112 years of professional disability: an under‐examined aspect of the 1846 Education Minutes
Abstract
Grant regulations under the Education Minutes of 1846 prohibited ministers of religion teaching in aided schools. This article examines the background to this professional disability, the extent of its application and its survival for 112 years. The impact of changing social conditions and the creation of new justifications as the policy became anachronistic are discussed. The fiftieth anniversary of its abolition in 1959 allows a long view of this regulation, unjust yet remarkably resistant to change. Documentary sources, public and personal, reveal the actions of policy‐makers and concerns of groups and individuals, and expose complex issues forming the historical context of this contested aspect of teacher employment. Attention is given to the effects of central policy on individual schools and teachers at significant stages in the account. Finally, suggestions are made for further research on the employment of ordained teachers since the ban was lifted 50 years ago. Keywords: churchKay‐Shuttleworthreligious indoctrinationprofessionteacher training Notes 1Minutes, dated 25 August and 21 December 1846, in Committee of Council on Education (CCE), Minutes for 1846 (London: HMSO, 1847). The best general account is: Nancy Ball, ‘The administration of the Minutes of 1846’, Her Majesty's Inspectorate, 1839–1849 [University of Birmingham, Institute of Education, Educational Monograph 6] (London: Oliver and Boyd, 1963), 124–48. 2James Kay‐Shuttleworth, Public Education as affected by the Minutes of the Committee of Privy Council from 1846 to 1852 (London: Longman, 1853), 18. 3Frank Smith, The Life and Work of Sir James Kay‐Shuttleworth (London: Murray, 1923); D.W. Warwick, ‘Sir James Kay‐Shuttleworth (1804–1877): the genesis, development and influence of his ideas on education and teaching’ (PhD thesis, Lancaster University, 1978); R.J.W. Selleck, James Kay‐Shuttleworth: Journey of an Outsider (Ilford: Woburn, 1994). 4J.L. Alexander, ‘Collegiate Teacher Training in England and Wales: a study in the historical determinants of educational provision and practice in the mid‐nineteenth century’ (PhD thesis, University of London, 1978), 239. 5D.G. Paz, The Politics of Working‐class Education in Britain, 1830–50 (Manchester University Press, 1980), 135; J.T. Smith, Methodism and Education, 1849–1902: J.H. Rigg, Romanism, and Wesleyan Schools (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998), 17. 6D.S. Nicholas, ‘Derwent Coleridge (1800–83) and the Deacon Schoolmaster’ (PhD thesis, University of London, 2008), 153–6; 210–20; 241–2. 7Ibid., 41–75. 8Wood to Manning, [25 April 1838], in E.S. Purcell, Life of Cardinal Manning (London: Macmillan, 1896), i, 149; Wood to Newman [April 1838], Borthwick Institute, University of York, Hickleton papers, A2/42/2, f. 85. 9National Society records: Church of England Record Centre, London; St Mark's College records: University College of St Mark & St John, Plymouth. 10Barclay Fox, diary, 28 May 1842, in R.L. Brett, ed., Barclay Fox's Journal (London: Bell & Hyman, 1979), 269; William Wordsworth to Isabella Fenwick, [July 11, 1843], in A.G. Hill et al., eds, The Letters of William and Dorothy Wordsworth (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993), vii, 455–6. 11CCE, Minutes for 1843, 337–8; Minutes for 1844, ii, 599. 14 English Churchman, October 2, 1845, 633. 12S.F. Wood, ‘On attaching the middle and lower orders to the Church’, English Journal of Education, April 1843, 128. 13F.D. Maurice, Has the Church, or the State, the Power to Educate the Nation? (London: Rivington, 1839), 363. 