Sources as interpretation: sources in the study of education history
Abstract
Sources and interpretations With this issue we introduce a new feature to appear regularly in History of Education. A compelling aspect of education history and one that is drawing new writers and readers in the field is the increasing diversity of sources on which education historians draw. New forms of admissible evidence challenge us to adopt different approaches to analysis, while changing analytical frameworks demand the inclusion of new sources of data. Evidence and interpretation in this sense stand in a symbiotic relationship. As outlined in the editorial to this issue of the journal, this section intends to encompass critical discussion of source genres, problematics of interpretation and interpretive debates relating to individual documents, images, artefacts and sites. The ‘Sources and Interpretations’ section takes forward in some respects the work of the Journal of Sources in Educational History, which ran from 1978 to 2003 (latterly published by Taylor & Francis). The Journal of Sources stood in a tradition that might be traced back to the remarkable work of Paul Monroe and E.P. Cubberley earlier in the twentieth century and two key works by these authors constitute the sources at the centre of this first contribution to the new section. Though these scholars have subsequently been the focus of criticism and methodological debate, it will be argued here that their work is of sufficient significance and interest for the historiography of education to merit a reappraisal of their contribution to the field. Before proceeding back to the work of Monroe and Cubberley, however, a context can be set by considering the Journal of Sources in its own distinctive setting. This microfiche journal exploited a new medium in academic publishing in the 1970s to serve and promote study and research in the history of education.