From Perfection to Habit: Moral Training in the American Kindergarten, 1860-1920
Abstract
Historians agree that progressive kindergartners inspired by the child-centered psychologies of G. Stanley Hall and John Dewey initiated a critique of the Froebelian pedagogy upon which the kindergarten curriculum had been based since its introduction into the United States in the 1860s. Historians also agree that by 1920, after a long and sometimes bitter struggle, progressives emerged as victors in the battle with Froebelians for control of the curriculum. (1) What historians have not agreed upon are the social import and educational consequences of this struggle. Thus Vandewvalker, herself a progressive, argued that molding the curriculum in accordance with the child's nature, as divulged by modern biology and psychology, was the catalyst for the rapid integration of the kindergarten into the public school system after 1900. The child-centered curriculum was also the primary reason why kindergartners could boast that their institution played an important role in the urban reform movement. (2) By contrast, Marvin Lazerson, in a recent, provocative analysis of Massachusetts' kindergartens between 1870 and 1915, suggested that by the turn of the century the integration of the kindergarten into the public school system was symptomatic of a nullification of the reform ideals of early kindergarten advocates. The institutionalization of the kindergarten, the expense of implementing kindergarten programs, and the ambivalence of many progres