Exaggerated Estimates of Reading and Writing as Means of education (1867), by W. B. Hodgson
Abstract
William Ballantyne Hodgson stands as a typical, but also a special Victorian. His unheralded but important essay, Exaggerated Estimates of Reading and Writing as Means of Education, also combines the typical with the special. It informs our understanding of nineteenth-century attitudes toward education, adding a complexity and a critical edge usually not accorded to reformers. It also reveals a special depth to that most Victorian of obsessions: the faith in the power and efficacy of schooling for the improvement of society and of the individual within it. The document, reprinted here, not only has a historical value which should be apparent to readers, but it may also be seen as speaking to concerned persons of the late twentieth century. Hodgson is not well known among midnineteenth-century educational activists. Although he merited a full-page entry in the Dictionary of National Biography and his Life and Letters was edited in fine contemporary style by J. M. D. Meiklejohn in 1883, his name and manifold activities only occasionally appear in educational and intellectual histories of the period. In part, the typicality of his life and work accounts for this neglect. Born in 1815 in Edinburgh, Hodgson was known primarily as an educational reformer and political economist. The son, appropriately, of a working printer, he studied at Edinburgh High School and then worked for a short time in a lawyer's office. In 1829, at the age of fourteen, he matriculated at Edinburgh University, although he took no degree as a student. For several years, he was employed as a lecturer, speaking on