historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Book reviews

Joel Barnes
History of Education Review · 2022 · 51(1) · pp. 96-98

Abstract

In recent years, a group of historians at Lund University, Sweden, has emerged as among the most active practitioners and proponents of the new and developing field of the history of knowledge.Forms of Knowledge is the group's second major English-language edited collection, following Circulation of Knowledge (Nordic Academic Press, 2018), and coincides with the formalisation of its activities as the Lund Centre for the History of Knowledge, which was established in early 2020.The collection's editors and most of its contributors are based at Lund, with the rest drawn from other Swedish and Danish universities.The history of knowledge has developed in several centres in Europe and the United States, out of and in connection with a number of other subdisciplines, including the history of science, the history of ideas, the history of the book, and cultural history.It also intersects with the similarly nascent field of the history of the humanities.As Johan € Ostling, David Larsson Heidenblad and Anna Nilsson Hammar note in the introduction to the present collection, the history of knowledge has both integrative and generative capacities, bringing scholars from various fields into dialogue in ways that cut across traditional subdisciplinary boundaries and chronological specialisms, while also generating new questions and problems.While still diverse in methods and approaches, and indeed in its conceptualisation of "knowledge", the field has in general meant a reorientation towards knowledge as an object as such, to its processes of circulation and translation, its mediality and materiality.For the history of science this means a somewhat broader object of study than that of "science"; for other fields such as traditional forms of intellectual history it means a shift away from highly textual, close reading methods and more focus upon the operation of knowledge in society and its functions in people's everyday lives.For some scholars these developments provide means of describing forms of informal, extra-institutional or historically denigrated forms of knowledge that are not well captured by traditional subdisciplines' conceptualisations of their objects.For others it represents a suite of new methods and concepts with which to approach old topics.Forms of Knowledge arrives at a time when the field is starting to move beyond initial programmatic statements and into more developed empirical studies.Its 15 short chapters cover a range of ground including the development of the category of "conventional wisdom"; the official promotion of knowledge of the potato in mid-18th-century Sweden; Aristotelian phronesis or practical knowledge gained by experience in the history of psychiatry; and the ways in which historical narratives are shaped on Wikipedia.Nordic topics predominate, but there are also chapters exploring German, Spanish, American and Ottoman histories, frequently with an emphasis on transnational connections between multiple national or imperial contexts.Often the chapters are rather too brief to do justice to their topics, and the reader is left with a sense of having glimpsed just the tip of the iceberg.Whereas Circulation of Knowledge comprised a diverse set of short studies under the banner of the concept of HER 51,

Computer science
Open in the catalogue DOI PDF