historyofeducation.eu · Journals

From exclusion to self-selection: examination of behaviour in Finnish primary and comprehensive schooling from the 1860s to the 1990s

Hannu Simola
History of Education · 2002 · 31(3) · pp. 207-226

Abstract

Introduction In his inaugural lecture at the Sorbonne in 1902, Emile Durkheim described compulsory schooling as `an initiation ceremony’ that makes of the initiate `an entirely new man’, `a man and a citizen’. Since Durkheim’s times this `extended initiation rite’, as John Boli formulated it, has developed into a fundamental societal institution promising to transform children `into modern individuals, capable of rational calculation, self-discipline, political astuteness, and religious righteousness required to make the national policy both successful and just’. Mass schooling has become the main gateway to fully authorized citizenship throughout the world. It was Michel Foucault who focused on examination as one of the main tools for this speci®c moulding and shaping work. He saw the modern school as a part of a new kind of disciplinary power deriving its historical success from the use of `hierarchical observation, normalizing judgement and their combination in a procedure that is speci®c to it, the examination’. Only by examination is it possible to qualify, to classify and to punishÐin a word, to create a new individual. The results of these countless examinations, and the di€ erent diplomas, certi®cates and reports they give rise to, dictate the recognition or denial of our access to social success and a‚uence in our `credential societies’. This article is about one speci®c form of school examinationÐconcerning pupils’ behaviour. By analysing changes in Finnish educational discourse from the beginning of mass schooling in the 1860s up to the late 1990s it is aimed to elucidate how the examination of behaviour, as one ritual among others, contributed to the construction of citizenship. The concept of examination here covers a wide range of words: evaluation, assessment, grading, marking, testing and measuring. This vast ®eld is narrowed down by focusing on what has been stated about the examination of behaviour in authoritative educational texts and in reportsÐi.e. the term and year report forms, especially Graduation Diplomas. The source material comes mainly from texts that could be characterized as `state educational discourse’: the national curricula, governmental committee reports, legislative and administrative texts, semi-o cial hand-

Power (physics)SociologyPoliticsJudgementCeremonyLawInstitutionAestheticsSocial sciencePolitical scienceHistoryPhilosophy
Open in the catalogue DOI