15Phillpotts to Coleridge, January 1, 1847, in Memorials of S. Mark's College, ed. G.W. Gent (Chelsea: [The College], 1891), 52–3. 16 Woolmer's Exeter and Plymouth Gazette, 27 February 1847, 3. 18Blomfield to Henry Montagu Villiers, 5 January 1846, Lambeth Palace Library: Fulham papers, Blomfield letterbook 43, f. 261. 17 Record, September 25 and 29, October 2, 1845. 20Helmore to editor, Guardian, August 29, 1855, 660. 19James Pereiro, ‘Samuel Francis Wood: A London Tractarian’, ‘Ethos’ and the Oxford Movement (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008), 7–39. 21United Wesleyan Sub‐Committees to Lansdowne, 6 April 1847, Watchman, April 21, 1847, 187–8. 22Kay‐Shuttleworth to United Wesleyan Sub–Committees, April 7, 1847, ibid., 188. 23Ibid., 188. 24Ashley to Russell, April 8, 1847, The National Archives (TNA), Kew: Russell papers, PRO/30/22/6C, ff. 35–6. 25Hansard, Parliamentary Debates (Third Series), 91, April 19, 1847, 949–52, 983; April 23, 1289–90. 26Henry Dunn, Calm Thoughts on Recent Measures of Committee of Council on Education (London: Houlston and Stoneman, [1847]), 20–1. 28Ibid., June 11, 1847, 366; Derwent Coleridge to Phillpotts, May 15, 1847, St Mark's College archive, Plymouth: A.D. Coleridge donation: letter 18. 27 Parliamentary Debates, 93, June 7, 1847, 174–9. 29Ibid., 367. 30Ibid., 377–9. 32‘Explanatory Minute’, June 28, 1847, CCE, Minutes for 1846, i, 24. 31Second leader, The Times, June 12, 1847, 5. 33Second leader, Morning Chronicle, June 9, 1847, 4. 34TNA, ED/8/1, ‘Annual Grants: Disused forms up to 1st July 1852’, Form III: England and Wales; Form IV: Scotland. See also: ED/7, Preliminary Statements, Elementary Schools, 1846–1924, 172 boxes. 38Chester to E.A.K. Wetch, September 8, 1849, ibid., f. 190. 35Parliamentary Papers (House of Commons) 1851 XLIII (103), Education Return: Parliamentary Grants, ‘List of applications refused’, 19. 36Lingen to Joseph Fletcher HMI, April 24, 1848, TNA, ED/9/12, ‘Grants under Minutes of 1846’ (typescript copy letters), f. 76. 37Lingen to Read, August 29, 1849, ibid., f. 189. 39Lingen to R.L. Burrows, December 18, 1849, ibid., f. 214; CCE, Minutes for 1850–51, xciii–xciv. 41Report of Royal Commission (Newcastle), The State of Popular Education in England (London: HMSO, 1861), i, 278. 40Horace Mann, Census of Great Britain, 1851. Education: England and Wales; Report and Tables (London: HMSO, 1854), cxxix; CCE, Minutes for 1850–51, c–cii. 42Ibid., 671. 43 Ecclesiastical Gazette, August 14, 1855, 40. Admiral Fowler (Charles's father) lived at Walliscote, Whitchurch, near Reading. 44J.T. Smith, A Victorian Class Conflict? Schoolteaching and the Parson, Priest and Minister, 1837–1902 (Brighton: Sussex Academic Press, 2009), 55–7. 45Biographical details: Admission Register (St Mark's College archive, Plymouth); inspectors' reports, CCE, Minutes; ordination papers (diocesan record offices). 46Henry Phillpotts, Acts of the Diocesan Synod (London: Murray, 1851), 109–15. 47Christopher Wordsworth, MS draft report on St Mark's College inspection, 6 June 1850, Lambeth Palace Library: Wordsworth papers, MS 2144, ff 144–5. 48CCE, Minutes and Regulations reduced into Form of Code, 1860, 11. 49‘Revised Code’, May 9, 1862, CCE, Report for 1861–62, xxvi. 50CCE, Minutes for 1847–48, xxvi; Minutes for 1852, 37. 51 Watchman, June 1, 1870, 176. 52CCE, A New Code of Regulations, 1871 (London: HMSO, 1871), 8. 54Graves to editor, School Guardian, December 2, 1876, 813. 53 Watchman, March 22, 1876, 93–4. 55F.R. Sandford to Wesleyan Education Committee, December 6, 1876, Watchman, December 20, 1876, 411. 