Educational attainment in South Africa: a view from the census 1865–2011
Abstract
Population censuses record considerable volumes of personal information, which when aggregated and tabulated provide significant insights into national societies. South African censuses have recorded levels of educational attainment since their inception in the mid-nineteenth century, initially measuring literacy and later the level of education completed. The statistics demonstrate deep long-term inequalities within South African society and the changing emphases placed upon them by governments of widely varying viewpoints. Temporal changes have been of constant concern, with the comparison of the results of one census with another to assess the effectiveness of government programmes. However, it has been the differences based on race or population group that have attracted most attention and remain the most contentious in the post-apartheid era. The census collects comprehensive statistical information independent of other sources and so provides a highly valuable and reliable record for a wide variety of investigations.Keywords: South Africacensuseducational attainmentracial inequalitystatistical record AcknowledgementThe financial assistance of the National Research Foundation towards the costs of this research is hereby acknowledged. The opinions expressed in this article and the conclusions arrived at are those of the author and are not necessarily to be attributed to the National Research Foundation.Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.Notes1 J. Scott, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition have Failed (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998).2 E. Higgs, Life, Death and Statistics: Civil Registration, Censuses and the Work of the General Register Office 1836–1952 (Hatfield: Local Population Studies, University of Hertfordshire, 2004).3 S. Szreter, H. Sholkamy and A. Dharmalingam, Categories and Contexts: Anthropological and Historical Studies in Critical Demography (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004), 16.4 B. Anderson, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism (London: Verso, 1991); K. Levithan, A Cultural History of the British Census: Envisioning the Multitude in the Nineteenth Century (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2011).5 D. I. Kertzer and D. Arel, Census and Identity: The Politics of Race, Ethnicity and Language in National Censuses (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002).6 P. Weller, ‘Identity, Politics, and the Future(s) of Religion in the UK: The Case of the Religion Questions in the 2001 Decennial Census’, Journal of Contemporary Religion 19, no. 1 (2004): 3–217 I. White and E. McLaren, ‘The 2011 Census Taking Shape: The Selection of Topics and Questions’, Population Trends 135 (2009): 8–19.8 D. Dorling, ‘The 2011 Census: What Surprises are Emerging and how they Show that Cancellation is Stupid’, Radical Statistics 109 (2013): 4–12.9 J. L. Rury, A. Saatcioglu and W.P. Skorupski, ‘Expanding Secondary Attainment in the United States 1940–80’, Historical Methods 43, no. 3 (2010): 139–52.10 A. J. Christopher, ‘The Religious Question in the United Kingdom Census 1801–2011’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History 65, no. 3 (2014): 601–19.11 A. J. Christopher, ‘The “Religion” Question in British Colonial and Commonwealth Censuses 1820s–2010s’, Journal of Religious History 38, no. 4 (2014): 579–96.12 S. A. McDaniel and H. MacDonald, ‘To Know Ourselves – Not’, Canadian Journal of Sociology 37, no. 3 (2012): 253–71; M. Walton-Roberts, R. Beaujot, D. Hiebert, S. McDaniel, D. Rose and R. Wright, ‘Why do we Still Need a Census? Views from the Age of “Truthiness” and the “Death of Evidence”’, Canadian Geographer 58, no. 1 (2014): 34–47.13 M. Campbell-Kelly, M. Croarkin, R. Flood and E. Robson, The History of Mathematical Tables: From Sumer To Spreadsheets (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003).14 A. R. H. Baker, ‘The Dead Don’t Answer Questionnaires: Researching and Writing Historical Geography’, Journal of Geography in Higher Education 21, no. 2 (1997): 231–43.15 C. Hakim, ‘Census Reports as Documentary Evidence: The Census Commentaries 1801–1951’, Sociological Review 28, no. 3 (1980): 551–80; M. Dinan, Mauritius in the Making across the Censuses 1846–2000 (Port Louis: Nelson Mandela Centre for African Culture, 2002).16 E. Higgs, Making Sense of the Census Revisited: Census Records for England and Wales 1801–1901, A Handbook for Historical Researchers (London: University of London, Institute of Historical Research, 2005).17 E. A. Wrigley, Nineteenth Century Society: Essays in the Use of Quantitative Methods for the Study of Social Data (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1972).18 J. Long, ‘The Socioeconomic