historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Abolitionists as Academics: The Controversy at Western Reserve College, 1832-1833

Lawrence B. Goodheart
History of Education Quarterly · 1982 · 22(4) · pp. 421

Abstract

DURING 1832 to 1833, the faculty and trustees of Western Reserve College in Hudson, Ohio, were embroiled in a controversy over immediate abolition. The faculty advocated immediate abolition and the establishment of biracial equality in the United States; the trustees urged gradual abolition and the colonization of freed slaves in Liberia. The controversy at Western Reserve College raises the question of why some people adopted immediate abolitionism while others of similar background remained colonizationists? Although the case of Western Reserve College provides no Rosetta Stone to unravel the mystery of motivation, there were notable differences in age, in relationship to the community, and in enthusiasm for the evangelical doctrine of the immediate repentance of sin that distinguished the main protagonists among the faculty and the trustees from one another.' The faculty were recent arrivals to the community and were a generation younger than the trustees. As young evangelicals they had been caught up in the wave of revivals that swept the North during the late 1820s and early 1830s. They were more concerned with right action, repentance, and regeneration than the trustees, who as well established leaders of the community and founders of the college highly valued stability, harmony, and consensus. The faculty adopted immediate abolition because it reaffirmed their belief in man's moral ability to free himself at once from sin even at the price of social disruption. Their more cautious elders clung to colonization because of its stress on orderly social change even if it meant tolerating sin. The faculty believed its duty was to teach the moral imperative of immediate abolition, but the trustees were alarmed that this controversial doctrine would alienate popular support from the college. The controversy became heated as the trustees sought to censor and then to oust the faculty. who all the more persisted in advocating abolitionism.2 The decision whether immediate abolitionism ought to be discussed on campus was far from being a clear-cut issue, for Western Reserve College had been founded in 1826 to provide both intellectual and moral instruction. The

Political scienceSociology
Open in the catalogue DOI