John Dewey and the New Liberalism: Some Reflections and Responses
Abstract
IN RESPONSE to a series of criticisms which appeared in the Spring issue of the History of Education Quarterly, I would like to react directly to some of the more salient issues raised by my critics and at the same time suggest further areas of the Dewey legacy which might profitably be explored. M.y critics charge that I have distorted John Dewey's position in educational history by forcing him into what they assert is a bad guy perspective. They further believe that I questioned Dewey's commitment to democracy and mistook him to be advocating forcing immigrants to assimilate to AngloSaxon standards. Lastly, they claim that my assertion that Dewey, in 1918, was deeply involved in the manipulation of Polish affairs was without foundation. On the contrary, they argue Dewey was really involved in extending democratic representation within the Polish community. While in this paper I present evidence which suggests that my critics are seriously mistaken in their specific charges, I also believe that their criticisms