Toward a New Direction in Educational History: Prospect and Retrospect
Abstract
BERNARD BAILYN's famous attempt of a decade ago to redefine the scope of educational history has rightly been much applauded ever since, but it has been subjected to enough careful scrutiny. Bailyn was appalled by what he perceived to be the narrow character of educational history as it had long been written by men lacking historical vision or imagination. To counter such narrowness, he proposed, a widely quoted dictum, that one think of education not only as formal pedagogy but as the entire process by which a culture transmits itself across the generations, and that one see education in elaborate, intricate involvements with the rest of society, noting its shifting functions, meanings, and purposes. (i) When Bailyn's dictum was uttered, it sent an enormous gust of fresh air across this particular corner of the scholarly landscape. It lent encouragement to researchers who were anxious to integrate the study of educational history with all that seemed vital the social sciences. It gave important leverage to younger, more adventurous spirits who were struggling, presumably, against somnolent establishments departments of education throughout the United States. Bailyn's words seemed to carry the promise that what had hitherto been considered one of the most arid fields of inquiry might suddenly be transformed into one of the freshest and most exciting. In creating this impression, perhaps more important than anything Bailyn said was the very fact that he had taken the trouble to say it-that is, a distinguished historian had chosen bold-