Class Size and Pedagogy in Isocrates' School
Abstract
HISTORIANS OF ANCIENT EDUCATION have been speculating about the enrollment in Isocrates' school. (1) While enrollment can hardly be taken as a critical historical datum-and evidence supporting even the best opinions on the subject is not too good-these speculations may bring to light some little-known dimensions to Isocrates' basic teaching method. If Isocrates were teaching as many as o100 students a year, his pedagogy should not have been the same as if he taught only o100 students during his entire career. Freeman believes that Isocrates had a huge school attracting an annual clientele of o100 students; (2) Isocrates himself speaks of having had more pupils than all the other schools combined. (3) Marrou, on the other hand, describes the Isocratic school as an elite institution supplying an academic adventure of rare quality to carefully selected and highly motivated persons. (4) Is there any way of illuminating these divergent views since apparently they cannot be reconciled? Taking Isocrates at his word is not always satisfactory, not because he tries to mislead us, but because what he says is often ambiguous. When he said he had more students than all the other schools, he may not have meant in a single school year but for the half-century of the school's existence. When we hear that Isocrates was rich and assigned a trierarchy, it is perhaps natural to envision large numbers of students in his classrooms, for if he did not charge Athenians tuition, as pseudoPlutarch asserts in the Life of Isocrates, he must have had a foreign enrollment large enough to make his enterprise profitable and him a rich man. Demosthenes, however, states that Athenians were charged. Perhaps the misunderstanding arises from Isocrates' own comments: he says he received payments from foreigners and that his wealth came chiefly from foreign gifts. (5) He implies, though does not assert, that