historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Women’s work or creative work? Embroidery in New South Wales high schools

Susan Wood
History of Education · 2009 · 38(6) · pp. 779-789

Abstract

Embroidery is traditionally regarded as women’s work and the teaching of embroidery as a means of preparing young women for domesticity, a view which has been reinforced by historians studying changes in the high school art curriculum that occurred with the introduction of the Wyndham Scheme in New South Wales in the early 1960s. This paper argues that those involved in promoting and teaching embroidery in NSW high schools at that time had a different agenda. They wanted embroidery to be seen as a legitimate form of creative work. The paper considers the relationship that developed in the 1960s between the Embroiderers’ Guild of NSW and the NSW Department of Education. This relationship resulted in a series of ventures intended to promote embroidery as creative, artistic expression rather than as domestic work. The paper argues that, in this context, embroidery was a vehicle for women’s agency and self‐determination. Keywords: art educationhistorywomenembroideryAustraliaart worlds Notes 1R. Parker and G. Pollock, Old Mistresses: Women, Art and Ideology (New York: Pantheon, 1981), 58–67. 2Roszika Parker, The Subversive Stitch: Embroidery and the Making of the Feminine (London: Women’s Press, 1984). 3Parker, Subversive Stitch, 128. 4Parker, Subversive Stitch, 189. 5Penny McKeon, ‘Eighty Five Years of School Art History’, in Papers: Occasional Seminar in Art Education 7. Continuity and Change in NSW Art Education: The Reinvention of Practices and Content (Paddington: School of Art Education, COFA, UNSW, 1997), 39. 6McKeon, ‘Eighty Five Years’, 40. 7Christopher Peers, ‘A Secret Tribunal in the History of New South Wales Art Education’, Australian Art Education 23, no. 2 (2000): 9. 8Peers, ‘Secret Tribunal’, 10. 9NSW Department of Education Syllabus in Art, c.1947, quoted in Christopher Peers, ‘Mapping Art as a Matriculation Subject in New South Wales’, History of Education Review 31, no. 1 (2002): 54. 10At the Bauhaus, the renowned German art and design school that existed between 1919 and 1932, each workshop or studio was overseen by two masters – one a master of form, who provided guidance on matters of aesthetics, and the other a master of craft, whose role it was to provide technical training. It was thought that this provided a more complete education than that which could be provided by a single teacher. 13Oswald‐Jacobs, conversation with author, January 8, 2003. 11‘You Needn’t be Such a Lazy Daisy’, Sydney Morning Herald, August 11, 1960, women’s section. 12‘Students Break Away From the Traditional’, Sydney Morning Herald, September 16, 1968. 14 The Pauline, no. 59 (1963): 13. One frontal was designed by Janna Bruce (identified in The Pauline by her married name, Mrs Sowerby‐Drake) and completed in 1961. It is not clear who designed the second frontal, but as the design is sophisticated it seems likely that it was also the work of a professional artist such as Janna Bruce. 15Dorothea Allnutt, Application for Australia Council Grant, File No 73/369, Australia Council. 16‘Students Break Away’. 17Oswald‐Jacobs, conversation with author, January 8, 2003. 18 The Record 117 (1971): 9–10. 19Becker, Art Worlds (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1982). 20Babette Hayes, ‘The Craft Professionals’, Woman’s Day, December 3, 1973. 21Margaret Oppen, who initially trained as a painter, taught at the Society’s design school at Double Bay in the late 1940s. The programme, which was developed for the Society by Ann Gillmore Rees, included modern embroidery. Under Rees’s influence, Oppen began experimenting with embroidery and in 1949 her embroideries were included in an exhibition she and Ethleen Palmer held at the Grosvenor Galleries in Sydney. 22Arts and Crafts Society of NSW papers, MLMSS 3645 3(9) MLK 02077 Mitchell Library, Sydney. 23See, for example, Jean Vere’s comments in The Record 201 (1980). Pat Langford made similar comments in a conversation I had with her on 25 November 2002. 24Transcript of interview between Dr Ann Ross and Pat Langford, April 15, 1987. Embroiderers’ Guild of NSW Archive, Sydney. 25This difference in approach can perhaps be accounted for by the training undertaken by those teaching in the two systems. Needlework teachers in Department of Education schools completed their practical training at Technical Colleges, where the emphasis was on patternmaking and dressmaking skills. By contrast, private schools were free to employ teachers like Pat Langford and Dorothea Allnutt whose education and experience was broad based. 26 The Record 46 (1964): 13. 27 The Record 19 (1962): 4. 28 The Record 73 (1967): 5. 29Langford and Oppen. Paper Cuts: Designers and Embroiderers (Sydney: Ure Smith on behalf of the Embroiderers’ Guild, NSW, 1964). 30 The Record 47 (1964): 4. 31 The Record 46 (1964): 13. 32Ruby Riach, letter to author, July 15, 2005. 33 The Record 34 (1963): 15. 34I.N. Gilbert, ‘The Embroiderers’ Guild – N.S.W. Branch’, Needlework Bulletin 10 (1961): 9–10. 35I.N. Gilbert, ‘The Development of Embroidery’, Needlework Bulletin 11 (1962): 8–13. 36Pat Langford, ‘Designing for Embroidery’, Needlework Bulletin 12 (1962): 12–13. Although this article appears under I.N. Gilbert’s name, notes in the Embroiderers’ Guild archive and a comment in the next issue of the Needlework Bulletin make it clear that the article was actually prepared by Langford. 37 The Record 34 (1963): 15. 38 The Record 58 (1965): 7. 39 The Record 69 (1967): 9. 40Ibid., 11. 41 Sydney Morning Herald, November 23, 1967, women’s section. 42Parker and Pollock, Old Mistresses, 70. 43R.A. Stebbins, Amateurs, Professionals and Serious Leisure (Montreal: McGill‐Queen’s University Press, 1992). 44Ibid., 6–7. 45Conrad and Alice Oppen, conversation with author, July 22, 2004. 46Peers, ‘Mapping Art’, 64. 47Maud L. Eduards, ‘Women’s Agency and Collective Action’, Women’s Studies International Forum 17, nos 2/3 (1994): 185. 48Peers, ‘Mapping Art’, 65.

Work (physics)SociologyGender studiesWomen's workEconomic growthPolitical sciencePedagogyEngineeringEconomics
Open in the catalogue DOI