historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Response to: Nicholas Kryczka, Whitney E. Barringer, and Scot McFarlane, “Changing the Subject in the School Wars: An AHA Research Team Perspective”

Larry Cuban
History of Education Quarterly · 2025 · 65(2) · pp. 296-297

Abstract

Amid so-called culture wars, how do America's teachers teach US history?Are teachers "whitewashing history" or "brainwashing children?" Loaded as these questions are, these researchers, representing the prestigious American Historical Association, sought answers to them.They surveyed over three thousand middle and high school US history teachers in nine states (with a response rate from teachers of 13 percent).Then they interviewed over two hundred more teachers while collecting thousands of pages of actual instructional materials.But they did not observe any actual lessons.The strange upshot of the paper is that the researchers sidestepped their initial questions quoted in the opening paragraph above and instead answered a completely different one: Where do curricular decisions get made?They locate the decentralized decision-making sites in the US's system of schooling and ask how these diverse "layers of authority interacted to determine the character of instructional materials."From their survey and interviews, the researchers make five claims that emerged from their investigation.Here, the word claims could have been avoided in favor of a more straightforward one like findings.There were other examples of awkward language in the paper that often required me to reread entire paragraphs.Here are their "findings:" First, "apathy, not activism, is what many history teachers spend their time trying to overcome among students and parents Teachers we engaged with don't typically encounter politicized pressure at their job."Second, "in spite of the various efforts by state and local administrators to standardize and align instruction, history teachers retain substantial discretion over what they use in their daily work." In other words, history teachers have great autonomy in the materials they choose to teach and the methods they use to teach them.Third, even with that classroom autonomy, the researchers found:

Subject (documents)Perspective (graphical)SociologyPolitical scienceLibrary scienceArtComputer scienceVisual arts
Open in the catalogue DOI PDF