Nicholas Murray Butler and the Teaching Profession
Abstract
It is strange that Charles W. Eliot, William Torrey Harris, and Murray Butler are so little remembered. For a generation their counsels dominated American education, yet few histories of education give them more than passing notice. Eliot does receive some attention as father of the elective principle, and Harris enjoys at least a dubious reputation as high priest of conservative idealism. Butler, if mentioned at all, appears as Harris's acolyte and is variously described as a classical humanist, an intellectualist, and an idealist with faintly liberal tendencies. It has been his misfortune to be cast in the role of educational philosopher, the role to which he aspired, but to which he could bring the least talent. Butler was an independent thinker, but not a creative one, a man of action, not of contemplation. Comparing him with Harris is like comparing Alexander with Aristotle. Nicholas Miraculous was, in truth, that rare combination of insights, practicality, and force that makes a philosopher king. Never content to contemplate ends, his vast energies were concentrated on means. He fathered organizations, not ideas. At Columbia College in the 1880's Butler came under the influence of Frederick A. P. Barnard. The vigorous old president moulded Butler's vague aspirations into a dedication to education as a career. He had long believed that education needed reforming from top to bottom, and that this could be accomplished only when it was firmly established as a science. He hoped to make Butler the instrument for this goal. He was not disappointed, at least not in the thoroughness with which his protege applied himself to the task.l