Return on Primary Schooling in Victorian England’, Journal of Economic History 66, no. 4 (2006): 1026–53; D. Mitch, ‘Literacy and Occupational Mobility in Rural Versus Urban Victorian England: Evidence from the Linked Marriage and Census Records for Birmingham and Norfolk 1851 and 1881’, Historical Methods 38, no. 1 (2005): 26–38.19 For example: B.W. Higman, The Jamaican Censuses of 1844 and 1861 (Mona: Department of History, University of the West Indies, 1987); M. R. Sainty and K. A. Johnson, Census of New South Wales, November 1828 (Sydney: Library of Australian History, 1980).20 C. Hall, ‘Making Colonial Subjects: Education in the Age of Empire’, History of Education 37, no. 6 (2008): 773–87; K. Mwiria, ‘Education for Subordination: African Education in Colonial Kenya’, History of Education 20, no. 3 (1991): 261–73; C.M. White, ‘Historicizing Educational Disparity: Colonial Policy and Fijian Educational Attainment’, History of Education 32, no. 4 (2003): 345–65.21 I. Seri-Hersch, ‘Towards Social Progress and Post-Imperial Modernity? Colonial Politics of Literacy in the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan, 1946–1956’, History of Education 40, no. 3 (2011): 333–56.22 V. Carpentier, ‘Quantitative Sources for the History of Education’, History of Education 37, no. 5 (2008): 701–20.23 An example relevant to this paper is presented by T. L. Zuze and V. Reddy, ‘School Resources and the Gender Reading Literacy Gap in South African Schools’, International Journal of Educational Development 36, no. 1 (2014): 100–7.24 B. Fleisch, J. Shindler and H. Perry, ‘Who is Out of School? Evidence from the Statistics South Africa Community Survey’, International Journal of Educational Development 32, no. 4 (2012): 529–36.25 South Africa, Census of the Union of South Africa 1911, Report U.G.32-1912 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1913), xli–xliii. School attendance figures derived from the occupational tables and the parallel schools’ survey showed marked discrepancies.26 Z. George, ‘“Ghost” Pupils Cost E Cape almost R91m: Deserving Schools to Benefit from Future Saving’, Daily Dispatch (East London), December 5, 2011, 4.27 P. de Wet, ‘Anomalies could Disadvantage Some Provinces: The Results Mean a Huge Shift in the Amount of Money Disbursed, Which Will Have a Major Effect on the Regions’, Mail & Guardian (Johannesburg), November 2–8, 2012, 12.28 E. J. Pretorius, ‘Editorial Preface: An Introduction to Literacy in the African Learning Environment – Challenges and Changes’, Language Matters 33, no. 1 (2002): vii.29 United Kingdom, Census of the British Empire 1901, Report with Summary Cd2660 (London: His Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1906), lii–lvi.30 D. Posel, ‘Adult Literacy Rates in South Africa: A Comparison of Different Measures’, Language Matters 42, no. 1 (2011): 39–49.31 A. J. Christopher, ‘The Quest for a Census of the British Empire c.1840–1940’, Journal of Historical Geography 34, no. 2 (2008): 268–85.32 M. F. Stieg, ‘The Nineteenth Century Information Revolution’, Journal of Library History 15, no. 1 (1980): 22–52.33 Statistical Society of London, ‘Report to the Council of the Statistical Society of London, from the Committee Appointed to Consider the Best Mode of Taking the Census of the United Kingdom in 1841’, Journal of the Statistical Society of London 3, no. 1 (1840): 98.34 United Kingdom, Report of the Commissioners appointed to take the Census of Ireland for the year 1841 (Dublin: Alexander Thom, 1843), vi.35 United States, Measuring America: The Decennial Censuses from 1790 to 2000 (Washington, DC: US Census Bureau, 2002), 9.36 United Kingdom, Report… Ireland, xl.37 National Archives, Kew, London (TNA), CO/854/4 Circular Despatches to Colonial Governors, January 20, 1849, 58.38 United Kingdom, Census of Great Britain 1851, Education, England and Wales, Report and Tables (London: George Eyre and William Spottiswoode, 1854).39 J. M. Goldstrom, ‘Education in England and Wales in 1851: The Education Census of Great Britain 1851’, in The Census of Social Structure: An Interpretative Guide to Nineteenth Century Censuses for England and Wales, ed. R. Lawton (London: Routledge, 1978), 224–40.40 New South Wales, Census of the Colony of New South Wales 1861 (Sydney: Government Printer, 1862), 16.41 South Australia, Census of the Province of South Australia 1861 (Adelaide: Government Printer, 1862), xv.42 United Kingdom, Census of England and Wales 1911, General Report Cd8491 (London: His Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1917), 380–383.43 Most census organisations maintain internet websites including census questionnaires and a range of results, for example: England and Wales (www.statistics.gov.uk), Scotland (www.rgo-scotland.gov.uk), Canada (www.statcan.co.ca), Australia (www.abs.gov.au), New Zealand (www.statsgovt.nz), South Africa (www.statssa.gov.za), India (www.censusindia.net), Pakistan (www.census.gov.pk), Sri Lanka (www.statistics.gov.lk) and Singapore (www.singstat.gov.sg).44 A. J. Christopher, ‘“To Define the Indefinable”: Population Classification and the Census in South Africa’, Area 34, no. 4 (2002): 401–8. It should be noted that the term ‘Kafir’, used in the Cape colonial censuses, denoted a Xhosa-speaking person, and had not taken on the highly derogatory connotations now attached to it.45 M. Borman, The Cape Education Department 1839–1989 (Cape Town: Cape Education Department, 1989).46 J. Fourie, R. Ross and R. Vijoen, ‘Literacy at South African Mission Stations’, Journal of Southern African Studies 40, no. 4 (2014): 781–800.47 A. L. Behr, Education in South Africa: Origins, Issues and Trends 1652–1988 (Pretoria: Academica, 1988).48 Cape of Good Hope, Correspondence relative to a Proposal from the Government of Australia for taking a Census of the British Colonies generally in 1861 (Cape Town: Saul Solomon, 1860).49 Cape of Good Hope, Bill For Providing for taking a census of the population of the Colony of the Cape of Good Hope (1861) Government Gazette (Cape Town: Saul Solomon, 20 March 1860), 2–4. An occupation question also identified children at school, a practice that was repeated in all subsequent censuses.50 Cape of Good Hope, Census of the Colony of the Cape of Good Hope 1865 G.20-’66 (Cape Town: Saul Solomon, 1866).51 The 1951 census report noted that: ‘literacy is defined as the ability to read and write any language. Those who can only read, are regarded as illiterate and are not included in the tables’ (South Africa, Population Census 1951, Volume VI: Languages and Literacy (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1958), viii). This definition has been adopted throughout this article. Most censuses, until 1991, published only the numbers, so that for comparisons to be made the percentages have to be calculated by the individual reader. Percentages stated have therefore been calculated by the author.52 Cape of Good Hope, Census of the Colony of the Cape of Good Hope 1875, Part I Summaries G.42-’76 (Cape Town: Saul Solomon, 1876), 3.53 Cape of Good Hope, Census of the Colony of the Cape of Good Hope 1875, Part II Supplementary Tables G.42-’76 (Cape Town: Saul Solomon, 1878).54 Pakistan, Census of Pakistan 1951, Volume I: Pakistan (Karachi: Manager of Publications, 1955), 76.55 Cape of Good Hope, Results of a Census of the Cape of Good Hope 1891, G.6-’92 (Cape Town: Government Printers, 1892).56 Cape of Good Hope, Census of the Colony of the Cape of Good Hope 1904, G.19-1905 (Cape Town: Government Printer, 1905), lxxxv. The census director made the comparison using the wider definition of literacy to include those who could only read, but not write, where the figures showed 29.9% could read in 1865 but only 27.7% in 1904.57 Natal, Census of the Colony of Natal 1904 (Pietermaritzburg: Government Printers, 1905). The 1891 census of Natal did not include a question on education.58 Orange Free State, Verslag van den Census 1890 (Bloemfontein: C. Borckenhagen, 1890). A summary of the results of the 1880 census is included.59 Orange River Colony, Census of the Orange River Colony 1904 (Bloemfontein: Government Printer, 1905).60 Transvaal, Results of a Census of the Transvaal Colony and Swaziland 1904 (London: Waterlow, 1906). The 1890 census of the Transvaal had not included a question on education.61 A. J. Christopher, ‘A South African Domesday Book: the first Union census of 2011’, South African Geographical Journal 92, no. 1 (2010): 22–34.62 South Africa, Census of the Union of South Africa 1911, Part III: Education of the People U.G.32b-1912 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1912).63 South Africa, Census of the White Races of the Union of South Africa 1918, Final Report and Supplementary Tables U.G.56-1920 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1920), 41.64 J.-P. Beaud and J. G. Prévost, ‘Statistics as Science of Government: The Stillborn British Statistical Bureau 1918–20’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 33, no. 3 (2005): 369–91.65 South Africa, Third Census of the Union of South Africa 1921, Part X Report, U.G.37-1924 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1924).66 South Africa, Third Census of the Union of South Africa 1921, Part VIII: Non-European Races U.G.46-’23 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1923).67 TNA RG19/56 General Register Office correspondence, C. W. Cousins to S. P. Vivian, September 16, 1921.68 South Africa, Fourth Census of the Union of South Africa 1926, Volume XIII: Summaries and Analysis U.G.4-’31 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1931); South Africa, Fifth Census of the Union of South Africa 1931, Summaries and Analysis