56Allen to editor, The Times, January 29, 1878, 11. 57‘The Code (1892)’, CCE, Report for 1891–92, 142. 58Board of Education, Code of Regulations for Public Elementary Schools, 1904, 6. 59H.W.F[awkes], ‘Interpretation of the meaning of Art. 11(d) of 1904 Code’, June 28, 1916, TNA, ED/26/3: ‘Ministers of Religion, 1916–52 (Law Section)’. 62Board of Education, Circular 986: ‘Offers of service in public elementary schools made by clerks in holy orders or regular ministers of congregations’, March 21, 1917. 60Bishop of Salisbury to Fisher, February 16; reply, February 20, 1917, TNA, ED/24/1731: ‘Ministers of Religion, 1915–30’. 61Lidgett to Fisher, March 3; Yoxall to L.A. Selby‐Bigge, March 5; Archbishop of Canterbury to Fisher, March 18, 1917, TNA, ibid. 63NW London Teachers' Association to Prime Minister, March 30, 1917, TNA, ED/24/1731: ‘Ministers of Religion, 1915–30’. 64Second leader, Times Educational Supplement, March 29, 1917, 109. 66Selby‐Bigge, ‘Admission of men in holy orders to training as teachers for continuation schools’, March 9, 1920, TNA, ED/24/1435: ‘Employment of ministers of religion as county teachers in continuation schools’. 65‘Secularisation’ is critically considered in: John Wolffe, God and Greater Britain: Religion and National Life in Britain and Ireland, 1843–1945 (London: Routledge, 1994), 255–9. 67Board of Education, Education Code for Public Elementary Schools, 1926, Grant Regulations No. 8 (Statutory Rules and Orders, 1926/856). 68Ministry of Education, Primary and Secondary Schools Regulations (Draft) (London: HMSO), March 13, 1945. 69 Parliamentary Debates (Fifth Series), 410, April 19, 1945, 376. 70‘A.A.P.’ to Chuter Ede, April 19, 1945, TNA, ED/34/16. 71Regulation 23, Minute 4, April 28, 1945, TNA, ED/190/12: ‘Primary and Secondary Schools (Grant Conditions)’. 72Ministry of Education, Primary and Secondary Schools (Grant Conditions) Regulations, 1945, Grant Regulations No. 2 (Statutory Rules and Orders, 1945/636). 73 Parliamentary Debates (Fifth Series), 411, June 11, 1945, 1342. 74Ibid., 1372. 75Association of Education Committees, Education, July 20, 1945, 124. 76Church Education League, Regulation 23: the ban on clerical teachers; what can be done (London: CEL, [31 July 1945]), 8. 77 Parliamentary Debates (Fifth Series), 414, October 18, 1945, 1468–76. 78Ibid., 1494–7. 79 Church Times, October 26, 1945, 612. 84A.C.D[awes], memorandum, March 19, 1952, ibid. 80J.A.H[udson], memorandum, December 1947, TNA, ED/262/3: ‘Ministers of Religion, 1916–52’. 81Howlett to AEC, February 1949, ibid. 82L.D. Orton, minute, October 11, 1949, ibid. 83A.C.D[awes], memorandum, February 9, 1952, ibid. 87G. Williams, Minute 4, February 1952, ibid. 85Regulation 19, Minute 2, October 1951, TNA, ED/190/12: ‘Schools Grant Regulations, 1951’ (Statutory Instrument 1951/1743). 86Minute 3, January 1952; June 1954, ibid. 88Regulation 19, Minute 5, August 1952; October 1953, ibid. 89Minute 12, March – May 1955, ibid. 90Minute 17, May 28, 1957, ibid. 91Minute 19, August 6, 1957, ibid. 92Minute 22, 8 August 1958; Minute 23, February 19, 1959, ibid. 93Ministry of Education, Schools Regulations, 1959 (Statutory Instrument, 1959/364), ‘Explanatory Note’ (c). 94 Parliamentary Debates (Fifth Series), 604, April 27, 1959, 1029–58. 95D.S. Nicholas, ‘Derwent Coleridge (1800–83) and the Deacon Schoolmaster’ (PhD thesis, University of London, 2008), 223–30. 96Free Church Federal Council, Annual Report and Directory (London: FCFC, 1963), 14. 97Table 2.3, ‘Occupations of men ordained to non‐stipendiary ministry, 1971–81’, in Mark Hodge, Non‐Stipendiary Ministry in the Church of England (London: CIO, 1983), 30.