Education and Professional Life Styles: Law and Medicine in the Nineteenth Century
Abstract
BY THE END of the nineteenth century a period of formal schooling had replaced apprenticeship to a practitioner as the primary method of professional training and certification for American lawyers and doctors. In their public pronouncements leaders of these professional groups gave essentially similar reasons for this important shift. Lawyers and doctors commonly urged the formation of professional schools because such institutions, they argued, would through the systematic instruction offered there inevitably raise the moral and intellectual tone of the entire profession. To group students together on a regular basis under the tutelage of the most prominent members of a profession seemed inherently superior to the apprenticeship arrangement which necessarily reflected the impact of a wide range of professional talent and ethics. Finally, some men also supported professional schools because they would provide institutional shelter to those professionals who wished to set the practice of the profession on a more scholarly basis. Doctors, however, supported the establishment of professional schools much earlier and much more vigorously than did lawyers. expansion of American medical schools dates from the 1820's while American law schools proliferated in number only after 1870. Some sense of the energy that American physicians expended in creating medical schools can be gotten from the fact that in the years 1800 to 1910 over 450 medical schools were established in this country. During that same period only 171 law schools were founded, and most of these opened after 1870. Throughout the nineteenth century existing medical schools always outnumbered law schools by at least two to one; and in most decades the figure was three or four to one. (1) Morris Fishbein has noted that The multiplication of medical schools was such that, by the end of the nineteenth century there were about as many medical schools in the United States as there were in all the rest of the world. (2)