historyofeducation.eu · Journals

The Bureau of Education's Suppressed Rating of Colleges, 1911-1912

David S. Webster
History of Education Quarterly · 1984 · 24(4) · pp. 499

Abstract

THE EARLIEST academic quality ranking ever discussed by those few scholars who have written comprehensive reviews of such rankings was a 1925 rating of graduate departments in 20 disciplines at American Ph.D.-granting universities. It was published by Raymond M. Hughes in 1925.' In actuality, academic quality rankings existed before then; as early as 1911, for example, the United States Bureau of Education produced one that stratified hundreds of American colleges and universities into five levels, according to their presumed However, because a storm of protest led to this work's being suppressed before it was officially published, very little is known about it. This article has three purposes. The first is to show that an academic quality ranking was produced and circulated fairly widely, even though not officially published, long before Hughes' 1925 ranking of graduate departments. The second is to tell the story, which has never been told, of the work of the United States Bureau of Education that led up to this ranking and to discuss the ranking itself. The third is to show why this seemingly innocuous classification of colleges and universities caused such fury that two presidents of the United States ordered that it not be published. Academic quality rankings are efforts to rank order or to stratify into groups or classes colleges and universities-or individual academic departments within them, like English, history, and sociology-in order of their quality. One of the most frequently used criteria for ranking or classifying institutions and academic departments over the years has been their graduates' achievements in later life, as evidenced by their incomes, occupations, or listings in publications like American Men & Women of Science and Who's Who in America. Others have included the research accomplishments of their faculty, as measured by the academic awards and honors they win and their scholarly reputations in the eyes of their peers, and these institutions' resources as measured, for example, by the number of books and journals in their libraries, the amount and quality of their laboratory equipment, and the size of their instructional budgets.

Political sciencePedagogyPsychology
Open in the catalogue DOI