. 85‘Boarding Education’, TES, September 25, 1948, 545. 86Royston Lambert, The State and Boarding Education (London: Methuen, 1966), 33–5. Bury apparently supported no boarding pupils. 87‘Boarders’, TES, September 25, 1948, 545. 88Lambert, State and Boarding Education, 37; Daphne Johnson, Private Schools and State Schools (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1987), 48; Robin Williams, Whose Public Schools? (London: Bow Group, 1957), 52. 89Conservative Party, Campaign Guide 1950 (London: Conservative and Unionist Central Office, 1949), 430. 90John Cole, ‘The Fleming Report’, Guardian, April 9, 1957. 91‘Comment in Brief’, The Times Educational Supplement (hereafter TES), October 17, 1952, 837. 92Parliamentary Debates (Commons), 513, April 2, 1953 179. In the same year, the Education (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act (1953) said LEAs arranging boarding places in independent and direct grant schools must cover the entire boarding costs, with no parental contribution, when suitable non-boarding education was unavailable for the relevant pupils. 93‘From State to Public Schools’, The Times, December 3, 1953. 94M.L. Jacks, Letter to the Editor, The Times, December 8, 1953. 95‘A Revised “Fleming” Scheme’, The Times, February 5, 1954. 96F.F. Turnbull, ‘H.P. (55) 86—Public Schools’, November 24, 1955, Her Majesty’s Treasury (hereafter T) 227/573, TNA. 97Williams, Public Schools, 49. 98John Cole, ‘Minister’s doubts’, Guardian, April 10, 1957, 18. 99Brief for the Chancellor of the Exchequer, May 15, 1958, T 227/573, TNA; Minutes of the Cabinet Committee on Educational Policy, May 19, 1958, T 227/573, TNA. 100GBA/GBGSA, Future Policy for Admission to the Public Schools, May 1959. 101Parliamentary Debates (Commons), 642, June 16, 1961, 898. 102John Rae, Public School Revolution (London: Faber & Faber, 1981), 85. 103Labour Party, Challenge to Britain (London: Labour Party, 1953), 22. 104Labour Party, Report of the Fifty-Second Annual Conference of the Labour Party (London: Labour Party, 1953), 172, 173. 105John Hipkin, ‘Integration: The Fleming Response’, in Royston Lambert, John Hipkin and Susan Stagg, New Wine in Old Bottles?: Studies in Integration within the Public Schools (London: G. Bell & Sons, 1968), 96. 106Public Schools Commission, First Report, 99. There were additionally 4254 pupils boarding in direct grant schools who received some public help, along with 11,244 pupils in maintained schools. The figures do not include children who were given help with boarding costs because of special educational needs. The maintained school figure is for 1967. 107Hipkin, ‘Integration’, 123. 108Hipkin, ‘Integration’, 97. 109Rae, Public School Revolution, 56. 110R.H. Tawney, The Problem of the Public Schools (London: Workers’ Educational Association, 1944), 25; Board of Education, The Public Schools, 75–6. 111‘National Union of Teachers: Interview Memorandum’, November 30, 1944, ED 12/518, TNA. 112Parliamentary Debates (Lords), 273, February 23, 1966, 227. 113Leeson, Public Schools, 15. 114Simon Batten, A Shining Light: 150 Years of Bloxham School (London: James & James, 2010), 64. 115E.R.G. Heath, ‘A Secondary Schoolboy’s View’, The Spectator, April 19, 1940, 552. 116GBA/GBGSA, Future Policy, 1. 117Headmasters’ Conference, Report of the Annual Meeting 1961, 16–37, 95. 118Peter Preston, ‘Conflict on Boarding School Places’, Guardian, December 10, 1965. 119‘Grants for Boarders’, TES, October 17, 1952, 846. 120Lambert, State and Boarding Education, 20, 37, 38. 121Hipkin, ‘Integration’, 102–5. 122Ministry of Education, ‘Boarding Education’, Circular 120, August 19, 1946, 2. 123Ministry of Education, ‘Boarding Education: The Principles of Selection’, Administrative Memorandum No. 225, May 9, 1947; Ministry of Education, ‘Assistance to Pupils at Direct Grant and Independent Day and Boarding Schools’, Administrative Memorandum No. 244, September 5, 1947. 124Revd George Snow, ‘The State Should Pay its Fair Share of School Fees’, Daily Telegraph and Morning Post, June 18, 1949, 4. 125Ministry of Education, Assistance with the Cost of Boarding Education (London: HMSO, 1960); Lambert, State and Boarding Education, 8–9, 14. 126Johnson, Private Schools, 46. 127‘Comment in Brief’, TES, October 17, 1952, 837. 128Hipkin, ‘Integration’, 125. 129Association of Education Committees, Boarding Education (London: ACE, 1965), 3. 130‘Boarders’, TES, September 25, 1948, 545. 131J. Stuart Maclure, Educational Documents (London: Methuen, 1979), 212. 132Nicholas Hillman, ‘The Public Schools Commission: “impractical, expensive, and harmful to children”?’, Contemporary British History 24, no. 4 (2010): 511–31. 133‘Was it Worth While?’, TES, May 28, 1965, 1677. 134 When Wesley went to Winchester (BBC Radio 4, 2011). 135‘The Direct Grant schools, abolished by Labour, gave wider opportunities for bright children from modest backgrounds. The Direct Grant principle will therefore be restored with an Assisted Places Scheme.’ Conservative Party, ‘The Conservative Party Manifesto’, in British General Election Manifestos 1959–1987, ed. F.W.S. Craig (Aldershot: Parliamentary Research Services, 1990), 279. 136Claire Maxwell et al., Boarding School Provision for Vulnerable Children (London: Institute of Education, 2009); Anthony Seldon, ‘Boarding’, in Academies and the Future of State Education, ed. Julian Astle and Conor Ryan (London: CentreForum, 2008), 64–71. 137See, for example, ‘Onwards and upwards’, The Sunday Times, January 16, 2011. 138R.A. Butler to H.C. Dent, July 10, 1942, ED 136/599, TNA. 139Lord Butler, The Art of the Possible (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1971), 121.