The Education of Elites in Modern Europe
Abstract
SEVERAL YEARS AGO, my then graduate students David O. Justice, David Kelly and I took random samples of the major biographical encyclopedias for Germany, France, England and the United States. (1) The entries we considered were those for males born 1810 to 1899, who might have reached advanced educational institutions between about 1830 and 1930. (2) What we were chiefly interested in is the level and type of education enjoyed by these eminent men; but we also looked at their fathers' occupations and at a number of other characteristics. Soon after obtaining our first set of cross-tabulations, which were done by computer, we began to simplify our categories and to drop a number of variables from consideration. We did this not only where distributions produced numbers too small to be statistically significant, but also where results seemed to us devoid of significance or distinctions hard to maintain with any consistency. Our most serious problems stemmed from the fact that we had allowed the editors of the biographical encyclopedias to define our samples. We had not confronted our sources with independently established definitions of particular elite groups, of leading entrepreneurs, for example. Of course we found the editors' definitions quite interesting in themselves; for they were surely based on more than purely personal conceptions of eminence. (3) Yet it was difficult to keep the initial selections from dominating every cross-tabulation we tried. Before these problems were adequately resolved, our research group split up. I was left with a goodly number of tables, and with a long text that advanced a few generalizations at the cost of many qualifications. In an effort to improve matters, I have since experimented with a whole series of additional simplifications and schemes of tabulation. With the help of my student, Dan Graham, I also surveyed other studies on the education of entrepreneurs and high civil servants, hoping to introduce comparative perspectives where they seemed useful. But every step I took raised new difficulties of comparability and imposed additional explanations and qualifications.