Book review: From Integration to Inclusion: A History of Special Education in the 20th Century
Abstract
Margaret A. Winzer's book, “From Integration to Inclusion: A History of Special Education in the 20th Century,” illuminates the remarkable journey of special education and disability studies throughout the 20th century. Rather than presenting a linear series of events, Winzer adopts a thematic approach, enriching readers' understanding of how evolving ideologies and philosophies catalyzed pivotal moments in special education history. This skillfully crafted narrative reveals the intricate interplay between research and practice and distinguishes effective educational interventions from unsuccessful ones.In the first chapter, Winzer provides an overview of historical perceptions of disability. She emphasizes that the essence of special education history lies in the diverse approaches civilizations across different centuries and contexts have taken toward human differences and disabilities. Interestingly, the treatment of mental illness predates the consideration of disabilities, with France leading the way in Enlightenment-era reforms, subsequently followed by Britain and America. These reforms reshaped conventional philanthropic structures, paving the way for establishing institutions dedicated to special education. However, although the Enlightenment changed the outlook toward disabled people, “the institutions served as much to separate disabled children and youth from a cruel world as to relieve the world of disabled people” (Winzer, 2009, p. 8).In Chapter Two, Winzer underscores the influence of the United States' population growth and significant immigration on the establishment of common schools. These schools, which adopted a German model of philosophy and pedagogy, aimed to educate all students, regardless of ability, with a unified focus on social and political ideology. However, many common schools struggled with remediation efforts, often viewing students with disabilities as disruptive and segregating them into separate classes. As a complement to residential schools, day schools emerged, facing their own set of challenges but achieving some degree of success. Notably, these schools transitioned from religious and evangelical control to become the responsibility of the state in the 19th century, shedding their charitable connotations. Additionally, the quest for labels in special education prompted significant changes in terminology related to disabilities and mental illness after 1880.As emerging labels for children with disabilities evolved, Winzer highlights the complex connection between feeblemindedness, immigration, intelligence testing and eugenics in Chapter Three. Linking delinquency and feeblemindedness to the immigrants reinforced ethnic and racial hatred and catalyzed the quest to improve the human race. Further, the testing movement was prominent even though it promoted seeking explanations of human differences in nature, bolstering bias against feebleminded populations who, as a result, were subjected to segregation and sterilization.The special segregated class paradigm was developed in the first half of the 20th century, as discussed in Chapter Four. Winzer investigated the circumstances that contributed to the growth of these classes. She also pays special attention to compulsory education, with many States passing legislation reinforcing special education in schools. Many children's access to school has been considerably improved by legislation requiring schools to admit exceptional students. Yet, in many jurisdictions, a disability was considered a good enough reason to keep a child out of school. Immigration also affected special education. In essence, integration or segregation was the answer to the vast immigration wave that characterized the United States in the 19th century. Furthermore, mental ability testing was pervasive, notably the use of standard IQ tests and the emergence of educational psychology.Chapter Five of the book addresses the emergence of new philosophies in the 1960s that led to more sophisticated diagnosis and instructional approaches in special education. This period saw significant social and educational changes, bolstered by the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibited discrimination based on race and national origin. The chapter focuses on the advent of normalization, which aimed to provide living conditions and educational experiences for individuals with disabilities that resembled those of their able-bodied counterparts. This philosophy sparked criticism of institutional conditions for people with disabilities and advocated for community-based settings as a more effective alternative. Notably, alongside the shift towards normalization, there was a redefinition of mild mental retardation. Subsequently, the government passed legislation, namely the Education for All Handicapped Act, reaffirming the provision of special education. This led to a wave of lawsuits aimed at securing inclusion in special education for many disabled children.Chapter Six concentrates on children and young individuals dealing with behavioral issues. Winzer delves into the historical literature surrounding behavioral deviance, discussing the various categories and labels ascribed to disabled children by the legal system until the 1950s. Industrial schools emerged during this period, aiming to provide a familial environment for these children. Alternatives to institutionalization focused on reintegrating disabled children into family settings. This shift in philosophy led to changes in the juvenile court system, which transitioned from punitive measures to protective ones for children. Consequently, social workers began focusing on rebuilding nuclear families, and the mental hygiene movement gained momentum. The remainder of the chapter elaborates on ADHD and autism as emerging behavioral and emotional disorders.Winzer gives specific attention to students with hearing impairments in Chapter Seven. She discusses the debate around oralism versus sign language instructional methodologies for deaf students and the development of Braille as a reading aid for blind students. She also highlights the journey towards gaining access to special education for students with intellectual disabilities. Additionally, she introduces students with speech impairment, health disorders and physical disabilities, albeit brief. Finally, Winzer acknowledges gifted children as understudied with regard to students with disabilities while emphasizing the importance of the emerging field of learning disabilities.In Chapter Eight, Winzer offers an overview of the historical professionalization of special education, distinct from general education. She discusses the inequalities faced by women teachers and outlines the teacher training history for educators of the deaf, blind and students with intellectual disabilities, with in-house training being popular at the time. Moreover, she touches upon the changes in teaching requirements brought about by the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) of 2001, which, while setting standards for teachers, did not define what constituted a high-quality teacher. Consequently, special education teachers took it upon themselves to establish their authority and expertise, leading to the formation of the Council for Exceptional Children.Chapter Nine concludes the discussion by highlighting the culmination of efforts towards inclusive schooling. The reform observed in general education also significantly impacted special education, driven by concerns about education outcomes and accountability. At the core of this inclusive era was the emergence of the regular education initiative aimed at eliminating barriers to the inclusion of students with disabilities. In this regard, Winzer notes the various amendments to the law pertaining to special education, crediting the NCLB for increasing students with disabilities’ chances of receiving quality education. She concludes the chapter by presenting various research methods and postmodern perspectives on disability as well as recommendations to direct researchers’ and practitioners’ efforts in the future.Finally, as the pursuit of effective interventions and practices to enhance the learning experiences of students with disabilities persists, I contend that this book is a must-read for anyone desiring comprehensive knowledge in the field. With its well-crafted arguments and thorough analysis, this book serves as a reference text for building a foundational understanding. It contains the level of detail needed for advanced master’s and doctoral students seeking a solid knowledge base in special education. Undoubtedly, Winzer made significant strides in elevating the study of special education by bringing its history to the forefront – an essential endeavor to link historical development with the dynamic innovations of the present.