The Southern Progressive Educator on Race and Pluralism: The Case of William Heard Kilpatrick
Abstract
THE WORK of William Heard Kilpatrick (1871-1965) in the area of race and ethnic relations presents an opportunity to explore how one of the foremost educators of his time responded to a difficult and potentially dangerous aspect of American life. A consistent spokesman for New South approaches to racial injustice and a key member of the early intercultural education movement, he was also an influential officer of the New York Urban League in its formative years. Indeed, Kilpatrick's example as a pioneer in these affairs provides insight into the liberal pluralist outlook which came to prevail in American education for almost forty years, an outlook which only recently has come under scrutiny and criticism by scholars of race relations and ethnicity. (1) Much could be said about Kilpatrick. He lived long, moving from the confines of an essentially rural, post-Civil War, Southern environment to fashionable intellectual and educational circles in one of America's most prestigious universities and its most cosmopolitan city. This Teachers College, Columbia University, professor was a prime disciple of progressive educational pedagogy and an original member of the Social Frontier Group of social reconstructionists. Democratic in outlook and aristocratic in bearing, he was in many respects a quintessential liberal, a man so prolific and complex that he defies easy description and comparison with his peers. He will not get this comparison in the following pages. He will receive something else he deserves: a somewhat detailed look at this race relations work, a topic generally ignored by students of the progressive education movement and Kilpatrick's role in it. By way of background, two points need to be made clear at the outset. The first is that Kilpatrick's personality, southern background, sense of morality and pragmatic bent made him a cautious gradualist. Like many