The response of the Roman Catholic Church to the introduction of vocational education in Ireland 1930–1942
Abstract
This paper discusses the manner in which the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland attempted to impose denominational control on the system of vocational education introduced by the state in 1930. Considerable research on education has been conducted within the period in question; however, the area addressed in this paper has been largely neglected by scholars in the field. The position of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland is examined in the context of Church–state relations within Europe with particular reference to the issue of control in education. The paper argues that the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland sought denominational control over vocational education through the introduction of various amendments to legislation dealing with the system. Keywords: church and stateeducation controlvocational educationeducation policyIreland Notes 1J. Goldthrope, 'The Uses of History in Sociology: Reflections on Some Recent Tendencies', British Journal of Sociology 42, no. 2 (1991): 211–30. 2Paul Smeyers and Marc Depaepe, 'A Method Has Been Found? On Educational Research and its Methodological Preoccupations', Paedagogica Historica 44, no. 6 (2008): 625–33. 3C.J. Bermejo-Barrera, 'Making History, Talking about History', History and Theory 40 (2001): 190–205. 4I. Grosvenor and K. Myers, 'Progressivism, Control and Correction: Local Education Authorities and Educational Policy in Twentieth-century England', Paedagogica Historica 42, nos. 1&2 (2006): 225–47. 5Charles Tilly, 'How (and What) are Historians doing', American Behavioral Scientist 33, no. 6 (1990): 685–711. 6A. Hyland and Milne, Irish Educational Documents, Vol. 11 (Dublin: Church of Ireland College of Education, 1992), 7. 7M. Conway, Catholic Politics in Europe 1918–1945 (London: Routledge, 1997), 100. 8Conway, Catholic Politics in Europe 1918–1945, 11. 9Ibid. 10Conway, Catholic Politics in Europe 1918–1945, 13. 11Conway, Catholic Politics in Europe 1918–1945, 14. 12Conway, Catholic Politics in Europe 1918–1945, 32. 13Ibid. 14Conway, Catholic Politics in Europe 1918–1945, 42. 15A. Ferrari, 'The Problem of Civic Cohesion and The Role of the State School in France and Italy: Historical, Religious and Secular Comparisons', Journal of Moral Education 35, no. 4 (2006): 533–50. 16Ibid., 541. 17Ibid. 18T.O. Donoghue and J. Harford, 'Comparative History of Church–State Relations in Irish Education', Comparative Education Review 55, no. 3 (2011): 315–41. 19L. Fuller, Irish Catholicism since 1950: The Undoing of a Culture (Dublin: Gill and Macmillan, 2002), 3. 20Ibid., 69. 21Ibid., 69. 22The Irish Free State (Gaelic: Saorstát Éireann) was the name of the Republic of Ireland from 1922 to 1937. 23J.J. Lee, Ireland 1912–85, Politics and Society (Cambridge University Press, 1989), 77. 24Ibid., 77. 25Cumann na nGaedheal was formally launched on 27 April 1923, from the pro-Treaty wing of Sinn Féin which had been running the country since the split in the party. It continued in power until 1932 when it was defeated at a general election by Fianna Fáil, formed in 1927 from the anti-Treaty Sinn Féin. 26Lee, Ireland 1912–85, Politics and Society, 77. 27F.S.L. Lyons, Ireland Since the Famine (London: Fontana, 1971), 609. 28Lee, Ireland 1912–85, Politics and Society, 119. 29Lyons, Ireland Since the Famine, 609. 30Ibid, 609. 31Lee, Ireland 1912–85, Politics and Society, 80. 32S.O. Buachalla, Educational Policy in Twentieth Century Ireland (Dublin: Wolfhound, 1988), 60. 33Lee, Ireland 1912–85, Politics and Society, 130. 34Ibid, 130. 35T. O'Donoghue, The Catholic Church and the Secondary School Curriculum in Ireland 1922–1962 (New York: Peter Lang Publishing, 1999),141. 36Ibid., 145. 37Ibid., 146. 38B. Titley, Church, State and the Control of Schooling in Ireland 1900–1944 (New York: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1983), 5. 39W. Dietrich Greinert, Mass Vocational Education and Training in Europe: Classical Modes of the 19th Century and Training in England, France and Germany during the First Half of the 20th , Cedefop Panorama Series 118 (Luxembourg: Official Publications of the European Communities, 2005), 12. 40Ibid., 15. 41Ibid., 84. 42Ibid., 88. 43Ibid., 90. 44Ibid., 93. 45Ibid., 108. 46G. Gooze, The Development of TAFE in Australia. A historical perspective. (Kensington Park, South Australia: National Cenre for Vocational Eductaion Research, 1993), 8. 47J. Coolahan, Irish Education History and Structure (Dublin: Institute of Public Administration, 1981), 94. 48W. Mulcahy, 'Rural Vocational Schools' (Master of Arts in Education dissertation, University College Dublin, 1942), 26. 49Minister for Education Mr J. M. O'Sullivan, introducing the Vocational Education Act into the Dail 1930, Dail Debates 1809. 50Hyland and Milne, Irish Educational Documents, Vol. 11, 214. 51Ibid, 214. 52Ibid, 214. 53Archbishop Byrne's Papers, Letters to the Department of Education 1922–1939, in Diocesan Archives, Archbishop's House, Drumcondra, Dublin 3. 54Extract from Letter from the Minister for Education, J. M. O' Sullivan, to Most Rev. D. Keane, Bishop of Limerick, dated October 31, 1930, quoted in Hyland and Milne, Irish Educational Documents 2, 219. 