The New History and French Schooling: A Response
Abstract
Let me first assure Chartier, Compere, and Julia that I read their book with care and that any differences we might have are based on more substantial considerations that inattentiveness on my part. Arguing who does or does not belong in an amorphous category is not very productive. I thought I had clearly made the point that recent trends in French historiography cannot be neatly divided up into schools and camps (p. 333). Consequently I did not pigeonhole Viguerie, and I did mention his connection with Roland Mousnier, whose interests and approach are not unrecognized. In reviewing the two books together, however, it made sense to note similarities, and both share several characteristics, including a penchant for counting. My general reaction to the other objections is that I think the authors claim too much for what they have accomplished. I stand by my statement that they were not successful in their discussion of the social origins of collegiens. They fail to demonstrate how their sample meets the requirements of statistical significance and how their conclusions are valid for the scope of their study, namely, the entirety of France over a period of three centuries. Their treatment of social class is much too rigid and historical. Unlike Viguerie-but like other sociologically inclined historians-the authors gloss over the problems involved in the apperception of social status in the past, and the assertion that their conclusions rest on a scientific basis taxes credibility. Given their doubt about my understanding of the work, I find it ironic that the authors credit me with following their demonstration and with only reorganizing their conclusions. My complaint is that the study is in general interpretively slight. The various sections may contain some conclusions, but the work as a whole lacks an adequate interpretive stance which connects the diverse elements and gives the totality cohesion and significance. In this sense, the whole is something less than the sum of the parts. Chartier, Compere, and Julia miss the point of my comment concerning the absence of movement. The issue is not whether they follow a chronological plan or plot educational changes. My remarks were aimed at their failure to offer a cogent historical account of the process of change. Allusions to the social milieu merely beg the question. What is called for is the investigation of just how contextual features influenced the nature of schooling. L'Education en France is unquestionably useful and presents a great