U.G.11-1933 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1933). No concluding report was written on the 1941 census.69 South Africa, Sixth Census of the Union of South Africa 1936, Volume IX: Native (Bantu) and Other Non-European Races U.G12/42 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1942).70 South Africa, Population Census 1946, Volume IV: Languages and Literacy U.G.18/1954 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1954).71 South Africa, Population Census 1951, Volume VI: Languages and Literacy U.G.64/1958 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1958).72 S. A. Hlatshwayo, Education and Independence: Education in South Africa 1658–1988 (Westport CT: Greenwood, 2000).73 O. Crankshaw, Race, Class and the Changing Division of Labour under Apartheid (London: Routledge, 1997).74 South Africa, Population Census 1960, Volume 4: Education (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1967), viii.75 South Africa, Population Census 1970, Level of Education Report 02-05-07 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1975).76 South Africa, Population Census 1970, Xhosa Report 02-02-03 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1976) and the consecutively numbered reports (02-02-04 to 02-02-14) for the South Ndebele, Seshoeshoe, Tswana, Shangaan, Venda, Zulu, Sepedi, Swazi, North Ndebele, Other than South African Bantu language, and Foreign Bantu respectively.77 South Africa, Population Census 1991, Adjustment for Undercount Report 03-01-26(1991) (Pretoria: Central Statistical Services, 1992), 22.78 South Africa, Population Census 1991, Level of Education Report 03-01-07(1991) (Pretoria: Central Statistical Services, 1992). A further 21.5% of the White population had completed Standard 8 for the Junior Certificate, a recognised qualification for a wide range of mid-level jobs. It must be noted that the percentages cover the whole range of ages, including pre-school children.79 South Africa, Population Census 1980, Level of Education Report 02-80-07 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1985); South Africa, 1986. Population Census 1985, Level of Education Report 02-85-04 (Pretoria: Government Printer, 1986).80 African National Congress, The Reconstruction and Development Programme (Johannesburg: Umanyano Publications, 1994); South Africa, The National Development Plan RP270/2011 (Pretoria: National Planning Commission, 2011).81 J. J. Booyse, B. S. Le Roux, J. Seroto and C. C. Wolhuter, A History of Schooling in South Africa: Method and Context (Pretoria: Van Schaik, 2011).82 South Africa, Census 2001: Primary Tables, South Africa, Census ’96 and Census 2001 Compared, Report No. 03-02-04(2001) (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2004).83 South Africa, Achieving a Better Life for All, Progress between Census ’96 and Census 2001, Report 03-02-16(2001) (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2005), 48.84 E. B. Fiske and H. F. Ladd, Elusive Equity: Education Reform in Post-apartheid South Africa (Cape Town: HSRC Press, 2005), 232–48.85 South Africa, Census 2011 Statistical Release P0301.4 (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2012), 32–8.86 L. A. Staeheli and D. Hammett, ‘“For the Future of the Nation”: Citizenship, Nation and Education in South Africa’, Political Geography 32, no. 1 (2013): 32–41.87 South Africa, Census 2011 Community profiles in SuperCross Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, http://interactive.statssa.gov.za/superweb/setTableState.do?x=0&waferselected=2 and =3 (accessed 22 January 2014).88 South Africa, Census 2011, P0301.4, 39–40.89 E. Unterhalter, ‘Measuring Education for the Millennium Development Goals: Reflections on Targets, Indicators, and a Post-2015 Framework’, Journal of Human Development and Capabilities 15, no. 2–3 (2014): 176–87.90 South Africa, Census 2011, User Consultation on Data Items (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2008), 5.91 South Africa, General Household Survey 2011, Statistical Release PO318 (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2012), 14.92 South Africa, Census 2011, Household Questionnaire (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2011), A07.93 South Africa, General Household Survey, 66–7. The figures presented here are taken from the General Household Survey, conducted by Statistics South Africa parallel with the census and asking exactly the same literacy questions. The corresponding census figures have not yet been published, but preliminary calculations suggest that they are close to those of the published General Household Survey (personal correspondence June 5, 2014).94 P. Dobraszczyk, ‘“Give in your Account”: Using and Abusing Victorian Census Forms’, Journal of Victorian Culture 14, no. 1 (2009): 1–25.95 South Africa, Census 2011, User Consultation, 23.