55Department of Education, Vocational Continuation Schools and Classes: Memorandum for the Information of Committees, 1931. 56This second Cumann na nGaedheal party was formed by pro-Treaty Sinn Féin TDs in Dáil Éireann in Dublin on 27 April 1923 and until 1932 it formed the Government of the Irish Free State. 57T. Garvin, Preventing the Future: Why was Ireland so Poor for so Long? (Dublin: Gill & Macmillan, 2004), 136. 58Part of Correspondence between Mr Sesame O Neil and Archbishop McQuaid dated July 25, 1941 in McQuaid Papers Reference AB 8/B, Government Box 7. 59Fianna Fáil (Gaelic Term translated as Soldiers of Destiny) was founded in 1926 by Eamonn de Valera as a result of a split within Sinn Fein, which refused to enter the Dáil (parliament) following the establishment of the Irish Free State under the 1921 Anglo-Irish Treaty. It attracted the majority of Sinn Fein's support and became the main opposition party. 60Bunreacht na hÉireann, the Constitution of Ireland, is the basic law of Ireland. No law can be passed which does not agree with it. The Constitution can be changed only by a referendum in which every citizen of Ireland, over the age of 18, is entitled to vote. The Constitution was passed in a referendum on July 1, 1937. It came into operation on December 29, 1937. The present Constitution replaced the Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Éireann) which came into existence in 1922. Article 42 deals with Education. Article 3 1° The State shall not oblige parents in violation of their conscience and lawful preference to send their children to schools established by the State, or to any particular type of school designated by the State. 2° The State shall, however, as guardian of the common good, require in view of actual conditions that the children receive a certain minimum education, moral, intellectual and social. Article 4 The State shall provide for free primary education and shall endeavour to supplement and give reasonable aid to private and corporate educational initiative, and, when the public good requires it, provide other educational facilities or institutions with due regard, however, for the rights of parents, especially in the matter of religious and moral formation. 61Article 44 of the constitution mentions the special position of the Holy Catholic and Apostolic and Roman Church as the guardian of the Faith professed by the great majority of the citizens. In December 1972 this clause under article 44 were deleted by referendum as a gesture towards Protestant susceptibilities under the impact of the crisis in Northern Ireland. See Ronan Fanning, Independent Ireland (Dublin: Helicon, 1983), 130. 62Dr John Charles McQuaid became Archbishop of Dublin in 1940. 63B. Girvin, 'The State and Vocational Education 1922–1960', in Teachers' Union The TUI and its forerunners 1899–1994, ed. J. Logan (Dublin: Farmar 1999), 76. 64Ibid, 76. 65Ibid, 76. 66B. O Reilly, 'Vocational Education and Society in Ireland 1930–1990: A Case Study in the Politics of Education' (PhD dissertation, University of Edinburgh, 1998), 268. 67Girvin, 'The State and Vocational Education 1922–1960', 76. 68Ibid, 76. 69 Memorandum submitted by Fr. Martin Brenan, Professor of Education at Maynooth, to Archbishop John Charles McQuaid on 16th May 1942, Ref AB8/B Government, Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 70Ibid. 71Ibid. 72Ibid. 74Ibid. Garvin, Preventing the Future: Why was Ireland so Poor for so Long?, 138, inaccurately attributes the authorship of this analysis to McQuaid. By doing so he has missed the subtlety of the approach adopted by the Catholic Church in the promotion of its sustained opposition to the vocational education system over a long period of time. 75 Memorandum submitted by Fr. Martin Brenan, Professor of Education at Maynooth, to Archbishop John Charles McQuaid on 16th May 1942, Ref AB8/B Government, Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 73Ibid. 76Ibid. 77Garvin, Preventing the Future: Why was Ireland so poor for so long?, 138. 78Hyland and Milne, Irish Educational Documents 2, 224. 79 Letter from J P Hackett to Archbishop McQuaid on 25th March 1942, McQuaid Papers Ref. AB 8/B Government Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 80Ibid. 81 Letter from Fr Martin Brenan, Professor of Education, Maynooth to Archbishop McQuaid 16th May 1942, Reference, AB 8/B Government Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 82Ibid. 83Ibid. 84 Copy of amended Draft Memo V.40 entitled Changes accepted by Mr O Neill on 5th August 1942, Ref. AB 8/B Government Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 85 Copy of amended Draft Memo V.40 entitled Changes accepted by Mr O Neill on 5th August 1942, Ref. AB 8/B Government Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 86 Amendments made by Archbishop McQuaid to Memo V.40, Ref. AB 8/B Government Box 7, Diocesan Archives. 87Hyland and Milne, Irish Educational Documents 2, 226. 88Garvin, Preventing the Future: Why was Ireland so Poor for so Long?, 139; O Connor, A Troubled Sky: Reflections on the Irish Educational Scene. 89Garvin, Preventing the Future: Why was Ireland so Poor for so Long?, 138.