Sentimental Womanhood and Domestic Education, 1830-1870
Abstract
A SEXUAL IDEOLOGY with profoundly antifeminist implications developed in the northern United States during the forty years after 1830. This middle class ideal of sentimental womanhood, defining women as spiritual, emotional, and dependent, has received less attention than the ideology of the small minority of feminists and reformers who rejected a passive stereotype of women in their search for autonomy. Yet the antifeminist system of belief dominated the perception of women in the nineteenth century. It provided women with supreme domestic powers through religious influence and the education of children, though it exacted a price of powerlessness beyond these spheres. How was it that this sentimental ideal had such pervasive influence? The most common answer is that it was the result of economic change. It is argued that the American Mother-God was the direct outcome of the impact of industrialization on family structure and sex roles. In order to evaluate this argument the assumptions underlying it must be made explicit. According to the economic interpretation capitalism displaced the household as the center of the productive process, and so caused the disintegration of the extended family. Geographic mobility, accelerated by both urbanization and the rapid western movement, intensified the isolation of.the nuclear family. In the middle class, the male worked away from home, and male nature was re-defined by this new economic role. Women were deprived of any economic function; to them were consigned the humanly necessary but economically disadvantageous qualities of modesty, of delicacy, of sympathizing sensibility, of prompt and active benevolence, of warmth and tenderness of attachment. (1) There are, however, limitations to this interpretation. (2) The idea that the definitions of female nature and the home were economically functional actually depends upon assumptions about human nature; they are functional only if it is assumed that periodic refuge is a psychological neces-